Alan-Ertac Grit and Growth Mindset Intervention: Study 1

How to cite

Alan, Sule; Ertac, Seda. 2018. "Alan-Ertac Grit and Growth Mindset Intervention: Study 1." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0003317. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.3317-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Sule Alan* , Seda Ertac

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0003317
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.3317-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2013-03-01 – 2014-06-15
Countries
Turkey (Istanbul)
JEL codes
C91, C93, D03, I28
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/3317

Abstract

The growing literature on human capital accumulation has emphasized the importance of socio-emotional skills in explaining individual differences in achievement in various economic and social domains. These skills encompass a broad range of individual character traits, often measured via standardized questionnaires by psychologists and, more recently, via incentivized experimental elicitation techniques by economists. Non-cognitive skills such as patience, self-control and conscientiousness, and preference parameters such as risk attitudes have been shown to be highly predictive of outcomes ranging from educational attainment, occupational and financial success to criminal activity and health outcomes.

In collaboration with the Turkish Ministry of Education, we evaluate a randomized educational program that aims to foster grit. The program involves an intensive teacher training program, supported by a specifically designed curriculum. The curriculum consists of animated videos, mini case studies and classroom activities that highlight i) the plasticity of the human brain against the notion of innately fixed ability, ii) the role of effort in enhancing skills and achieving goals, iii) the importance of a constructive interpretation of failures and therefore perseverance, and iv) the importance of goal setting.

The intervention is randomized across 37 schools in socioeconomically disadvantaged district of Istanbul. We measure the outcomes through a multi-faceted methodology that includes a novel incentivized real effort task, grades and objective test scores. The incentivized real effort task is designed to elicit a number of aspects of grit: challenge seeking, perseverance through setbacks, goal setting and the propensity to engage in effortful behavior to accumulate skill. In addition to experimental choices and outcomes, we administer standardized tests to measure mathematics and verbal (Turkish) skills.

We find that treated students are more likely to exert effort to accumulate task-specific ability, and hence, more likely to succeed. In a follow up 2.5 years after the intervention, we estimate an effect of about 0.2 standard deviations on a standardized math test.

Intervention

The Turkish Ministry of Education encourages schools and teachers to participate in socially useful projects offered by the private sector, NGOs, the government and international organizations. These projects, upon careful examination and endorsement by the Ministry, are made available to interested schools. The Ministry allows up to 5 lecture hours per week for project-related classroom activities, and participation in these projects is at the discretion of teachers. The program we evaluate has been approved as an extracurricular project.

Teachers in the treatment group received full-day training on the delivery of the curriculum. They were advised to use the free hours allowed by the ministry to cover the curriculum and implement the suggested activities. Teachers were encouraged to adopt the ideas put forward in the materials as part of a teaching philosophy, and to implement them by praising students’ effort, perseverant behavior and their positive attitude toward learning, rather than just praising good outcomes. They were also encouraged not to praise a successful student in a way which would imply that the student possesses superior intelligence (in the innate sense of the word), but were rather advised to highlight the role of effort in the student’s success.

Experimental design

This is a two-armed RCT, with each arm targeting a specific non-cognitive skill, patience and grit. We initially sampled 37 schools and collected baseline information. We randomly allocated 15 schools to Initial Treatment (IT), 10 schools to Control-then-Treatment (CT) and the remaining 12 schools to pure control (PC). The program was promised to all participating teachers at some point in two academic years, not to students. Therefore, the design allowed us to conduct long-term tracking of students. We lost 1 CT school after the first follow up of the patience arm (May 2013). In Fall 2013, the IT group received the “grit/mindset” intervention, while the CT group (9 schools) received the “patience” intervention. The CT group never received the grit intervention. Short-term follow-up was done in May 2014, long-term follow up was done in March 2016.

Design details

Randomization method
Teachers in designated schools were called in a random manner. A willing teacher was assigned 40% probability to be in IT, 30% in CT, 30% in PC. Using Stata’s uniform random number generator, we performed the assignment.
Randomization unit
School.
Clusters
Planned 37 schools. Actual number of clusters=36 schools.
Observations
The officially registered number of students in 36 schools is 2575.
Arms
For this evaluation we compare 15 IT schools which were assigned to the program with 21 PC+CT schools which were not. Official student number for IT= 1443 (15 schools), CT=457, PC=675, Total =2575 Official sample size corresponds to all registered students in participating schools. Sample size for experimental outcomes is lower because these outcomes were collected from students who were present at the time of the classroom visits.
Primary outcomes
We have two sets of outcomes: 1) Experimental outcomes 2) Achievement outcomes
Secondary outcomes
self-reported grit (Duckworth grit scale) self-reported mindset (Dweck mindset scale)

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords