The Effects of a Supported Employment Program for Disability Insurance Recipients with Mental Health Conditions: A Randomized Controlled Trial Evaluation
How to cite
Tojerow, Ilan; Fontenay, Sébastien. 2018. "The Effects of a Supported Employment Program for Disability Insurance Recipients with Mental Health Conditions: A Randomized Controlled Trial Evaluation." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0003378. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.3378-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
The share of Disability Insurance (DI) recipients with a mental health condition has increased substantially over the last decades in many OECD countries. In Belgium, they have come to represent 35% of all beneficiaries.
Previous research has shown that many DI recipients retain considerable capacity to carry on economic activities, paving the way for programs aimed at labour market reintegration. In this study, we evaluate the effects of an innovative employment support program aimed at those beneficiaries with mental disorder.
Job coaches help DI beneficiaries to find and retain a job that fits their mental health condition. The program includes counselling during the job-searching phase, as well as continuous coaching after a job has been found. The job coaches work closely together with regular doctors to ensure a long lasting reintegration into the labour market.
Using a Randomized Control Trial, we evaluate the effects of this program in the Belgian labour market. We complement the existing studies by considering short and long-term effects but also by looking into the quality of jobs and the potential household spillovers.
Intervention
Previous studies have shown that Disability Insurance (DI) beneficiaries may have substantial remaining capacity to work (Bound, 1989; French & Song, 2014; Maestas, Mullen, & Strand, 2013). This motivated social security administrations to implement Active Labour Market Policies that encourage DI beneficiaries to return to work.
In this study, we evaluate the effects of an innovative employment support program aimed at DI beneficiaries with a mental condition. The program is based on the “Individual Placement and Support” (IPS) model (treatment condition). We compare this new program with traditional rehabilitation services based on vocational training (control condition).
Vocational training has been traditionally favoured to help DI beneficiaries to return to work. It relies on the assumption that DI recipients should first rebuild a working capacity and afterwards reintegrate the job market. This approach is often called “train-then-place”. In Belgium, it is managed by the public employment centres since 2012. The program includes three phases supervised by employment specialists: 1) assessment of an individual’s rehabilitation needs, 2) vocational training, and finally 3) job search counselling. The whole process might be quite lengthy (in Belgium, it spans on average a period of 12 months, with trainings of about 6 months).
The IPS model of supported employment proposes to inverse this traditional "train-then-place" approach with a "place-then-train" approach that should favour quick insertion into the labour market and afterwards, if necessary, on-the-job training. The program relies on job coaches who help DI beneficiaries to find and retain a job that fits their mental health condition.The IPS model is based on several principles (R. Drake, Bond, & Becker, 2012), including:
- “rapid job search” (i.e. participants should quickly have face-to-face contacts with potential employers);
- “competitive employment” (i.e. no sheltered or voluntary work);
- “follow-along support” (i.e. continuous coaching, even after a job has been found);
- “integrated services” (i.e. job coaches work closely with mental healthcare specialists).
Experimental design
Doctors of the healthcare funds select participants that (1) suffer from moderate-to-severe mental illness and (2) are willing to reintegrate the labour market. After they have given their informed consent, their file is sent to the disability insurance agency. Relevant information is then transmitted to the researchers: individual characteristics (gender and work experience) used for the stratified randomization, as well as names and contact details for the follow-up surveys.
The researchers allocate participants to the IPS or control group using the randomization list of the correct stratum. The result of the allocation is communicated to the disability insurance agency in a password-protected file sent by email. Participants are then invited to a job centre of the region where they live (Job centres in Belgium are a regional competency, supervised in Flanders by the VDAB, in Brussels by Actiris and in Wallonia by the Forem).
Three actors will be in contact with the participants during all the study period: healthcare fund doctors, job centres’ workers and IPS job coaches (only for the treatment group). The allocation sequence will be concealed from them, as well as from the disability insurance agency.
However, blinding the professionals for the randomization result is impossible. Indeed, the IPS program relies on close communication between health and employment specialists. Therefore, they will all be aware of the allocation of a participant to the intervention group. Doctors of the healthcare fund will also know about the control group allocation, as they need to sign a specific document to start the traditional vocational rehabilitation and send it to the disability insurance agency.
On the other hand, participants will ignore in which group they have been allocated (treatment or control). Professionals are instructed to communicate only about the program chosen for the participant and never disclose information about the other program.
The research team is responsible for the randomization and will therefore not be blinded. However, they will never enter directly in contact with the participants who answer the surveys at home (online or in paper form) or in their job centre (online).
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.