Financial Education vs. Access to Finance in Transnational Households
How to cite
Yang, Dean; Abarcar, Paolo; Barua, Rashmi. 2014. "Financial Education vs. Access to Finance in Transnational Households." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0000342. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.342-4.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
The potential of international migration to provide immediate and large income gains to migrant households have generated interest in programs that can enhance its development impacts. We compare the impact of financial education with that of access to financial services and products, and measure complementarities between the two programs. The study population comprises of households in Cabanatuan, Philippines with a family member abroad. To establish a causal effect, we use random assignment of households to financial education sessions or access to financial services or both. The outcomes of interest are variables related to long-term financial security of transnational households where the migrant workers are mostly female. These include formal saving, remittance expenditures, borrowings, wages and entrepreneurial activities.
Intervention
Individuals who are more able and self-motivated enough to enroll in financial literacy training are also more likely to make sound financial choices. There is an obvious selection bias if those with high levels of financial literacy are different than those with low levels of financial literacy. OLS estimates of the effect of financial literacy on financial decisions and outcomes would be biased as we might end up attributing differences in savings levels to unobserved differences rather than financial literacy. For instance, Meier & Sprenger (2008) show that individual time preference may explain who chooses to become financially literate. At the same time, discount rates are an important determinant of individual saving patterns as a person with a high discount rate would place lower value on future rewards. If we do not control for this unobserved heterogeneity in time preferences across individuals, we will get biased estimates.
In order to establish a causal effect, our study uses random assignment of transnational households to financial literacy training. We seek to evaluate the effect of a financial literacy program and access to financial services.
Filipino overseas workers and their families are our target population. The Philippines is the second largest migrant-sending country and the third largest remittance receiving country in the world. The concentration of Filipino women as international migrants is striking; 87% of international migrants in the services sector from the Philippines in 2010 were women. Among these, 70% were domestic workers.
Experimental design
The IPA survey team will administer a baseline survey to consenting migrant households upon locating them using the contact information provided by OWWA or through the door-to-door campaign. Migrants at this point will most likely be already abroad. We interview the household head among remaining household members.
The study sample will then be randomly subdivided into different treatment conditions on-site. First, households will be randomized into either a financial education treatment, or into a group that receives no financial education at all. Second, households will be independently cross-randomized into being offered access to formal credit, insurance, and savings products, or into a group that is not offered financial access. This will generate four treatment conditions with 450 households in each. The chart below maps the four groups:
Treatment 0 (control group): This is the control condition: No offer of financial education program and/or financial services. The sealed envelope will merely contain a “thank you” letter for participating in the baseline survey.
Treatment 1: Invitation to attend a financial education program: The household head will be invited to attend a short workshop on financial education in ASKI’s training center. The workshop will be free and will be scheduled on a Saturday. It will last 6-8 hours and will be completed in one day. To facilitate take-up, the household head will be allowed to bring a companion. A letter will provide details and will ask the household head to indicate interest in the program. OWWA will also provide a letter endorsing participation in the financial education program, which we expect to raise take-up.
Treatment 2: Access to financial services and products: This treatment group will only be provided access to financial services and products and will not be offered any form of financial literacy training. In particular, they will be invited to avail of 4 different products:
1. A BPI Savings Account – a regular savings account with low required maintaining balance, which can be used to receive remittances from migrant members abroad.
2. ASKI microloan – a small loan for enterprise development.
3. ASKI micro-insurance - accident or property insurance. Accident insurance covers losses caused by accidental death or bodily injury due to accident occurring in any place in the world. Property insurance covers property damage resulting from a peril.
Households in this treatment group will be provided with a letter that specifies requirements, and would indicate instructions from where and how they can avail of the products in addition to specifying a contact person to talk to. In addition, the surveyors will offer households immediate registration for a ASKI micro-insurance product, should they wish to register on the spot.
Treatment 3: Invitation to a financial education program and access to BPI Financial services and ASKI microloan facilities: This treatment group will be invited to attend both a financial education workshop and given access to financial services offered by BPI and ASKI, as in households in treatment groups 1 and 2.
The offer to attend a financial education program and to avail of financial products constitutes an encouragement design, since in practice we cannot prevent migrants and households from accessing these services independently. That said, past research (Ashraf, Aycinena, Martinez & Yang 2011) shows that mere offers and assistance with opening bank accounts lead to large differences in bank account usage in transnational households. Doi, McKenzie, and Zia (2012) find that attendance rates for financial literacy training in Indonesia have a high take-up rate when offered for free and done in coordination with accredited recruitment agencies, even when the training is done separately for migrant workers and family members. Their experiment involved assigning migrants to a migrant-only training group, a family member-only training group, and a joint training group. The take-up rates were 81.2 percent, 76.5 percent, and 65 percent respectively. We expect our offers to be similarly effective, as the government endorses it.
Design details
Papers from this trial
- Abarcar, Paolo, Rashmi Barua, and Dean Yang. "Financial Education and Financial Access for Transnational Households: Field Experimental Evidence from the Philippines" Working Paper, April 2017 http://sites.lsa.umich.edu/deanyang/wp-content/uploads/sites/205/2016/09/abarcar-barua-yang-financial-education-financial-access.pdf
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.