Cluster Randomised Trial of the effect and Timing and Duration of Early Childhood Interventions in Odisha, India

How to cite

Attanasio, Orazio; McGregor, Sally; Meghir, Costas; Behrman, Jere; Jervis, Pamela; Codina, Marta; Augsburg, Britta; Banerji, Rukmini. 2018. "Cluster Randomised Trial of the effect and Timing and Duration of Early Childhood Interventions in Odisha, India." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0003161. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.3161-3.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Orazio Attanasio* , Sally McGregor , Costas Meghir , Jere Behrman , Pamela Jervis , Marta Codina , Britta Augsburg , Rukmini Banerji

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0003161
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.3161-3.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2018-01-01 – 2022-12-31
Countries
Private
JEL codes
I30, I38, J13
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/3161

Abstract

The importance of early life has been highlighted in three series on Early Childhood Development (ECD) published in The Lancet between 2007 and 2016 and in many other publications. One of the key conclusions of this burgeoning literature is that stimulation interventions can be life-changing with long-run persistent effects leading to tangible improvements in quality of life through adulthood. There have been an increasing number of studies, including randomized trials, of interventions (typically based at home) during the first life-cycle stage, from pregnancy to 2 years or interventions (often center-based) during the second life-cycle stage (3 to 5). Ultimately, the aim of such interventions is to break the intergenerational transmission of poverty and to offer equal opportunity to all. However, there are three critical questions outstanding:
(i) how to design scalable ECD interventions that can reach broad segments of poor populations in an effective and sustainable way and lead to longer-run impacts,
(ii) at what stage should one intervene in a child’s development and for how long, and
(iii) can such approaches be adopted effectively in the contexts of rural South Asia, wherein live almost half of the world’s children under 5 years of age who are predicted to not reach their developmental potential.
To answer the questions above about optimal timing requires however a randomized design at both the earliest and the next stage. In this study we implement the second phase of such a design in 192 villages in rural Odisha (India), with randomized curricular improvements for the pre-school stage (ages 3-5 years) overlaid on a completed randomized intervention to improve parental stimulation during the first 1-3 years of life. With such a design, some children will be exposed to our interventions in both the first 1-3 years of life and when 3-5 years old, some children will be exposed in one or the other of these two age ranges, and some will not be exposed at all, but will of course have access to whatever is currently provided in these communities by the government or the private sector. Odisha provides an excellent setting for the study as it represents a prototypical context of low levels of stimulation, high malnutrition, poor developmental outcomes and extreme levels of poverty. Only with such a design can we confidently learn answers to the critical questions about timing that are raised above.

Intervention

Currently pre-school services are provided through the Anganwadi program, started by the Indian government in 1975 as part of the ICDS program to combat child hunger and malnutrition. A typical Anganwadi center provides supplementary nutrition, non-formal pre-school education, nutrition and health education, immunization, health check-up and referral services of which latter three services are provided in convergence with public health systems. The non-formal Pre-School Education component of the ICDS for 3-to-6 year-old children in the Anganwadis is directed towards school readiness and development of positive attitudes towards education and is intended to contribute to the universalization of primary education, by providing to the child the necessary preparation for primary schooling and offering substitute care to younger siblings, thus freeing the older ones - especially girls - to attend school. However, the pre-school aspect of the program, is very weak and has a particularly low awareness in the wider community.

Our treatment is an enhanced preschool program (EPP) organized in the Anganwadi centers and accompanied by parenting classes embedded in currently existing parental meeting at the center. This includes the implementation of the enhanced curriculum, along with all of the materials required to implement it, and the assistance of a Pratham Mentor who will attend each center 2 days per week for 18 months. Our starting point for the curriculum is the existing one used by the ICDS, which the research team, including CECED and Pratham, has enhanced further drawing on existing expertise and knowledge of those working with young children in India.

Experimental design

The evaluation will take place using a cluster-randomized controlled trial and will be based on two further rounds of data collection. The initial phase of the trial has three data collection rounds: a baseline survey (completed and report is available), one at midline (December 2016) and one at endline (December 2017). In this second phase, we will build on this data collection with two further rounds: one in June 2019 (midline of the new project) and one in December 2019. The end product will be a unique data set tracking child development from age 1-5 with children having received different intervention combinations in a randomized fashion.

Overall there are 192 communities in our experimental population. Each current intervention arm (three in total) includes 48 communities and we also have 48 control communities. The allocation of a community to an intervention or control arm was random.

In the proposed project extension, we intend to randomize half the communities of each current experimental arm to the new intervention described above. This means that we will include 96 communities in the new intervention, while the remaining 96 will not be included. Randomization will ensure unbiased comparisons with the control group and across alternative arms. All children will be evaluated based on the same measurements. Hence a comparison of children who only received the first part of the intervention with those who received only the second part will reveal the effect of starting early versus later – a key question of this research; a comparison of those always in the intervention with those only later will quantify the extent to which the two components reinforce each other and so on.

Importantly the data include detailed household and parental characteristics, which will allow us to understand the heterogeneity of outcomes across different groups. Specifically, we will be considering how the educational level of the mother affects child outcomes and we will focus on how parental investments in time and materials (which we measure) are affected by the interventions and in turn reinforce them.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization will be done in office by a computer using the statistical software stata, version 14.1.
Randomization unit
Randomization will be carried out at the village level.
Clusters
192 villages (clusters), 96 in treatment and 96 in control.
Observations
The total sample sizes will be 1,427 families with children who were a part of the initial phase of the trial, distributed among the two treatment arms.
Arms
96 communities in treatment and control for the new trial, creating 8 arms of 48 clusters each.
Primary outcomes
Key Final Outcomes 1. Children’s child cognitive development 2. Children’s school readiness
Secondary outcomes
Key Intermediate Outcomes 1. Children's language development, executive function and behaviour. 2. Preschool quality 3. Child anthropometric outcomes 4. Child rearing practices: level of stimulation in the home 5. Parental knowledge of child rearing practices

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords