Information, Fiscal Capacity and Tax Revenues: An Experimental Evaluation
How to cite
Almunia, Miguel; Hjort, Jonas; Knebelmann, Justine; Tian, Lin; Henning, David J.. 2018. "Information, Fiscal Capacity and Tax Revenues: An Experimental Evaluation." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0002958. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.2958-1.2
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
The value-added tax (VAT) is one of the most important sources of domestic tax revenue in developing countries. In theory, the VAT has two desirable properties: it is more efficient than alternative tax instruments, and it is self-enforcing because the two sides of each transaction (seller and buyer) have incentives to report truthfully. However, when enforcement capacity is limited, these two properties can break down, leading to economic distortions and tax revenue losses. When cross-checking the transactions reported monthly by all VAT-registered firms in Uganda in the period 2015-2017, we estimated substantial discrepancies leading to a large revenue shortfall.
This experiment aims to improve compliance along the VAT chain through the implementation of a tax enforcement intervention that encourages taxpayers to amend their past tax returns and comply with tax laws in the future. Specifically, the treatment will consist of sending notification letters to about 1,000 randomly selected firm-pairs (i.e., buyer-seller pairs) with the following information: (i) their VAT returns will be closely monitored (ii) a list of up to 3 discrepancies that have been found in their past returns (iii) failure to comply could result in additional enforcement measures or prosecution. We will measure the direct effect of the letters on the tax compliance behavior of the treated firms, and also the spillover effects on their trading partners.
Intervention
The intervention consists of sending notification letters to a randomly-selected sample of firm pairs (i.e., a seller-buyer match) for which reporting discrepancies were observed in the year before the intervention. The letters state that the tax authority has developed a new system to monitor VAT compliance and that the VAT returns will be closely monitored. The letters list up to 3 detected discrepancies and ask taxpayers to submit an amendment to correct any existing discrepancies. Finally, the letters point out that a failure to comply can result in additional enforcement measures or prosecution.
Experimental design
The first step of the experimental design selects a "base sample" of firm-pairs. The criteria to be included in this base sample are: both firms in the buyer-seller pair must be registered for VAT, must have filed a VAT return in the last month, must not be part of the URA's annual audit plan for the financial year (2017/18), and must have an accumulated discrepancy above 1 million UGX (approximately 270 USD) over the previous 10 months.
In the second step, we employ an iterative randomization procedure to select firm-pairs to be included in the "study sample". Once the first firm-pair is randomly selected, we remove all the trading partners of the two firms (buyer and seller) from the base sample. Then, we randomly select another firm-pair and remove all their trading partners. Following this iterative procedure, we obtain a set of firm-pairs which are (i) separated by at least two nodes in the network of firm-to-firm transactions and (ii) have an accumulated misreporting discrepancy that is greater than 270 USD over the past year.
In the third step, we apply a stratified randomization procedure to allocate firms from the study sample to three treatment arms and a control group. In the first treatment arm, the letter is sent only to the buyer in the selected pair. In the second treatment arm, the letter is sent to the seller. Finally, in the third arm, letters are sent to both the buyer and seller.
Design details
Papers from this trial
- Almunia, Miguel, David Henning, Justine Knebelmann, Dorotyh Nakyambadde and Lin Tian (2023), “Leveraging Trading Networks to Improve Tax Compliance: Experimental Evidence from Uganda”, CEPR Discussion Paper No. 18151. https://cepr.org/publications/dp18151
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.