Increasing the Take-Up of Cal Grant Awards Through Improved Notification Letters
How to cite
Rothstein, Jesse. 2018. "Increasing the Take-Up of Cal Grant Awards Through Improved Notification Letters." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0003031. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.3031-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Each year, over 150,000 California high school students receive letters notifying them that they qualify for Cal Grants, grant aid for college that is assigned based on family income and high school GPA. Less than two-thirds claim their awards. The California Student Aid Commission (CSAC) believes this is in part because some students do not understand their eligibility. This study will investigate whether a simplified letter, in terms of both format and the use of language that behavioral science research suggests would nudge students to take action, will induce higher take-up of the Grants and will consider how different letters impact students’ college choices decision making.
In 2017-18, students were randomly assigned (at the high school level) to receive CSAC’s usual notification letter or one of two variants designed with behavioral science principles in mind. Primary outcomes of interest include whether students create accounts in CSAC’s online portal, enroll in college, and claim their awards, as well as which type of college (community college vs. 4-year) they choose. Analysis of these outcomes will occur beginning in Spring 2018.
Intervention
In November, the California Student Aid Commission (CSAC) began mailing preliminary notification letters to notify students that they have qualified for a Cal Grant. These letters include information on the size of the Cal Grant award, instructions on how to claim the award, and some additional information on other potential sources of aid. In 2017-18, instead of sending the same letter to all Cal Grant recipients, CSAC is sending three variants of this letter. One letter – the control letter –closely resembles the letters sent in previous years but has been updated to reflect this year’s Cal Grant award amounts. The other letters have been designed to be simpler, both in terms of the language used in the text, and in the way in which they are formatted. While these variants have been designed to be simpler, the research team has taken care to ensure all relevant information on the award and how to claim it is included in the letter. The two variants differ in that one includes language designed to “nudge” students into college attendance. Samples of the three letters are included below.
High schools were randomly assigned to one or another letter variant, so that all students at a school who appear to be Cal Grant eligible will receive the same letter but students at different schools may receive different variants.
CSAC is creating and mailing all communications, recording which version of each letter is sent to students at a given school. California Policy Lab researchers at the University of California, Berkeley, will conduct the data analysis.
Experimental design
This study employed a randomized control trial to test whether a letter designed using insights from behavioral science elicits a better response than the letter previously mailed to students who are eligible to receive a Cal Grant award. High schools were randomized into three groups, one control group and two treatment groups, with students at a given high school receiving the letter variant assigned to their school.
We will look for differences among the treatment groups and the control group in terms of the number of students who register for a webgrants4students account, the time between receiving the letter and creating the account, whether students enroll in college and claim their award, and the types of institutions students attend. Additionally, we will look for differences in longer-term outcomes including persistence, graduation, and continued claiming of Cal Grants in subsequent years.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.