Are teachers biased against poor students? Experimental evidence from Peru
How to cite
Holla, Alaka; Vakis, Renos; Bertran, Maria Gabriela Farfan. 2018. "Are teachers biased against poor students? Experimental evidence from Peru." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0003331. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.3331-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
This study tests whether teachers use students’ income to evaluate their scholastic aptitude, behavior, and education potential, using experimental data from teachers in elementary schools representative of the public sector in Metropolitan Lima, Peru. The experimental design was adapted from a landmark study from psychology (Darley and Gross, 1983), in which subjects viewed a video of a child and teacher in a testing situation, where the child’s performance provided a very noisy signal of scholastic aptitude (the child correctly answered some difficult questions and incorrectly answered some easy questions). Prior to the testing video, subjects were randomly assigned to two different priming videos that showed the same child playing at home, either in a working class neighborhood or a middle class neighborhood. We augment this experimental set-up with another variant in which the child provides a very clear signal of high scholastic aptitude. We test to see whether teachers assigned to the different experimental variants rate the child differently with respect to their estimates of the child's grade level, educational potential, and behavior.
Intervention
Teachers in public primary schools in Metropolitan Lima used tablets during an experimental session. They first watched a video that introduced a male fourth grade student and depicted his socioeconomic background. Then teachers watched a video of the same child being evaluated by a teacher in an oral examination that contained questions from the official fourth grade curriculum. After watching these two videos, teachers were asked to rate the child in terms of his current scholastic aptitude, behavior, and expected educational attainment. There were two variants of the introductory video: one in which the student comes from a poor background and one in which he comes from a less poor background. There were also two variants of the examination video: one in which the child's performance provides a noisy signal of aptitude and one in which the child's performance provides a clear signal of high aptitude.
Experimental design
Teachers were randomly assigned to one of six conditions:
1. Teachers only see the examination video showing a noisy signal of aptitude.
2. Teachers only see the examination video showing a clear signal of high aptitude.
3. Teachers see an introductory video showing a poor child and the examination video showing a noisy signal of aptitude.
4. Teachers see an introductory video showing a non-poor child and the examination video showing a noisy signal of aptitude.
5. Teachers see an introductory video showing a poor child and the examination video showing a clear signal of high aptitude.
6. Teachers see an introductory video showing a non-poor child and the examination video showing a clear signal of high aptitude.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.