Trust, Truth, and Selective Exposure to Partisan News
How to cite
Yang, David Y.; Allcott, Hunt; Gentzkow, Matthew. 2018. "Trust, Truth, and Selective Exposure to Partisan News." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0002894. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.2894-4.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Americans are increasingly exposed to news and information that confirms instead of challenges their pre-existing viewpoints. Why do we tend to demand ideologically aligned news? Theory and laboratory evidence suggest two broad groups of mechanisms that may play a key role. The first is psychological mechanisms leading to a “taste for consistency," which entails that partisans will be seek ideologically aligned sources even if this means choosing sources which they know to be less accurate. The second mechanism is rational updating that leads partisans to infer that sources which agree with their prior beliefs are likely to be more accurate. Distinguishing the relative importance of these two mechanisms is crucial for understanding how media consumption will evolve and what changes in policy or platforms will be most likely to lead to more accurate beliefs. We aim to use a field experiment to precisely identify the importance of trust vs. taste for consistency in generating selective exposure.
Intervention
There are two main interventions in the experiment:
1. Incentive treatment: subjects randomly receive different amount of bonus payment if they make correct predictions. The bonus payment ranges from 0, $5, and $25. There is both a within and across subject component of the treatment variation.
2. Information treatment on media outlets' trustworthiness: subjects randomly receive information regarding how trustworthy the media outlets of interest are. The format of the information treatment is the truthful information on the percentage of study participants who could make correct predictions if they were randomly assigned to read news articles from a given outlet. Each treated subjects are informed about two outlets.
Experimental design
There are 7 parts of the experiment:
1. Introducing subjects to the experiment, and consent
2. Collecting demographic information and subjects' political positions
3. Asking subjects general questions regarding trust and readership on the media outlets of interest
4. Introducing subjects to prediction questions, and randomly assign subjects to read articles from one of the media outlets of interest before they make the prediction
5. Eliciting subjects' prior beliefs on the percentage of study participants who can make correct predictions, if they are assigned to each of the news outlets of interest
6. Information treatment that provides truthful information on two of the outlets (or placebo if in the control group)
7. Eliciting subjects' posterior beliefs on the percentage of study participants who can make correct predictions
8. Subjects are asked to make two additional predictions, and they can read articles from the media outlets of their choice beforehand. Subjects are randomized into 3 groups: (1) no incentive in 1st question, $5 incentive in 2nd question; (2) no incentive in 1st question, $25 incentive in 2nd question; and (3) $5 incentives in both groups.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.