Towards a better understanding of the development of non-cognitive skills in children: Evidence from Bangladesh

How to cite

Schildberg-Hörisch, Hannah; Chowdhury, Shyamal. 2018. "Towards a better understanding of the development of non-cognitive skills in children: Evidence from Bangladesh." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0003129. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.3129-1.2

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Hannah Schildberg-Hörisch* , Shyamal Chowdhury

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0003129
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.3129-1.2
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2018-03-20 – 2021-12-31
Countries
Bangladesh (South Asia)
JEL codes
C21, C90, D1, D90, D81, I20, J13, J24
Secondary IDs
DFG-Bewilligung SCHI 1377/1-1
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/3129

Abstract

Non-cognitive skills are key predictors of central life outcomes such as educational attainment, job performance, earnings, health outcomes, and participation in risky behaviors. Despite their fundamental importance, we know surprisingly little about how non-cognitive skills form. By combining the collection of panel data (three to four waves) with an RCT design, we will provide causal evidence on investments as possible drivers of skill formation on top of comprehensive descriptive evidence on the formation of non-cognitive skills in childhood and adolescence. In defining non-cognitive skills, our project adopts the interdisciplinary and multidimensional approach in the emerging field of personality psychology and economics. In this field, the definition of non-cognitive skills encompasses both economic preferences (time, risk, and social preferences) and personality traits from psychology (Big Five, locus of control, self-control, self-esteem). The malleability of both preferences and personality traits during childhood and adolescence is our key interest.

In cooperation with Lions Clubs International, we will implement the social and emotional learning (SEL) program Lions Quest Skills for Growing (PreK-5) in grades 2 to 5 of 69 primary schools (treatment group) located in rural areas of Bangladesh. In total, our sample covers 135 schools from four districts (Chandpur, Gopalganj, Netrokona and Sunamganj) that are divided into treatment and control group by stratified randomization.

We sample 3,000 children and their households, at least 20 from each school across grades 2 to 5. We will implement three waves of interviews: a baseline for the full sample of 3,000 households in 2018 (pre-treatment, wave 1), a short-run post-treatment measurement in 2019 (wave 2), and a longer-run follow-up in 2020 (wave 3). This allows us to identify short-run effects as well as to analyze whether possible treatment effects are sustained in the longer-run. We will not only analyze the impact of the intervention on the development of non-cognitive skills per se, but also be able to differentiate between different age groups, allowing for an analysis of heterogeneous treatment effects, and possibly to address the timing of skill-specific sensitive periods. Additionally, we will have data on an already existing sample of households from the same villages that was established earlier (“non-intervention sample”). It will extend our intervention sample with comprehensive information on demographics, socio-economic status, cognitive and non-cognitive skills on another 1,000 households.

Intervention

We have a single treatment and a single control group. The 135 primary schools in our sample are divided into 69 treatment and 66 control group schools by stratified randomization. In cooperation with Lions Clubs International, we implement the social and emotional learning (SEL) program Lions Quest Skills for Growing (PreK-5) in grades 2 to 5 of the 69 treatment schools. The remaining 66 schools in the control group do not receive any treatment.

Implemented in more than 90 countries, Lions Quest is one of the most widely used SEL and prevention programs in the world. Typically, Lions Quest lessons take 45 minutes per week on top of the standard curriculum over a 33-week schedule where lessons usually take place in the classroom environment. Lions Quest is designed to build up children’s non-cognitive skills and positive attitudes. The non-cognitive skills in turn are supposed to promote academic success and civic engagement and to prevent risky behaviors and discrimination (for detailed information, please see https://www.lions-quest.org/elementary-social-and-emotional-learning/). Among others, the program’s schedule explicitly addresses self-control and self-discipline, patience, cooperative behavior, empathy, perspective-taking, relationship skills, avoidance of overly risky behaviors, self-confidence, and goal-setting. Skills are taught in presentations, discussions and group work. The Lions Quest Skills for Growing materials have already been translated into Bengali and culturally adapted to the context of Bangladesh.

Experimental design

We have a single treatment and a single control group, consisting of 69 and 66 schools, respectively (for details, see section “Intervention” above).

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization was done in an office by a computer, more specifically using STATA. In order to gain a balanced treatment-control group setting, we stratified by subdistrict (our schools are located in 11 subdistricts differing in their schooling authorities and hence their educational environment), by distance of the school to its respective subdistrict capital (as a proxy for schooling quality) and village literacy rate. No re-randomization was done but the first draw taken. Balance checks were run ex post for the stratification variables via two-sided t-tests (no significant differences at the 5%-level) as well as for wages, village population, distribution of educational levels, and student-teacher ratios (no significant differences either).
Randomization unit
School level randomization
Clusters
Treatment was assigned to 69 out of a total of 135 schools (hence, 66 schools in control group). These schools are serving 150 villages that we randomly selected from 11 subdistricts (chosen based on the availability of NGOs willing to collaborate) belonging to four main districts of Bangladesh.
Observations
3,000 households from the 150 villages that are served by the 135 primary schools in our sample; sampled by selecting at least 20 children from grades 2 to 5 of each school – larger samples from schools serving multiple sample villages, e.g. 40 children per school if the school serves two villages. We will have a sample that covers at least 3,000 pupils attending grades 2 to 5 plus information on at least one of their siblings (if they have siblings, the additionally sampled sibling is chosen randomly).
Arms
69 schools in treatment group (Lions Quest program gets implemented) and 66 schools in control group. In sum, 135 schools.
Primary outcomes
Non-cognitive skills: risk, time, and social preferences, trust, Big Five personality traits, locus of control, self-control, self-esteem, IQ, outcomes at school (attendance, grades, test scores if available), life satisfaction, Strengths and Difficulties Questionnaire (SDQ), risky behaviors

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords