Identity and Choice Under Risk

How to cite

D'Acunto, Francesco. 2018. "Identity and Choice Under Risk." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0003438. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.3438-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Francesco D'Acunto*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0003438
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.3438-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2012-01-15 – 2016-11-15
Countries
United States of America ()
JEL codes
C91, D03, J16, Z13
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/3438

Abstract

Preferences and beliefs vary systematically across space, gender, and age. In the context of non-competitive choice under risk, men take on more risk than women. Researchers have shown biological characteristics help explain this fact. Cultural factors may additionally contribute to an explanation, whether consistent with expected utility theory or not. Other characteristics that correlate with gender are a third potential explanation.

This project builds on identity theory to derive a set of predictions that constitute a theory of choice under risk. Identity theory posits that individuals commit to several role identities, each prescribing norms of behavior that are common knowledge in society. Individuals conform their choices to these norms of behavior to verify their identity. Verifying a role-based identity ``means engaging in the behavioral requirements of the role, that is, enacting behavior consistent with the role'' (Burke, 1991). Identity verification increases individuals' (self-)utility, whereas incongruence to one's identity reduces (self-)utility. In this setting, maintaining self-views involves trading off costs and benefits. In the context of gender identity, male identity verification affects men's utility more than female identity verification affects women's utility, because ``manhood, in contrast to womenhood, is seen as a precarious state requiring continual social proof and validation" (Vadello et al., 2008).

Individuals commit to several identities based on their societal roles, but they conform to the norms prescribed by their role identity that is most salient based on the situation or decision frame. Thus a basic prediction of identity theory for choice under risk is that men whose male identity is salient should make riskier choices, because male identity prescribes risky and aggressive norms of behavior. Moreover, this framework supports both conformity and overcompensation in choice -- men should take on more risk not only when their identity is primed, but also when it is threatened, because in both cases, conforming to male-identity norms allows identity verification.

Identity theory also has a set of unique predictions on choice under risk. First, the effects of identity salience on decision-making should involve a beliefs channel -- motivated beliefs arise to allow men taking more risk than would otherwise be warranted based on their risk preferences and known objective probability of success in risky outcomes. Second, any identity that prescribes the same normative behaviors as male identity should affect decisions under risk similarly as male identity. Third, identity should affect choice under risk similarly for positive and negative net present value (NPV) risky opportunities, which might contribute to explain why risk averse agent invest in negative NPV projects. Fourth, identity should affect direct and delegated choices under risk similarly. Finally, the effects of identity on choice should vary with the commitment of individuals to social identity and its norms. Systematic variation in commitment to identity across space and cohorts should therefore predict the size of the effect of the same identity shock on choice under risk of different individuals.

Intervention

Intervention 1: salience of gender identity for male and female subjects
Intervention 2: threatening of gender identity for male and female subjects

Experimental design

This trial consists of 5 artefactual field experiments run on the online platform Amazon Mechanical Turk (mTurk). The aim of the trial is to manipulate the salience of gender identity cues in subjects so as to test the predictions of identity theory on choice under risk.

The subject pool is restricted to mTurk Workers with a US tax identification number and who have been reviewed positively Requesters in at least 95% of the tasks they completed on mTurk. At sign up, subjects answer a few demographic questions, which include the country of residence to verify the US restriction is works.

Experiment 1 and Experiment 3 have a within-subject design. The experimental procedure consists of three steps. In the first step, subjects' risk tolerance is elicited using lottery choices a la Holt and Laury (2002). In the second step, subjects face the experimental manipulations. The design is a 2 (male, female) X 3 (control state, priming state, threatening state) experimental design. After facing the manipulations, which consist in reading online blog excerpts that include gender identity role cues, subjects recall and describe in detail in a short essay (5-10 sentences) a situation in which they behaved in line with the blog description. The content of the short essays is used to (i) verify subjects are not automated bots, and (ii) provide a manipulation check for the experimental procedure. In the third step, risk tolerance is elicited again at the subject level.

Experiment 2, Experiment 4, and Experiment 5 have a between-subject design. The experimental procedure consists of two steps -- exposure to the experimental manipulations and performance of a set of choices. In Experiment 2, the design is a 2X3 factorial design as discussed above. The choices aim to elicit subjects' own beliefs about winning if they take part in a lottery whose objective probabilities of winning are common knowledge. In Experiment 4, the design is a 2X3 factorial design, but the two treatment states are both priming states. Choices here are framed as investment games a la Gneezy and Potters (2009) with varying levels of risk and expected value. In Experiment 5, the design is a 2 (male, female) X 2 (control, priming) factorial design. Choices are also investment games a la Gneezy and Potters (2009) but framed as delegated investment opportunities.

At the end of each experiment, subjects face a debriefing procedure, obtain their payment, which include a fixed and a random component based on luck that guarantees choices throughout the experiments are incentive compatible. No subjects are recruited to take part in more than one experiment.

Design details

Randomization method
Across all 5 experiments, randomization is performed by a random generating process embedded in the survey platform used to administer the intervention (Qualtrics).
Randomization unit
The randomization unit is the individual
Clusters
Experiment 1: 300 Experiment 2: 300 Experiment 3: 300 Experiment 4: 200 Experiment 5: 200
Observations
Experiment 1: 300 Experiment 2: 300 Experiment 3: 300 Experiment 4: 200 Experiment 5: 200
Arms
Experiment 1: 120 control, 120 priming, 60 threatening Experiment 2: 100 control, 100 priming, 100 threatening Experiment 3: 100 control, 100 priming, 100 threatening Experiment 4: 70 control, 65 priming 1, 65 priming 2 Experiment 5: 100 control, 100 threatening
Primary outcomes
Change in Risk Tolerance within subject, Better-than-average-beliefs measure (see description in "Intervention"), Decision to Invest in Risky opportunities (extensive margin), Amount of experimental dollars invested in the Risky opportunities (intensive margin).

Papers from this trial

  1. D'Acunto, F. 2018. Identity and Choice Under Risk. Working Paper https://www.dropbox.com/s/10favphw8ffsekn/Identity_Oct2018_complete.pdf?dl=0

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords