Strengthening Prosecutors Capacities for Sexual Crime Investigations: Evidence from Colombia
How to cite
CAF, Pilar; Maris, Lesbia; Vargas, Juan; Rossi, Martin. 2018. "Strengthening Prosecutors Capacities for Sexual Crime Investigations: Evidence from Colombia." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0003010. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.3010-2.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Sexual violence’s victims face negative consequences, both physical and psychological, that could last throughout their lifetime. Despite their severity, sexual crimes are usually underreported because victims are afraid, are being pressured by their offenders or simply because they lack the relevant information about the process or do not trust the justice system. Furthermore, cases that are effectively reported tend to be poorly managed and are frequently influenced by social prejudices that can bias the prosecutorial processes. To our knowledge, there is limited empirical evidence about the effectiveness of different strategies aimed at improving the investigation and judicial process through training focused on reducing biases and pre-conception on the part of the prosecutors. Along with the Office of the Attorney General, we conducted a randomized controlled trial to evaluate the impact on the investigation process of sexual cases of a training workshop ("Taller de socialización del “Protocolo de investigación y judicialización de violencia sexual”) for Colombian prosecutors. The workshop is part of an initiative led by the Office of the Attorney General aimed at improving the quality and outcomes of sexual crimes cases by providing prosecutors with tools to overcome technical and investigative obstacles in an unbiased and victim-centered way.
Intervention
The training workshops aim to strengthen prosecutors’ capacities on how to effectively manage sexual crimes. Specifically, the main goals of the training workshops are:
(1) Familiarize prosecutors with conceptual terms related to sexual violence and how to approach the investigation process.
(2) Introduce how prejudices and biases can affect investigation processes and how to prevent them.
(3) Crime details and research acts that must be take into account.
(4) Effective trial strategies.
(5) How to treat the victim and apply differential approaches on this type of cases.
This workshop is targeted to judicial investigators and judicial police officers who have the higher proportion of sexual crime cases on their Sectional Division. Intervention will be done by Setional Division during 2 days (or 16 hours).
After the training, a work session will be held with the management team to report the results and highlight aspects that have to be improved to achieve the expected standards. Finally, a session of 2 hours will also be arranged with the local authorities of the entities involved in the investigation of cases of sexual violence and the attention to victims to present the basic contents of the Protocol and the Checklist.
Experimental design
As the training occurs at the Sectional Division level and all sectionals had to receive the training, we divided the 35 divisions in two groups (18 in the treatment group and 17 in the control group), that would receive the training with a six-month difference. We also stratified by type of Sectional Division. Sectional divisions are grouped by types depending on the number of subdirections each one of them has on their charge. In each sectional division, only 12 or 13 prosecutors could participate in the training. We created a ranking of prosecutors in each Sectional Division according to their individual load of sexual crime cases (from highest to lowest). The first 12 prosecutors were chosen for the workshop, and in some cases, this number was lower because there were less than 12 prosecutors in some Sectional Divisions. Also, 6 additional prosecutors were chosen to replace the selected ones in case that one of the originally chosen could not attend the training workshop (for Sectional Divisions that had fewer prosecutors, this number was smaller or simply did not exist).
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.