Are Parenting Interventions Transferable Across Settings? Evaluating Key Constraints in Sub-Saharan Africa
How to cite
Lichand, Guilherme; Wolf, Sharon. 2018. "Are Parenting Interventions Transferable Across Settings? Evaluating Key Constraints in Sub-Saharan Africa." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0003385. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.3385-2.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
While evidence from Brazil suggests that SMS messages to nudge parents’ engagement in their children’s education have large effects on educational outcomes, such an intervention might not work as intended in poorer settings, for at least two reasons: parents have a much higher likelihood of being illiterate – such that text-based interventions may fail to induce behavior change –, and teachers have less formal training and a much higher probability of being absent from schools – such that learning outcomes may not improve even if student’s attendance increases. This paper investigates whether those reasons are critical constraints for transferring the intervention across settings, in the context of Ivory Coast, by randomly assigning whether parents receive nudges over text or voice messages, and by cross-randomizing nudges across parents and teachers.
Intervention
The intervention, which has been designed and will be implemented by MGov and the Ministry of Education of Côte d’Ivoire, will randomly assign students’ parents and teachers to receive messages by the schools and by MGov. In particular, parents will be assigned to one of three treatment groups:
1. An “audio treatment”, in which parents will receive in the form of audio messages: (i) up to one message per week sent by school to parents about students’ attendance or performance, and (ii) two messages per week sent by MGov, as nudges, where parents will receive suggestions of simple activities that aid in social-emotional development, and which do not demand any curricular knowledge.
2. A text treatment in which the same information will be provided in the form of a message over SMS,
3. A control group, in which parents will not receive any message.
Additionally, teachers will also be assigned to one of two treatment groups:
1. A text treatment in which they will receive weekly messages over SMS with tips on activities to do with students and way to customize their classes to increase children’s learning,
2. A control condition, in which they will not receive any message from the platform.
Experimental design
The intervention will be evaluated through a school-randomized control trial with 100 schools in 2 regions in Côte d’Ivoire. In order to minimize spillovers, randomization will be done at the school level, which will be assigned to one of six treatment groups.
Cell 1: No communication with either parents or teachers
Cell 2: Communication with teachers but not with parents
Cell 3: Communication with parents (via text messages), but not with teachers
Cell 4: Communication with parents (via audio messages), but not with teachers
Cell 5: Communication with parents (via text messages) and with teachers
Cell 6: Communication with parents (via audio messages) and with teachers
Sample design is as follows:
Cell 1: 25 schools - 50 teachers + 5000 students (625 direct assessments)
Cell 2: 25 schools - 50 teachers + 5000 students (625 direct assessments)
Cell 3: 12 schools - 24 teachers + 2400 students (300 direct assessments)
Cell 4: 12 schools - 24 teachers + 2400 students (300 direct assessments)
Cell 5: 13 schools - 26 teachers + 2600 students (325 direct assessments)
Cell 6: 13 schools - 26 teachers + 2600 students (325 direct assessments)
We will use administrative data on test scores (if made available), attendance, and drop-out rates, as well as primary data collected through surveys with parents, teachers and head teachers, and direct assessments with students. Specifically, data collection will occur through: (i) direct child assessments administered in schools, with 25 randomly chosen students per school, (ii) surveys with teachers and head teachers administered in school, and (iii) directly administered surveys with caregivers in their home. This will occur at two time-points: baseline (October 2018 for parents, when assessors will already be going to communities for program enrolment, and October 2018 for children and teachers, during the first month of school), and follow up (June-July 2019, at the end of the school year). Finally, we will also administer a head-teacher survey at baseline, to assess school characteristics that may serve as barriers or supports for the successful implementation of the program.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.