Building Citizen Competencies from the Classroom: Experimental Evidence from Colombia
How to cite
CAF, Pilar; Rodríguez, Catherine; Maris, Lesbia. 2018. "Building Citizen Competencies from the Classroom: Experimental Evidence from Colombia." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0003116. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.3116-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
After long years of confrontation between armed groups and increased urban violence, Colombia must filled the left holes in order to overcome the negative consequences of this former reality. A crucial challenge faced by policymakers in Colombia is to promote and enhance a culture of peace. Education has proven to be an effective path to attain this goal; it helps to transform misconceptions and develop skills and knowledge that can create peaceful relationships from early years of life in spite of any violent context. Since 2003, the Ministry of Education have been working on establishing a culture of peace in the country. Even though different interventions have been applied, experimental evidence about their effectiveness is limited. Along with the Ministry of Education, we conducted a randomized controlled trial to evaluate the impact of a specialized teacher’s training on student's citizenship competencies. By changing the learning environments at the school, the program ("Modelo de Formación para la Ciudadanía: estrategias que contribuyen a educar para la paz or MFC") seeks to build and consolidate, along with teachers and school staff, strategies that enhance citizenship competencies in students for the exercise of human rights. The program was implemented in public schools located in municipalities prioritized for post-conflict programs.
Intervention
MFC offers specialized in situ training to enhance teachers’ competencies to promote education for peace and citizenship competencies on students. It also aims to strengthen Education Secretariats to institutionalize those practices at the local and department level.
The program comprises three phases (1) classroom, (2) school and (3) community:
1.The first phase starts at the classroom level, analyzing current pedagogical practices of teachers and promoting effective tools to develop citizenship competencies on students.
2.The second phase focuses on working on institutional management practices at the school level in order to assure that all spaces available at the school are effective opportunities for students to experience democracy along with other members of the school community.
3.The third phase further extends the exercise of citizenship to Education Secretariats and other plausible public and private allies, focusing on social mobilization and participatory practices, which aim is to establish links of collaboration between different members of the communities.
Each phase contains three main cycles: (1) understanding the context, (2) training and assistance, and (3) articulation. The first two cycles relate to specialized teacher training and classroom strategies, and the last one has a broader objective, which is to apply this knowledge beyond classroom environments, and strengthen the work conducted by teachers in the classroom at the school and community level.
Some of the primary topics that are discuss during the training are the following:
1) Education for peace and human rights: it highlights the relevance of acquiring values and developing attitudes, skills, and behaviors that lead to more inclusive and cooperative environments. In addition, it focuses on how to consider conflict as a mechanism for positive change, advice on how to handle conflicting situations in the classroom, and abilities necessary to achieve it.
2) Socio-emotional, cognitive and communicational abilities: how to identify, manage and learn from our own emotions -and others’- to ensure favorable interpersonal relationships, not only with students, but also with all school employees. It also puts emphasis on understanding other people’s circumstances, by developing empathy and mutual understanding.
3) Pedagogical style: education for peace’s approach centers on encouraging structured pedagogical practices that stimulate student’s participation in class. In order to achieve that, teachers have to prepare in advance the class’s structure and the main goal of every activity. Thus, preparation goes beyond “annual planning”; every day and every class must be carefully analyzed in order to achieve its higher ends.
4) Class planning: offers support and suggestions for class activities that promote citizenship competencies, such as collaborative strategies, conversations, ethic, and citizen’s fundamental values.
Experimental design
To identify the impact of the model, we randomized schools into treatment or control groups. The Ministry of Education restricted to 88 the number of treated schools that could take part in the pilot. Hence, the size of the experiment is 176 schools. From the initially focalized 281 schools, we randomly selected 88 to be part of the treatment group and 88 to be part of the control group. In addition, we selected 52 replacement schools for the treatment group and 53 for the control group, in case one of the originally selected schools could not participate in the program and/or survey. Finally, we stratified by the urban status of schools (urban, rural and mixed), as we could expect impacts to be different in different urban/rural settings
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.