Impact of information letters on participation in Payments for Environmental Services

How to cite

Chabé-Ferret, Sylvain. 2018. "Impact of information letters on participation in Payments for Environmental Services." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0003353. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.3353-1.3

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Sylvain Chabé-Ferret*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0003353
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.3353-1.3
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2017-11-01 – 2019-01-31
Countries
France (Hauts de France)
JEL codes
Q57
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/3353

Abstract

This study aims at estimating the impact of information letters on the uptake of Payments for Environmental Services (PES) by farmers in Northern France. PES are subsidies compensating farmers for the adoption of green practices. The European Union Common Agricultural Policy (EU CAP) is home to the largest PES program in the world. PES programs are voluntary and thus their efficiency strongly depends on farmers being informed about the existence of the PES. In this project, we sent letters to eligible farmers (located near zones where PES are available) informing them of their eligibility, of the type of program available to them (practices subsidized and subsidy amount) and providing them with the contact information to caseworkers in charge of helping them with their application. We also varied the content of the letter, adding testimonies of farmers already benefiting from PES and the ease of response by adding easy to use pre-stamped return letters. Finally, we test for the existence of a social multiplier in the numbers of letters sent by varying the proportion of farmers in a given commune receiving the letter.

Intervention

In this project, we sent letters to eligible farmers (located near zones where PES are available) informing them of their eligibility, of the type of program available to them (practices subsidized and subsidy amount) and providing them with the contact information to caseworkers in charge of helping them with their application. We also varied the content of the letter, adding testimonies of farmers already benefiting from PES and the ease of response by adding easy to use pre-stamped return letters. Finally, we test for the existence of a social multiplier in the numbers of letters sent by varying the proportion of farmers in a given commune receiving the letter.

Experimental design

We randomly select 10205 eligible farmers to receive the letters and 10169 to be in the control group.
Among the treated farmers, 5104 receive only the basic letter informing them of their eligibility, of the subsidies available and of the contact information of the caseworker; 3401 receive additionally a testimony of farmers already benefiting from the subsidy; 1700 receive additionally the easy to use pre-stamped reply letter.
There is also a first stage where communes are selected randomly in order to study possible social multiplier effects of the letters. 5427 treated farmers and 5430 control farmers are included in communes where only 50% of the eligible farmers are treated; 3448 control farmers are included in communes where noone receives the treatment; 3482 treated farmers are located in communes where every eligible farmer is treated.
There are also 1294 treated and 1293 controls that are located in communes only participating in the second stage of the experiment (their communes were too small to study diffusion effects but they could be included in the main effect specification).
Stratification was done by PES zone and by commune. That is we selected first communes in PES zones, and then farmers within communes.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization done in office by computer. The approach used was to classify farmers within strata by the value of a uniformly drawn random variable and to assign them in cycle to the different treatments.
Randomization unit
There is a two step randomization process, with first communes randomly drawn within PES zones and then farmers drawn within communes.
Clusters
542 communes.
Observations
20474 farmers.
Arms
In the final sample, we have 325 communes where 50% of eligible farmers receive a letter, 107 super control communes where no farmer receives a letter and 110 super treated communes where all eligible farmers receive a letter. The design can also be analyzed directly by comparing treated and control farmers: 10205 treated and 10169 control. Among the treated farmers, 5104 receive only the basic letter informing them of their eligibility, of the subsidies available and of the contact information of the caseworker; 3401 receive additionally a testimony of farmers already benefiting from the subsidy; 1700 receive additionally the easy to use pre-stamped reply letter.
Primary outcomes
All outcomes are measured during the 2018 season 1/ Overall take up of PES contracts 2/ Overall area under PES 3/ Uptake of "hard core" PES or easy PES
Secondary outcomes
1/ Contact taken with caseworkers

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords