Mobile Monitoring for Teachers: Can Calls Improve Learning Outcomes for Primary School Students in Niger

How to cite

Aker, Jenny. 2018. "Mobile Monitoring for Teachers: Can Calls Improve Learning Outcomes for Primary School Students in Niger." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0003346. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.3346-6.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Jenny Aker*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0003346
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.3346-6.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2019-01-19 – 2022-10-31
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/3346

Abstract

In remote rural areas of developing countries, teacher absenteeism is a widespread problem for both governmental and non-governmental programs, often due to long distances, remote monitoring budgets and weak institutions. Simple technologies, such as mobile phones, could potentially help policymakers to overcome the constraints associated with monitoring teachers' attendance. At the same time, mobile phones may not be effective in improving teacher attendance if they are not penalized for absenteeism, or increased monitoring via mobile phones crowds out intrinsic motivation. An experiment that called teachers, the village chief and two students in the context of an adult education program significantly increased students' test scores, although the mechanisms were difficult to disentangle. In partnership with the Ministry of Education and a research firm in Niger, this study will evaluate the impact of a mobile phone intervention on teacher attendance, motivation and student learning in the context of primary schools in Niger. Schools will be randomly assigned to one of two interventions designed to address the constraints associated with teacher attendance and performance in Niger, with a pure control

Intervention

Based upon previous work, there are two primary interventions. The first intervention is a simple monitoring call, whereby bi-weekly calls will be made the primary school teacher(s), the primary school principal, the village chief and the head of the PTA for the school. The calls will ask each stakeholder if class (taught by that teacher for that particular level) was held that week, the number of days held.

The second intervention is a motivational intervention, which will be implemented in a subset of mobile monitoring villages. In this case, randomly selected teachers in monitoring villages will receive a "motivational" message at the end of the monitoring call, thanking them for their work and encouraging them.

The third intervention is a series of pedagogical support calls, whereby teachers in select schools are provided with bi-weekly calls that provide pedagogical support to them in the area of math and reading.

The monitoring call will begin approximately 2 months after the start of the school year (January 2019, whereby the school year starts in October), and will occur every two weeks. The monitoring interventions will take place in 2019 and 2020, with pedagogical interventions in 2021/2022.

Experimental design

84 primary schools within the Tchadoua commune of the Maradi region in Niger will be stratified by rural and urban status and randomly assigned to one of three interventions:

1. Mobile calls. Weekly calls to targeted teachers, principal, village chief and the PTA president to ask questions about teacher attendance
2. Pedagogical calls
3. Pure control. No weekly calls.

A final, cross-cutting intervention (the motivational message) will be cross-cutting, whereby teachers will be randomly assigned to motivational messages within monitoring villages. Thus, a subset of teachers in monitoring schools will be chosen for this.

All monitoring visits conducted by the Ministry will occur normally.

Design details

Randomization method
The randomization will be conducted in an office by a computer.
Randomization unit
The cluster is the school level.
Clusters
The total number of schools in the experimental design is 84. However, we will also collect teacher attendance and student outcome data data from 20 schools in a nearby commune as a means of measuring trends in teacher and student attendance and performance. These additional schools will be non-experimental assigned, but serve as an additional control group.
Observations
The units will be approximately 4200 students, 84 principals, 168 teachers, 1500 households.
Arms
There will be 42 schools in the pure control (no calls) and 42 schools in the mobile monitoring treatment. Among the 42 schools, there will be 42 schools that are assigned to the pedagogical calls (half in monitoring, half in control). These pedagogical calls will occur after the first year of the monitoring intervention.
Primary outcomes
Teacher attendance (ie, intensive and extensive margin of attendance, as measured by logs taken by the school principal); timeliness of teacher attendance (ie, hours arrived and leaving); teaching quality (via a Stallings classroom observation method); teacher firing or movement; teacher motivation (as measured by an intrinsic motivation index and behavioral measures; students' attendance (number of students and number of days, according to teacher student attendance logs); students' test scores (as measured by the end of year exam); parental, principal and village chief knowledge about school activities.
Secondary outcomes
Attendance of other (non-called) teachers within the classroom; experimental measures of teacher motivation; experimental measures of community knowledge of school activities; teachers' performance on bi-annual teaching exams

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords