Role models, aspirations and competitive behavior

How to cite

Martini, Christina; Uruena, Viviana. 2018. "Role models, aspirations and competitive behavior." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0003119. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.3119-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Christina Martini* , Viviana Uruena

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0003119
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.3119-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2018-07-03 – 2018-12-31
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/3119

Abstract

We conduct a lab-in-the field-experiment in which we randomly assign students in their last year of secondary education to watch aspirational videos that show potential role models. After being exposed to these videos, the students perform an effort task under different payment schemes which serves to assess their performance in competitive environments as well as their preference to enter into competition. There is empirical evidence that videos which display successful peers can increase individual aspirations. Showing aspirational videos could provide students with a new sense on what they could achieve, making them more ambitious (increasing their performance) and competitive (selecting more into competition). The potential role model effect can be larger for women, owing to the fact that women in the study region continue education and follow a career less often than men.

Furthermore, we will test with an artefactual field experiment whether aspirational videos also have real-world consequences in the decisions of the students to enter into competition or not. The same students from the lab-in-the-field experiment will be informed about two job openings in the project of one of the principal investigators. The students will have the opportunity to express their interest of applying to the job after the lab-in-the-field experiment. One week later, students who expressed their interest will have to fill out an application form. For the second part of this study, we include two treatments in each of the three treatment arms mentioned above. We randomly assign students to give their statement of interest in applying for the job privately or publicly. Showing a potential female role model might lead to more females expressing their interest in the job publicly, as it might decrease their discomfort from not adhering to gender norms.

Intervention

The first of the three interventions consists in screening a video that shows the story of a woman who had the goal of becoming a teacher at a University and how she achieved it despite the many hardships she faced. In the second intervention a similar video is shown, but instead of a potential female role model we provide the students with a potential male role model. In the third intervention we show a placebo video which is about life in rural and urban areas in the study region.

Experimental design

In our lab-in-the-field experiment we have a 3x2 Between-Subject Design: In the first treatment group the students will watch a video with a female role model and in the second treatment group subjects will watch a video with a male role model. In the third treatment participants will watch a placebo video to control for the effect of watching a video.

In our artefactual field experiment we will provide the opportunity to apply for a job as a research assistant and/or as a coordinator in the project of one of the principal investigators. We will introduce two further treatments in each intervention: In one group subjects will write their decision whether they are interested in applying or not (private treatment) and in the other group subjects will write their decision and their names will be called out loud to verify that they want to apply for the job (public treatment). The final outcome will be the number of application forms students fill in one week after the lab-in-the-field experiment.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization into each treatment will be done in the office with the use of Stata/Excel.
Randomization unit
Individual
Clusters
3-5 Schools
Observations
750 students
Arms
40 in the female video & public statement treatment 40 in the female video & private statement treatment 40 in the male video & public statement treatment 40 in the male video & private statement treatment 40 in the placebo video & public statement treatment 40 in the placebo video & private statement treatment
Primary outcomes
Our primary outcomes are the following: - performance in the effort task - selection into inter-compeition - selection into intra-competition - number of expressed interests - number of filled application forms
Secondary outcomes
Our secondary outcomes are the following: - educational, status, wealth and asset aspirations - aspiration index - aspirations window - role model - self-efficacy - locus of control

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords