Effects of Female-Targeted Cash Transfers on Experimental Measures of Agency in Household Decision-Making

How to cite

Bakhtiar, M. Mehrab; Papineni, Sreelakshmi; Leonard, Kenneth; Goldstein, Markus; Fafchamps, Marcel; Bastian, Gautam. 2018. "Effects of Female-Targeted Cash Transfers on Experimental Measures of Agency in Household Decision-Making." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0003360. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.3360-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

M. Mehrab Bakhtiar* , Sreelakshmi Papineni , Kenneth Leonard , Markus Goldstein , Marcel Fafchamps , Gautam Bastian

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0003360
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.3360-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2015-04-01 – 2018-07-29
Countries
Nigeria (Kebbi)
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/3360

Abstract

We detail the design of lab-in-the-field experiments that have been carried out on married couples in two rural locations of northern Nigeria. We measure women’s (as well as men’s) agency in household decision-making in different decision domains which include the choice of gender-specific privately consumed goods and household public goods as well as money allocation decisions between self and spouse. We also consider the choice of food and drinks for immediate consumption within the experimental session. Our main experimental measure of agency is the propensity to not defer decision-making to one’s spouse (in the absence of any communication). We also investigate other potential measures of agency: propensity to make a suggestion to one’s spouse that is closer to own preferences, the likelihood to not revise earlier stated allocation decision after receiving communication from spouses, etc. By varying whether participants’ decisions (such as those mentioned above) can be observed by their spouses, we measure whether there is a demand for agency in the absence of spousal observation versus an ability to actually exercise one’s agency in household decision-making when decisions are observed by one’s spouse. Combined with data from a 15-month-long unconditional cash transfer (UCT) program which was targeted at women and carried out as a Randomized Control Trial, these lab experiments in the field, additionally, can provide evidence on the potential impact of receiving an UCT on women’s agency in household decision-making, one year after the UCT program ended. We hypothesize that UCT-receiving women will exhibit higher agency according to these experimental measures than non-recipients. Some likely channels include greater experience dealing with cash as well as higher involvement with income generating activities.

Intervention

Villages were randomly assigned to become either a (pure) UCT village or a (Program+UCT) village. In both types of villages, eligible households were randomized into receiving or not receiving the UCT. However, in (Program+UCT) villages, all eligible households had access to most of the program components, which included nutrition messages, savings groups, farmer’s groups, etc.

We carried out lab experiments in the field on a subset of this impact evaluation sample which consists of 503 households, with 251 households that did not receive a UCT and 252 households that did.

Experimental design

Villages were randomly assigned to become either a (pure) UCT village or a (Program+UCT) village. In both types of villages, eligible households were randomized into receiving or not receiving the UCT. However, in (Program+UCT) villages, all eligible households had access to most of the program components, which included nutrition messages, savings groups, farmer’s groups, etc.

We carried out lab experiments in the field on a subset of the impact evaluation sample which consists of 503 households, with 251 households that did not receive a UCT and 252 households that did. We targeted villages that had a school nearby where we could invite married couples from the evaluation sample. We could have up to 14 married couples per session. Depending on the sample size and availability of respondents in the nearby study village(s), we conducted one or two sessions in every experimental site. In total, 38 experimental sessions were carried out in 22 different sites. Participants from 27 villages attended the experimental sessions. Households were invited around four to five days before the day of the experimental session. Only married couples were invited to participate.

Design details

Randomization method
Public lottery
Randomization unit
Household level
Clusters
In total, 38 experimental sessions were carried out in 22 different sites. Participants from 27 villages attended the experimental sessions.
Observations
503
Arms
Non-UCT/Control HHs: 251 UCT HHs: 252 Lab-experimental treatments: Secret: 255 HHs No-Secret: 248 HHs
Primary outcomes
Our main experimental measure of agency is the propensity to not defer decision-making to one’s spouse (in the absence of any communication). We also investigate how likely women are to not revise their earlier stated allocation decision after receiving communication from spouses, as another potential measure of their agency.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords