Climate Levy, Informational Messages, Acceptability, and Treatment Effects of Framing Effectiveness and Earmarking (CLIMATEFEE)
How to cite
Carattini, Stefano; Kallbekken, Steffen; Cherry, Todd; Chatterjee, Anomitro. 2018. "Climate Levy, Informational Messages, Acceptability, and Treatment Effects of Framing Effectiveness and Earmarking (CLIMATEFEE)." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0003476. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.3476-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
There is a general consensus among economists that carbon pricing represents the most cost-effective way to tackle climate change. Yet, only a relatively limited number of jurisdictions have implemented either a carbon tax or a carbon trading scheme. Most often, the main barrier to the implementation of carbon taxes is lack of public support. The literature in economics and other disciplines has pointed to information asymmetries driving this shortfall in public support. People tend to underestimate the benefits of carbon taxes and their incentive effect, and overestimate their drawbacks. Since people underestimate the effectiveness of carbon taxes, earmarking revenues for additional abatement tends to be relatively popular. Public ballots on carbon taxes are rare. We are aware of only three instances in which people voted on a carbon tax: in 2000 and 2015 (both times in Switzerland) and in 2016 (in Washington State). Inference in the literature is based on population surveys or lab experiments. No carbon tax has so far been accepted at the ballot box. In November 2018, for the second time in two years, the population of Washington State will be asked to vote on a carbon tax proposal (Initiative 1631). We plan to combine a population survey, measuring people’s preferences for the 2016 and 2018 carbon tax designs, with field interventions, providing valuable information about the functioning of carbon taxes and the design of Initiative 1631 to a randomly selected number of precincts.
Intervention
Potential voters in randomly-selected precincts in Washington State are exposed to informational ads providing details about the functioning of carbon taxes and the design of Initiative 1631, the proposal on the ballot box in 2018. The 2016 and 2018 designs are also compared. Potential voters clicking on the ads are asked to fill a survey. The survey to which potential voters are redirected provide information consistent with the ad that they were exposed to. The experiment will be supplemented with data from a statewide survey of voters, administered by a professional marketing company. This will provide additional evidence, based on stated preferences and reported behavior, and will also allow us to test the external validity of the field experiment.
A statewide survey of voters, administered by a professional marketing company, is used to provide additional evidence, based on stated preferences and reported behavior, and to test the external validity of the main intervention.
Experimental design
Potential voters will be approached through online advertisement. Potential voters will be exposed to different informational treatments about carbon taxes and Initiative 1631. Information consistent with the treatments in the ads will be provided on the surveys, for the individuals who click on the online ads. For these individuals, additional variables will be gathered through an online survey. To supplement this, an identical online survey will be administered, by a professional marketing firm, to a representative sample of Washington State voters. Follow-up surveys may be administered after the ballot.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.