Alcohol and Self-Control: A Field Experiment in India

How to cite

Schilbach, Frank. 2018. "Alcohol and Self-Control: A Field Experiment in India." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0002898. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.2898-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Frank Schilbach*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0002898
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.2898-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2014-05-01 – 2014-09-30
Countries
India (Chennai)
JEL codes
D1, D9, O9
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/2898

Abstract

This study considers alcohol consumption among low-income workers in India. In a three-week field experiment, the majority of 229 cycle-rickshaw drivers were willing to forego substantial monetary payments in order to set incentives for themselves to remain sober, thus exhibiting demand for commitment to sobriety. Randomly receiving sobriety incentives significantly reduced daytime drinking while leaving overall drinking unchanged. I find no evidence of higher daytime sobriety significantly changing labor supply, productivity, or earnings. In contrast, increasing sobriety raised savings by 50 percent, an effect that does not appear to be solely explained by changes in income net of alcohol expenditures.

Intervention

In a three-week field experiment with 229 men in Chennai, India, I offered a random subset of individuals financial incentives for sobriety, while a control group received unconditional payments of similar magnitude. The remaining individuals were offered the choice between sobriety incentives and unconditional payments. The randomized nature of the experiment allows me to investigate the impact of increased sobriety on labor market outcomes and savings behavior. To measure the impact of acute intoxication on intertemporal choices, all subjects were provided with a high-return savings opportunity. For a cross-randomized subset of study participants, the savings account was a commitment savings account, i.e. individuals could not withdraw their savings until the end of their participation in the study.

For a detailed description, see here: https://economics.mit.edu/files/14959

Experimental design

229 cycle-rickshaw peddlers working in central Chennai were asked to visit a nearby study office every day for three weeks each. During these daily visits, individuals completed a breathalyzer test and a short survey on labor supply, earnings, and expenditure patterns of the previous day, and alcohol consumption both on the previous day and on the same day before coming to the study office. To study the impact of increased sobriety on savings behavior, we gave all subjects the opportunity to save money at the study office.

Participants were randomly assigned to various treatment groups with the following considerations. First, to create exogenous variation in sobriety, we offered a randomly-selected subsample of study participants financial incentives to visit the study office sober, while the remaining individuals were paid for coming to the study office regardless of their alcohol consumption. Second, to examine the interaction between sobriety incentives and commitment savings, a cross-randomized subset of individuals was provided with a commitment savings account, i.e. a savings account that did not allow them to withdraw their savings until the end of their participation in the study. Third, to identify self-control problems regarding alcohol, a randomly-selected subset of individuals was given the choice between incentives for sobriety and unconditional payments.

The experiment took place between April and September of 2014. 229 cycle-rickshaw peddlers working in central Chennai were asked to visit a nearby study office every day for three weeks each. During these daily visits, individuals completed a breathalyzer test and a short survey on labor supply, earnings, and expenditure patterns of the previous day, and alcohol consumption both on the previous day and on the same day before coming to the study office. To study the impact of increased sobriety on savings behavior, we gave all subjects the opportunity to save money at the study office.

Participants were randomly assigned to various treatment groups with the following considerations. First, to create exogenous variation in sobriety, we offered a randomly-selected subsample of study participants financial incentives to visit the study office sober, while the remaining individuals were paid for coming to the study office regardless of their alcohol consumption. Second, to examine the interaction between sobriety incentives and commitment savings, a cross-randomized subset of individuals was provided with a commitment savings account, i.e. a savings account that did not allow them to withdraw their savings until the end of their participation in the study. Third, to identify self-control problems regarding alcohol, a randomly-selected subset of individuals was given the choice between incentives for sobriety and unconditional payments.

(1) The Control Group was paid Rs. 90 ($1.50) per visit regardless of BAC on days 5 through 19. These participants simply continued with the payment schedule from Phase 1.

(2) The Incentive Group was given incentives to remain sober on days 5 through 19. These payments consisted of Rs. 60 ($1) for visiting the study office and an additional Rs. 60 if the individual was sober as measured by a score of zero on the breathalyzer test. Hence, the payment was Rs. 60 if they arrived at the office with a positive BAC and Rs. 120 if they arrived sober. Given the reported daily labor income of about Rs.\ 300 ($5) in the sample, individuals in the Incentive Group received relatively high-powered incentives for sobriety.

(3) The Choice Group was designed to elicit individuals' demand for sobriety incentives and simultaneously contribute to the estimation of the impact of increased sobriety. To familiarize individuals with the incentives, the Choice Group was given the same incentives as the Incentive Group in Phase 2 (days 5 to 7). Then, right before the start of Phase 3 (day 7) and Phase 4 (day 13), they were asked to choose for the subsequent six study days whether they preferred to continue receiving incentives or to receive unconditional payments ranging from Rs. 90 ($1.50) to Rs. 150 ($2.50), as described below.

For a detailed description of the experiment design, see here: https://economics.mit.edu/files/14959

Design details

Randomization method
In office by computer
Randomization unit
Individual
Clusters
229 individuals
Observations
229 individuals for 20 days each
Arms
83 individuals in Control Group, 71 individuals in Incentive Group, 75 individuals in Choice Group
Primary outcomes
(1) Individuals' savings at the study office; (2) Labor market outcomes (earnings, labor supply, productivity); (3) Demand for commitment to increase sobriety

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords