The effect of group formation and differentiated instruction in financial literacy education. Evidence from a randomized experiment.

How to cite

Iterbeke, Kaat; Witte, Kristof De; Schelfhout, Wouter; Declercq, Koen. 2018. "The effect of group formation and differentiated instruction in financial literacy education. Evidence from a randomized experiment.." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0003478. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.3478-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Kaat Iterbeke* , Kristof De Witte , Wouter Schelfhout , Koen Declercq

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0003478
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.3478-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2017-09-01 – 2018-12-31
Countries
Private
JEL codes
C93, I21, O16
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/3478

Abstract

Significant heterogeneity in financial literacy proficiency among students prevails, with an important group of the population not reaching the minimum performance level. Including differentiation practices in financial education may solve for these differences. Using two waves of a large-scale randomized experiment involving 69 schools and approximately 2,400 students, we evaluate the effect of within-class group formation and differentiated instruction on financial knowledge and behavior of eighth and ninth grade students in secondary education in the Flemish community of Belgium. Schools were randomly assigned to a control group (no financial literacy education) and treatment groups. The treatment groups received an intense four-hour financial education course which ran independently of the teacher, and where students worked together in groups of two. We examine the impact of group formation and differentiated instruction by comparing test scores of students for which teachers implemented heterogeneous group formation, homogenous group formation or homogenous group formation with differentiated instruction.

Intervention

Schools are assigned to the following four experimental conditions:
1) Control group: Students do not follow financial literacy education.
2) Treatment group 1: Students follow financial literacy education. Students complete the course in groups of two and are randomly assigned to a group (heterogeneous group formation).
3) Treatment group 2: Students follow financial literacy education. Students complete the course in groups of two and are sorted into groups according to their grade in mathematics (homogeneous group formation).
4) Treatment group 3: Students follow financial literacy education. Students complete the course in groups of two and are sorted into groups according to their grade in mathematics. For the groups where students have low or medium grades in mathematics, additional instructions are provided (homogeneous group formation with differentiated instruction).

Experimental design

Schools were randomized to the aforementioned four experimental conditions. We measured the level of financial literacy proficiency before and after students followed the course. Students who were assigned to the control group completed the same tests at the same time as students in the treatment groups. The experiment was conducted in two separate waves. In the first wave, students in eighth grade (average age 13-14) participated in the experiment. In the second wave, students in ninth grade (average age 14-15) followed the exact same course and completed the same questionnaires.

Design details

Randomization method
Schools were randomly assigned to the different experimental conditions by a random number generator in Stata.
Randomization unit
In both waves, we randomized at the school level. All pupils and teachers in the same school were assigned to the same condition. In this way, all teachers in the same school received the same teaching material and instructions. This minimizes the possibility of spill-over effects and contamination of the different experimental conditions.
Clusters
We report the actual number of participating students and schools, for which we have observations for both the pretest and the posttest. This sample will also be used for the calculation of the minimal detectable effect size. Wave 1: 43 schools Wave 2: 26 schools
Observations
Wave 1: 1,896 pupils Wave 2: 511 pupils
Arms
Wave 1: eighth grade Control group = 739 pupils, 13 schools Treatment group 1 = 400 pupils, 9 schools Treatment group 2 = 349 pupils, 9 schools Treatment group 3 = 408 pupils, 12 schools Wave 2: ninth grade Control group = 111 pupils, 5 schools Treatment group 1 = 161 pupils, 7 schools Treatment group 2 = 148 pupils, 10 schools Treatment group 3 = 91 pupils, 4 schools Total sample Control group = 850 pupils, 18 schools Treatment group 1 = 561 pupils, 16 schools Treatment group 2 = 497 pupils, 19 schools Treatment group 3 = 499 pupils, 16 schools Average number of schools per condition = 17.3 Average number of pupils per condition = 601.8 Average number of pupils per school = 34.9
Primary outcomes
We measure financial literacy proficiency by means of a test that contains 13 questions, covering both financial knowledge and financial behavior.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords