Judicial Decisions as Public Goods
How to cite
Harris, J. Andrew. 2018. "Judicial Decisions as Public Goods." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0003389. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.3389-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
How can judicial decision-making and legal processes be improved? Judicial decisions are a public good vulnerable to underinvestment by judges, thus eroding the rule of law and delegitimizing the state’s enforcement institutions. Evidence of such problems exists in Kenyan magistrates’ courts, an ideal context for understanding the malfunctioning of judicial processes. We propose two interventions, creating public scrutiny of magistrates via courtroom monitors and providing administrative support for magistrates via case clerks, designed to improve the quality and efficiency of Kenyan magistrates courts.
Intervention
We propose two interventions to improve case disposition and outcomes: courtroom monitoring and case clerking.
Courtroom Monitoring: Simply watching a public proceeding may improve the quality of that proceeding. This intervention will assign one courtroom monitor to attend all portions of a randomly selected court case. At the first meeting for the case, the monitor will introduce herself to the magistrate and the advocates present. During the trial, the monitor will follow the proceeding, compiling two kinds of information. First, she will fill out an app-based questionnaire on procedural aspects of the trial like witnesses called, cross-examination, and sentencing mitigation statements. Second, she will record outcome information like length of trial, verdict, and sentence/fine.
Magistrates' case clerks: Clerks will be randomly assigned to magistrates for several months, working with the magistrate to produce judgments for cases that magistrate is working on. Case clerks reduce the administrative and research costs related to the composition of a legal judgment by providing support on the recording of evidence, legal research, and drafting of judgment language. In this implementation, clerks will be hired from the class of graduating law students and trained on judgment writing, legal research, and sentencing guidelines prior to their first case assignment.
Experimental design
The experimental design features two parallel experiments, one for each intervention. The case observation intervention will focus on four case types, effectively blocking on case type: “running down” (personal injury), sexual offenses, grievous bodily harm, and succession. Cases will be assigned to treatment sequentially, as the case enters the court registry system, via an app-based randomization tool, into one of three groups: out of sample, observed case, and unobserved case. If "out of sample", no followup of the case or data collection will be performed. If "observed", the case will be followed across its lifecycle by an observer who will collect relevant procedural and outcome data. If "unobserved", no observer will be present in the courtroom, but procedural and outcome data will be culled from administrative records about the case. The clerk intervention will randomly assign clerks to magistrates for a period of 3 months (one quarter). During that period, the clerk will assist the magistrate on case summary and judgment writing.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.