Testing Means to Scale Early Childhood Development Interventions in Rural Kenya

How to cite

Luoto, Jill; Garcia, Italo. 2018. "Testing Means to Scale Early Childhood Development Interventions in Rural Kenya." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0002913. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.2913-1.1

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Jill Luoto* , Italo Garcia

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0002913
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.2913-1.1
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2017-08-03 – 2022-05-31
Countries
Private
Secondary IDs
1R01HD090045
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/2913

Abstract

Recent neurobiological and psychological research has established that vital development occurs in language, cognitive, motor and socio-emotional development during the first few years of life, and early life outcomes are key determinants of adult outcomes such as educational achievement, labor market outcomes, and health. Yet more than 200 million children under age five in low and middle income countries (LMICs) will fail to reach their developmental potential as adults, predominantly due to poverty, poor health and nutrition, and inadequate cognitive and psychosocial stimulation. Early childhood development (ECD) interventions that integrate nutrition and child stimulation activities have been proposed as a powerful policy tool for the remediation of early disadvantages in poor settings, and numerous field studies have shown they can be effective in improving children's developmental and health outcomes, at least in the short-term. Key questions remain on what models of delivery are the most effective and cost-effective that can be potentially scalable in LMICs, as well as how to sustain parental behavioral changes over time, which can lead to long-term improvements in child development and the possibility of positive spillovers to benefit younger siblings. Having a better understanding of the underlying behavioral pathways leading from intervention, to parental behavior changes, to child impacts, is also key to inform policy about the optimal design of interventions to maximize their scalability and sustainability. This study will conduct a multi-arm clustered randomized controlled trial across 60 villages and 1200 households in rural Western Kenya that tests different potentially cost-effective delivery models for an ECD intervention with a curriculum that integrates child psychosocial stimulation and nutrition education. Selected households will undergo baseline and follow-up surveys to measure short-term impacts in parental behaviors and children's developmental outcomes, and the study will collect data on potential mediators of parental behavioral change to uncover the pathways leading to impacts. Two follow-up surveys, one immediately after the end of the planned intervention and a second two years later, will enable testing of the short term and midterm sustainability of impacts, as well as the presence of any spillovers onto younger siblings. In collaboration with a local NGO, the Safe Water and AIDS Project (SWAP), community health volunteers (CHVs) will be trained to implement the intervention by introducing the ECD curriculum in their villages.

The goal of this study is to provide policymakers with rigorous evidence of how best to expand ECD interventions in low-resource rural settings.

Intervention

Arm 1 ("group" sessions): Group meetings only
Intervention for Arm 1:
Behavioral: Group sessions
Mother-child dyads in Arm 1 households will receive biweekly ECD sessions for a total of 16 sessions over 7 months. CHVs will record attendance at each session. To maximize participation, prior to each session the CHVs will send an SMS reminder of the session's topic, time and location to all participants.

After the end of the 16 biweekly sessions, we will re-randomize across the 40 intervention villages, stratified by Arms 1 and 2, and half of each of Arm 1 and Arm 2 villages will receive bimonthly booster visits for the period between endline and follow-up surveys.

Arm 2 ("group+home" sessions): Group meetings with a limited number of individual home visits and booster sessions
Intervention for Arm 2:
Behavioral: Group+Home sessions
Households in Arm 2 will receive a total of 16 sessions with identical content similar to Arm 1, but 4 of those sessions will replace group sessions held at the level of villages for personalized home visits, in which the CHV will visit each participant household to deliver these sessions. These home visits will cover identical material and topics as the group sessions in Arm 1 villages, but will be delivered on a personalized basis in the home of the mother and child. Personal barriers to the practices will be discussed and an active resolution strategy developed in concert with the CHV.

After the end of the 16 biweekly sessions, we will re-randomize across the 40 intervention villages, stratified by Arms 1 and 2, and half of each of Arm 1 and Arm 2 villages will receive bimonthly booster visits for the period between endline and follow-up surveys.

Arm 3: No Intervention
This arm will serve as the control group to identify the effects of a parenting intervention and the most effective mode of delivery, as well as the sustained impacts from the intervention

Experimental design

The evaluation design is a factorial assignment and consists of a clustered Randomized Control Trial (cRCT) in which 60 CHVs and their associated villages will be randomly assigned to one of three equally-sized treatment arms. Arms 1 and 2 comprise a 2x2 factorial design, while Arm 3 will serve as a control group. Our experimental design features 3 treatments: group meetings only with some booster sessions (Arm 1), group meetings with a limited number of individual home visits and booster sessions (Arm 2), and the involvement of fathers in the integrated intervention (one half of villages in Arms 1 and 2). All households, including the control group (Arm 3), will receive basic information about child feeding during a baseline survey.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization done in office by computer
Randomization unit
Village Randomization. After all baseline surveys are complete, we will randomly assign the 60 CHVs and their associated villages to one of three study arms. Each arm will have 20 CHVs and 400 households. After assignment to study arm, villages assigned to Arms 1 or 2 will undergo a secondary randomization procedure to determine those villages that additionally will invite fathers to the sessions focused on fathers’ involvement (in a 1:1 ratio among the 40 villages assigned to Arms 1 and 2). All randomizations will be stratified by Jamii center to ensure balance across treatment arms on any village-level characteristics that have the potential to have some relationship with intervention effects.
Clusters
60 villages
Observations
3802 observations (1200 households)
Arms
For the full evaluation, a total of 60 villages-- each arm will have 20 CHVs and 400 households o 20 in Arm 1 (groups only), 20 in Arm 2 (groups plus home visits), and 20 in Arm 3 (Control group) o Among the 40 villages in Arms 1 and 2, 20 will have fathers invited; 20 without fathers invited and only mothers and children are invited
Primary outcomes
Changes in child development, and changes in parental behavior
Secondary outcomes
1. Changes in child growth 2. Changes in preventive health practices 3. Perceived social support 4. Problem solving/social support 5. Maternal Knowledge 6. Maternal Beliefs

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords