Impact evaluation of a performance-based financing project in the health sector in the Democratic Republic of Congo
How to cite
Shapira, Gil; Fink, Günther. 2018. "Impact evaluation of a performance-based financing project in the health sector in the Democratic Republic of Congo." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0002880. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.2880-1.1
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
The study evaluates the impacts of a Performance-Based Financing (PBF) program introduced in selected districts in the Democratic Republic of Congo. The program was introduced in the context of the “Health Systems Strengthening for Better Maternal and Child Health Results” project that is financially supported by the World Bank, the Health Results Innovation Trust Fund and other partners such as USAID, GFF, and the Global Fund. The main goal of the project is to improve coverage and quality of maternal and child health services in targeted areas through providing contracted health facilities with performance payments according to defined quantity and quality indicators.
The objectives of the impact evaluation are to: (a) identify the impact of the PBF approach on service utilization, quality of care, and health outcomes, and (b) identify key factors responsible for this impact. The study will evaluate The overall impact of the PBF approach as well as compare outcomes when program design elements are varied.
Intervention
Performance payments will be made to health service providers and health administration units contracted in the target areas. Public, quasi-public and private health facilities, including health centers and first level referral hospitals, will be targeted in rural and urban areas. The purchasing, verification, community mobilization and coaching will be organized through provincial purchasing agencies (EUPs: Etablissement d’utilité publique). PBF payments will be paid to these health facilities in proportion to, and in payment for, achieved quantity and quality results. Facility payments will be based on (i) the quantity of services defined through a package of basic and complementary activities delivered to the targeted population, and (ii) the technical quality of these services as measured through comprehensive quantified quality checklists. Facility payments will be made quarterly after service volumes have been verified and quality of technical support and care has been assessed and certified by the EUPs, and validated through special governing boards at the provincial level. After the quantity and quality of services provided are certified, payment will be released to contracted health facilities via fundholding arrangements.
Modified quality checklists (quality incentives): An innovative aspect of the PBF approach in DRC will involve the content of the quality checklist that will be used for assessing the quality of care in health centers and hospitals. The amount of money paid for the quantity of services can be increased by up to 25% according to the quarterly quality score, if the facility exceeds the threshold score of 50%. In addition to determining the payment amount to facilities, the quality checklist also provides guidelines for good practice and structures the supervision of the facilities by the staff of the health zones. The study will evaluate the use of different types of quality checklists at different sets of health facilities. All checklists will include measure of structural quality, process and content of care. Examples of measures of structural quality are: proper storage of drugs, cleanliness of the facility and existence of required registries and protocols. Measures of process and content of care include indicators such as correct entries into registries and medical records and checking these records for proper application of the protocols. In selected health facilities, ‘Vignettes Quality Checklist’ will also include healthcare providers’ responses to clinical vignettes as indicators of quality of care. The vignettes will cover cases that represent the most common causes of morbidity and mortality and will be repeated each quarter. It is theorized that the quarterly repetition of these cases will reinforce the protocol related to these common cases. However, these measures are also a limited in representing quality of care as there might be a gap between what providers know and do when they are actually treating the patients.
Experimental design
The research questions will be answered employing randomized assignment of the different project components. The PBF intervention will be randomly assigned at the health zone level while the quality checklist intervention will be assigned at the catchment area level (Health zones have an average of about 10 catchment area with at least one health center in each catchment area).
Design details
Papers from this trial
- Shapira, G., Clarke-Deelder, E., Booto, B.M. et al. Impacts of performance-based financing on health system performance: evidence from the Democratic Republic of Congo. BMC Med 21, 381 (2023). https://link.springer.com/article/10.1186/s12916-023-03062-8#article-info
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.