Vocational Training and Youth Outcomes: Evidence from Nepal

How to cite

Nikolov, Plamen; Chakravarty, S.; Lundberg, Mattias. 2018. "Vocational Training and Youth Outcomes: Evidence from Nepal." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0003369. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.3369-3.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Plamen Nikolov* , S. Chakravarty , Mattias Lundberg

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0003369
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.3369-3.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2010-02-22 – 2013-03-31
Countries
Nepal (South Asia)
JEL codes
I21, I28, I38, J08, J24, O15
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/3369

Abstract

Lack of skills is arguably one of the most important determinants for high levels of unemployment and poverty. Targeting youth unemployment and also important because of its strong influence on other important social outcomes. Using a experimental design based on an admission cutoff, we examine the employment effects of a vocational training program in Nepal launched in 2009 over a three-year period.

Intervention

Admission to the program was based on a calculated score for each applicant and coupled with a course-specific threshold score. For each course, applicants with scores above the threshold were assigned to the training program, whereas applicants whose scores fell below the threshold were not assigned to the program. To form a sufficiently large quasi-experimental control group, training providers were advised to shortlist at least 50 percent more candidates than the number of spaces available in the training event. The assignment procedure followed streamlined guidelines, including a detailed scoring rubric, instructions for ranking the shortlisted candidates by score, and selecting the top-scoring candidates for admission to the program.

The individual score used in ranking candidates consisted of five sub-scores based on: (a) applicants’ trade-specific education (prerequisite, 15 points) , (b) applicants’ economic status (up to 20 points), (c) applicants’ social caste, gender, and special circumstances (up to 25 points), (d) development status of applicants’ district of origin (up to 10 points), and (e) a score determined by a selection committee during an interview procedure (up to 30 points). Sub-scores for the first four components were determined based on the information each applicant provided in his or her application form. The application form lists the exact questions upon which the distribution of scores was based. Based on the aggregated four-component score, candidates were short-listed and invited for an interview. The fifth sub-score was determined based on an interview with a three- to five-member committee comprised of representatives from the training institution and potential employers. Moreover, representatives of the survey firm and/or the donor institutions (e.g., EF, World Bank, etc.) were usually present to observe the procedure. The selection committee jointly decided on the fifth sub-score by assessing the candidate’s commitment, motivation, attitude, aptitude, and clear vision for employment and enterprising. Eventually, the selection procedure yielded a total score for each individual by summing across the five components. Possible total scores ranged from 0 to 100.

Experimental design

Admission to the program was based on a calculated score for each applicant and coupled with a course-specific threshold score. For each course, applicants with scores above the threshold were assigned to the training program, whereas applicants whose scores fell below the threshold were not assigned to the program. To form a sufficiently large quasi-experimental control group, training providers were advised to shortlist at least 50 percent more candidates than the number of spaces available in the training event. The assignment procedure followed streamlined guidelines, including a detailed scoring rubric, instructions for ranking the shortlisted candidates by score, and selecting the top-scoring candidates for admission to the program.

The individual score used in ranking candidates consisted of five sub-scores based on: (a) applicants’ trade-specific education (prerequisite, 15 points) , (b) applicants’ economic status (up to 20 points), (c) applicants’ social caste, gender, and special circumstances (up to 25 points), (d) development status of applicants’ district of origin (up to 10 points), and (e) a score determined by a selection committee during an interview procedure (up to 30 points). Sub-scores for the first four components were determined based on the information each applicant provided in his or her application form. The application form lists the exact questions upon which the distribution of scores was based. Based on the aggregated four-component score, candidates were short-listed and invited for an interview. The fifth sub-score was determined based on an interview with a three- to five-member committee comprised of representatives from the training institution and potential employers. Moreover, representatives of the survey firm and/or the donor institutions (e.g., EF, World Bank, etc.) were usually present to observe the procedure. The selection committee jointly decided on the fifth sub-score by assessing the candidate’s commitment, motivation, attitude, aptitude, and clear vision for employment and enterprising. Eventually, the selection procedure yielded a total score for each individual by summing across the five components. Possible total scores ranged from 0 to 100.

Design details

Randomization method
Office by a computer
Randomization unit
individuals
Clusters
5000 individuals
Observations
5000
Arms
200 training events in treatment arm and approximately the same number in control group.
Primary outcomes
employment outcomes self-employment outcomes non-cognitive outcomes and attitudes entrepreneurship outcomes fertility outcomes educational attainment outcomes marital aspirations outcomes

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords