Mentoring as a pathway to change education, life skills and sexual reproductive health among rural indigenous girl in Guatemala

How to cite

Valle, Angel del; Aponte, Alejandra; Hallman, Kelly. 2018. "Mentoring as a pathway to change education, life skills and sexual reproductive health among rural indigenous girl in Guatemala." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0003171. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.3171-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Angel del Valle* , Alejandra Aponte , Kelly Hallman

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0003171
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.3171-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2016-01-01 – 2018-12-01
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/3171

Abstract

Guatemala's Quality of Life Survey consistently demonstrates that indigenous girls have very steep declines in school enrollment at the onset of adolescence. Enrollment also declines among indigenous boys during this period, but not nearly as rapidly as girls. Previous research suggests that parental expectations and social norms play a role in this drop. This study features a cluster randomized control trial that measures the impact of a safe spaces, mentoring and life skills curriculum intervention designed to change behavior, knowledge and attitudes associated with early dropout and other negative life outcomes. For this, we track 1,200 girls aged 12 to 17 living in rural indigenous communities in the highlands of Guatemala for a period of 12 months. The study tests for impact on school enrollment as a primary outcome and early marriage and pregnancy, life skills, and sexual reproductive health knowledge and gender norms as secondary outcomes.

Experimental design

The evaluation employs a cluster randomized control trial (CRCT) to measure change, caused by AO, in the aforementioned impact and outcome indicators. For this, we randomly selected 20 treatment and 20 control communities, from a universe of 40 communities eligible to participate in AO in the Guatemalan department of Sololá. To improve the precision of our impact estimates, we used a subset of community-level covariates to stratify this sample into ten blocks, prior to executing the random assignment protocol. We will use this design to generate intent-to-treat (ITT) estimates of program impact, generated by comparing the average outcomes of girls living in treatment communities with the average outcomes of girls living in control communities, 12 months after the rollout of AO. In addition, we will observe "Treatment-on-the-Treated" effect estimates which measure impact by focusing on girls who actually participated in the program. The exact measurement strategies and estimation specifications used to generate both estimates are specified the analysis plan attached to this registration.

Design details

Randomization method
The sample used for AO’s evaluation was selected using a three step process that involved: defining a universe of communities eligible to participate in the program within the Sololá region, dividing this universe into six cluster-level strata, conducting strata-level lotteries that randomly assigned communities to treatment or control, and, finally, selecting a random sample of respondents, within each treatment and control community, to participate in the baseline. These processes are documented in detail elsewhere, nonetheless we summarize them below: 1. Identify eligible communities: The universe of communities eligible to participate in AO was selected using data from the 2011 ENCOVI. The Council selected the Sololá Region for the evaluation, as this area was included in its qualitative work on the links between social norms and girl’s educational attainment. It identified which Sololá communities were eligible to participate in the program by identifying all K’iche’-speaking municipalities which had not previously participated in the program. Once the later were identified, the Council refined its eligibility criteria to include only communities with 500-1500 inhabitants and approximately 30-40 girls, aged 8-19. These criteria were employed, as the Council’s experience suggests this size population is required for the successful implementation of AO. The total number of communities identified by this process is 40, all of which are included in the evaluation. 2. Create strata of eligible communities: Prior to assigning communities to treatment and control, the sample of eligible communities was divided into strata formed by region (highland, lowland) and school type variables (public secondary school, private secondary school, no secondary school) derived from geographic data and the Council’s community census. The final number of strata identified at this stage is 10, the number of communities per strata ranges from 2-7. 3. Randomly assign eligible communities to treatment and control: To assign communities to the evaluation’s treatment and control groups, we used a single-round, random assignment algorithm that placed half of the communities in each strata in the treatment group and half in the control group. To ensure parity in the final number of treatment and control communities, in the first strata with an odd number of communities, we assigned the odd observation to treatment, in the second strata, we assigned it to control and so on. 4. Select a random sample of respondents within treatment and control communities: The Council did not have direct control over the process used to select the community-level sample of approximately 30 girls, aged 12-17, that were invited to participate in the baseline and, possibly, future data collection rounds. Nonetheless, the Council did instruct UNIMER, the external firm responsible for the baseline, to complete this task by randomly selecting the number of girls required from each community from a list of girls located in its community-level census. This step was implemented using Stata 14 on a Population Council computer.
Randomization unit
Cluster (Community)
Clusters
We identified the sample size required for this evaluation by estimating the number of clusters and individual respondents required to detect at least .166 standard deviation change girls’ school enrollment rates. This minimal detectable effect size was selected, as it is equal to the “gap” between indigenous girls and boy enrollment rates, reported for the Sololá Region in Guatemala’s 2011 National Quality of Life Survey (ENCOVI). Setting power at .8, alpha at .05, and intra-cluster correlation at 0, while accounting for attrition and other potential threats to sample size between measurement rounds, we estimate that a total of 40 clusters.
Observations
The number of individual observations per cluster required by the aforementioned power calculation is 30 observations per cluster. The sample for AO’s evaluation was, thereby, set at a total of 40 communities and 30 individual observations or 1200 girls , aged 12-17, spread over 40 communities.
Arms
20 treatment 20 control
Primary outcomes
Scholl enrollment
Secondary outcomes
Life Skills, Sexual History, Protective Factors, Exposure to Violence.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords