Clouded Judgement: Air Pollution, Priming and Inattention to Energy Efficiency in China

How to cite

Ding, Iza; Nauze, Andrea La; Beattie, Graham. 2018. "Clouded Judgement: Air Pollution, Priming and Inattention to Energy Efficiency in China." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0003096. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.3096-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Iza Ding* , Andrea La Nauze , Graham Beattie

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0003096
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.3096-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2018-03-11 – 2018-07-30
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/3096

Abstract

We explore the interaction between salience, information and inattention to energy efficiency in China. To date, empirical evidence on the existence of inattention to energy costs comes from the developed world. Our project will establish whether inattention to energy efficiency exists in the developing world. Our experiment will also allow us to explore what drives heterogeneity in inattention. First, we will use plausibly exogenous variation in local air pollution as a measure of the salience of environmental problems to test whether salience has a causal effect on willingness to pay for energy efficiency and whether the effect of information is enhanced or attenuated by salience. Second, we will test whether air pollution, via changes in cognition, has an effect on willingness to pay for energy efficiency and the energy efficiency gap, and whether information is more or less effective when cognition is impaired. Finally, we will test whether priming decision makers to think about environmental or energy costs affects willingness to pay for energy efficiency and estimates of the energy efficiency gap. The results will contribute to our understanding of what drives inattention and will have important implications for the targeting of energy efficiency policy.

Experimental design

Participants will be provided with a budget from which they can purchase two lightbulbs. One lightbulb has high energy use and a short lifetime; the other uses less energy and has a longer lifetime. Participants will then be asked to choose between the light bulbs at a range of relative prices. At the end of the experiment, one of the participant’s decisions is chosen to be implemented and they will receive a package of lightbulbs, and any remaining budget that they did not spend. Randomization of the chosen lightbulb will be undertaken by a cell phone app that rolls dice in front of the survey respondent. The surveyor will record the outcome and give the respondent the correct lightbulb and remaining shopping budget. In addition to the lightbulb choice, the surveyors will collect demographic information as well as pro-environmental preferences.

Treatments are a combination of detailed information on the relative lifetime costs of the two lightbulbs and a series of priming questions. In addition, we will implement the experiment on high and low air pollution days, such that we have quasi-experimental variation in air pollution. The treatment groups are:

A: Cost Information
- Intro script
- Light bulb info sheet
- First 15 choices
- Light bulb shape distractor
- Energy cost info sheet
- Second 15 choices
- Cost priming
- Environmental priming
- Time preference elicitation
- Cognition tests
- Post questionnaire

B: Control
- Intro script
- Light bulb info sheet
- First 15 choices
- Light bulb shape distractor
-
- Second 15 choices
- Cost priming
- Environmental priming
- Time preference elicitation
- Cognition tests
- Post questionnaire

C: Cost Priming + Cost Information
- Intro script
- Light bulb info sheet
- First 15 choices
- Cost priming
- Light bulb shape distractor
- Energy cost info sheet
- Second 15 choices
- Environmental priming
- Time preference elicitation
- Cognition tests
- Post questionnaire

D: Environmental Priming + Cost Information
- Intro script
- Light bulb info sheet
- First 15 choices
- Environmental priming
- Light bulb shape distractor
- Energy cost info sheet
- Second 15 choices
- Cost priming
- Time preference elicitation
- Cognition tests
- Post questionnaire

E: Cost Priming
- Intro script
- Light bulb info sheet
- First 15 choices
- Cost priming
- Light bulb shape distractor
-
- Second 15 choices
- Environmental priming
- Time preference elicitation
- Cognition tests
- Post questionnaire

F: Environmental Priming
- Intro script
- Light bulb info sheet
- First 15 choices
- Environmental priming
- Light bulb shape distractor
-
- Second 15 choices
- Cost priming
- Time preference elicitation
- Cognition tests
- Post questionnaire

G: same as A, with lightbulb types reversed in questions X1-15 and X16-30

H: same as B, with lightbulb types reversed in questions X1-15 and X16-30

I: same as C, with lightbulb types reversed in questions X1-15 and X16-30

J: same as D, with lightbulb types reversed in questions X1-15 and X16-30

K: same as E, with lightbulb types reversed in questions X1-15 and X16-30

L: same as F, with lightbulb types reversed in questions X1-15 and X16-30

Design details

Randomization method
The randomization is done by the research team using a random number generator. Enumerators will approach respondents at random.
Randomization unit
individual
Clusters
The experiment is implemented via a paper-based field survey in two locations in Beijing. Survey responses will be collected by a team of four enumerators. Our target is to have each enumerator complete 16 surveys per survey day for a total of 32 days. Each day, the enumerators will implement 4 Group A,B, G, H surveys and 2 Group C-F & I-L surveys. At the start of each survey day, the enumerators are provided with a randomized ordering of surveys to be completed. The randomization is done by the research team using a random number generator. Enumerators will approach respondents at random.
Observations
1536 people
Arms
• Group A: 192 • Group B: 192 • Group C: 96 • Group D: 96 • Group E: 96 • Group F: 96 • Group G: 192 • Group H: 192 • Group I: 96 • Group J: 96 • Group K: 96 • Group L: 96
Primary outcomes
willingness to pay (WTP) for LED lightbulb and change in WTP for LED lightbulb

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords