Policies to reduce the Social Security shortfalls and their impact on subjective expectations of future retirement benefits, employment and retirement behaviors, preferences and attitudes

How to cite

Perez-Arce, Francisco. 2018. "Policies to reduce the Social Security shortfalls and their impact on subjective expectations of future retirement benefits, employment and retirement behaviors, preferences and attitudes." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0002941. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.2941-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Francisco Perez-Arce*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0002941
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.2941-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2017-09-01 – 2018-07-01
Countries
Private
JEL codes
J260; H310
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/2941

Abstract

The predicted shortfall in the Social Security trust fund will require policy changes such as reduction in retirement benefits, an increase of the payroll tax rate and/or of the “wage ceiling” (the upper limit on SS taxable income). It is thus important to understand the potential behavioral impacts of such policies.
Though the actual elasticities for saving, labor force participation and retirement depend on many factors, one important element is how policy-changes affect the expectations of Social Security benefit receipt. To some extent, people are aware of the predicted shortfalls in the Social Security system and thus already expect to receive lower amounts than those prescribed under current rules. Therefore, changes in the rules need may have no effect on expectations. For example, a reduction in social security benefits could have no impact on the expectations of those who had already internalized such reduction.
Understanding how people’s expectations would change in response to policy levers would be a useful input into studies of the likely behavioral responses of these policy changes. For instance, Kapteyn, Prados & Yoong (ongoing, KPY from now on) are currently studying how people make decisions on wealth accumulation and decumulation over the life span and how this may deviate from an “optimal” path of wealth over the life span (in terms of an individual’s own goals and expectations). The results of these combined studies would allow tracing back the behavioral effects of policy changes on private savings through their effects on subjective expectations. Furthermore, understanding whether these changes affect subjective expectations by themselves would be worthy on its own. For instance, Luttmer and Samwick (2017) show that the uncertainty of Social Security in itself reduces welfare. Thus, an important question is whether policy changes would reduce such uncertainty.
We field a survey on a internet-based representative panel, as a follow-up to respondents of an earlier survey. We present respondents with a series of “policy scenarios” where the government enacts alternative policy changes (such as increase in the tax rates, reduction of the benefits, and other). The order of the policy scenarios randomly differs across respondents. In each of these scenarios we measure respondents’ expectations. We compare expectations across the scenarios (within and across respondents) to present an estimate of how alternative policies would affect expectations. In addition, we randomize respondents into one of three treatment arms, that alter the baseline levels of information that each respondent has. The purpose of this randomization to test whether the impact of the scenarios on benefit expectations differ by the level of information of the respondents. However, the randomization will also be used in a separate paper to test for the impacts of information.

Intervention

We field a survey on a US-representative panel as a follow-up to respondents of an earlier survey (for whom we already had a baseline estimate of their expected retirement benefits). We present respondents with a series of “policy scenarios” where the government enacts alternative policy changes (such as increase in the tax rates, reduction of the benefits, and other). The order of the policy scenarios randomly differs across respondents. In each of these scenarios we measure respondents’ expectations using the method in the earlier study. We compare expectations across the scenarios (within and across respondents) to present an estimate of how alternative policies would affect expectations. In addition, we randomize respondents into one of three information treatment arms, that alter the baseline levels of information that each respondent has. The purpose of this randomization to test whether the impact of the scenarios on benefit expectations differ by the level of information of the respondents. However, the randomization will also be used in a separate paper to test for the impacts of information.

Experimental design

There are two levels of randomization. The first one is the order of the randomization of the different policy scenarios. All respondents will be asked to submit their benefit expectations under all the scenarios, but at a randomly different order (this will allow us to do cross-respondent comparisons to confirm the within-individual analyses).

The second level will be the randomization to iinformation treatments. This will allow to determine the heterogeneity of the impact of the policy scenario by levels of information (estimate whether the impact of the policy scenarios are different for respondents with high versus low levels of information).

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization via survey software.
Randomization unit
Individual
Clusters
3,500 individuals
Observations
3,500 individuals
Arms
1,166
Primary outcomes
1. Social Security Benefit Expectations. 2. Expected labor and retirement behaviors.
Secondary outcomes
However, the information randomization will also be used in a separate paper for a different research question (to be analyzed in a separate paper) to test for the impacts of information treatments on policy preferences. Policy Preferences and attitudes (this will be analyzed in separate study)

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords