Experimental evaluation of Semillas de Apego, a group-based program to foster maternal mental health and early childhood development among violence exposed communities in Colombia.

How to cite

Moya, Andres. 2018. "Experimental evaluation of Semillas de Apego, a group-based program to foster maternal mental health and early childhood development among violence exposed communities in Colombia.." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0002868. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.2868-3.1

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Andres Moya*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0002868
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.2868-3.1
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2018-03-09 – 2020-12-15
Countries
Colombia (Latinamerica)
JEL codes
C93, I15, I25, O12
Secondary IDs
Registered at ClinicalTrials.gov on 04/09/2018 - registry number pending
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/2868

Abstract

Over half a million children between 0 and 5 years of age in Colombia have been affected by a civil conflict that has spanned over six decades. Exposure to violence during early childhood may have devastating consequences on early childhood cognitive and socio-emotional development.
The devastating effects of violence on early childhood development occur through two different and complementary channels: First, excessive stress stemming from the exposure violence and other early childhood adversities disrupts the architecture of the developing brain (NSCDC, 2005) and inhibits the appropriate functioning of the body’s stress-response system. Second, violence brings about a legacy of poverty and psychological trauma (Ibañez & Moya, 2010; Moya, 2018), which undermines the primary caregivers’ capacity to form healthy emotional bonds with their children and increases the likelihood of extreme neglect (Lieberman and Van Horn, 2011; Cuartas, Harker, & Moya, 2015). This means that children’s development is at risk even if they are not exposed to violence directly; for example, if their parents had been victimized previously. Taken together, violence can impair the development of key cognitive and socio-emotional abilities therefore compromising the right to lead healthy and productive lives for thousands of children in Colombia.
Protecting children from effects of violence, toxic stress, and deficits in family care is therefore one of the key challenges as Colombia transitions into a post-conflict stage and for the construction of a more equal and peaceful society. More generally, identifying cost effective ways to guarantee children’s cognitive and socioemotional development is a key challenge in contexts of violence and humanitarian crises around the world.
In this trial, we evaluate the effectiveness of Semillas de Apego, a group-based psychosocial program for victimized caregivers with children 2 to 5 in Colombia, a country devastated by decades of civil violence. The program builds upon recent evidence on the positive effects of different interventions that limit the harmful consequences of childhood stress in the United States through the promotion of maternal mental health and healthy child-parent emotional bonds (Lieberman & Van Horn, 2011; Singla, Kumbakumba, & Aboud, 2015; Rahman et al., 2013). Together, this evidence suggests a promising path to protect early childhood development in contexts of extreme adversity through the attention to their caregivers.
Semillas de Apego seeks to promote healthy child-parent attachments as a pathway for a proper development among children exposed to violence. By fostering caregivers’ mental health and their capacity to become a source of emotional protection, the intervention helps children reach their full potential amid such traumatic circumstances. Delivered over 15 weekly group sessions, program first provides tools so that victimized caregivers can start processing their own trauma. Then, the program focuses on allowing a proper understanding of the child’s development trajectories and how they affected by the experience of adversities (such as violence exposure). Finally, it aims to foster positive child-rearing practices. Taken together, Semillas de Apego’s curriculum seeks to promote maternal mental health and the healthy child-parent attachments that translate into appropriate affect regulation and healthy emotional development in the midst of adverse circumstances.
The current trial will be conducted in Tumaco, a municipality in Colombia heavily affected by violence and poverty. Over a time-span of 23 months, we will follow the implementation of Semillas de Apego with 40 groups of 16 participants each, all of them mothers or primary caregivers of children 2 to 5. This will allow us to reach a total of 640 participants and their children. The impact evaluation will be based on a cluster- randomized control trial in which we will assign eligible subjects, nested within 18 child development centers, to either an intervention arm or a control group. The former group will participate in 15 group-led session over the period of 3 months; the latter will continue to have access to the regular early childhood programs offered through the centers to which children are affiliated. Data will be collected at baseline and two follow-ups: 1 and 12 months after the implementation has concluded. We hypothesize that the program will have a positive and sequential impact on the following dimensions: (i) primary caregiver’s mental health, (ii) child rearing practices, (iii) quality of child-parent emotional bond, (iv) children’s mental health, and (v) children’s cognitive and socioemotional development.

Intervention

Semillas de Apego is a group-based psychosocial program for victimized caregivers with children 2 to 5 in Colombia, a country devastated by violence. The program’s builds upon scientific evidence on (i) the way in which violence hinders early childhood development and erodes mothers’ mental health and their capacity to form nurturing relationships with their children, and (ii) the effectiveness of promoting healthy child-parent attachments to mitigate the effects of toxic stress on toddlers (Lieberman and Van Horn, 2011).
Semillas de Apego aims to foster the healthy child-parent attachments that promote appropriate affect regulation and healthy emotional development in the midst of adverse circumstances. For this purpose, the program first provides tools so that victimized caregivers can better understand their emotional and behavioral reactions to violence and can process their own trauma. Then, the program focuses on allowing a proper understanding of the child’s development trajectories and how they are silently being affected by the experience of adversities (such as violence exposure). Finally, the curriculum works towards fostering child-rearing good practices.
The program will be implemented through 15-weekly sessions among groups of 14 to 16 participants, who are mothers or primary caregivers of children 2 to 5. The sessions follow a detailed curriculum, which was developed in partnership between the Child Trauma Research Program at the University of California, San Francisco and our team at Universidad de los Andes. The original curriculum was first designed and adapted to the Colombian context between 2014 and 2015, based on the group-based Child Parent Psychotherapy curriculum (Reyes and Lieberman, 2010). In 2015 we conducted a small pilot test to assess the program’s validity. Based on the lessons that followed from this pilot test, we made further adaptations to the curriculum and developed a training manual for facilitators. Finally, between January and February 2018, we conducted a final adaptation to incorporate cultural and social practices that are common in Tumaco, Colombia, the implementation site of this trial.
Semillas de Apego will be delivered through the 18 Early Childhood Development Centers (ECDC) that are run by Genesis Foundation, our implementation partner, in the urban area of Tumaco. Currently, these ECDC serve over 2,000 children 0 to 5. Assignment into the program will follow a cluster-based randomization. In particular, we will first randomly select the Centers in which Semillas de Apego will implemented, and then we will randomly assign among eligible subjects within the treated and control centers to either arm. . We discuss this in more detail below.
Participants will be selected two to three weeks prior to the starting date of the program. Selection will be based using administrative data from Genesis Foundation. We will use this information to randomly assign a total of 640 mothers or primary care givers into the program and 640 into a control group. Participants will be assigned to a 16-member group intervention group in the ECDC closest to their residence. Groups will meet once per week for approximately 3 hours per session.
Subjects assigned to the control group, and those in centers assigned to the intervention but not randomly selected to participate in the program, will continue benefiting from the services available to all families affiliated with child development centers in the municipality of the intervention.
Due to local operation and implementation restrictions, the program will be delivered in four sequential cohorts of approximately 160 participants in the intervention arm and 160 participants in the control arm per cohort. The total number of intervention groups will vary per cohort starting with 9 groups in each of the two cohorts of 2018 and increasing to 12 groups for each of the two cohorts in 2019. After the implementation of these four sequential cohorts, we will reach 640 participants in the intervention arm, and 640 subjects in the control arm.
The implementation of the program will be led by a team of six social workers who participated in a three-week intensive training. The team of trained social workers will be assigned into three dyads. Each dyad will lead the implementation of the program among 3 to 4 groups per cohort and complete implementation and debriefing logs on the progress of the session and the participants. The implementation team, in addition, will be supervised by three expert coaches on a weekly basis. The supervision scheme aims to guarantee the quality and fidelity of the intervention but also to provide reflexive support to mitigate burn-out and symptoms of vicarious trauma.
To ensure adherence, we will implement the following actions: First, sessions will be held during a day and time convened with the participants. Second, community health workers will make weekly phone calls to follow-up on each participant’s needs and progress and encourage attendance. We followed this strategy during the implementation pilot and observed that 94% of the mothers who participated in the program completed all the sessions.

Experimental design

The experimental evaluation of Semillas de Apego will be conducted as a Cluster-Randomized Control Trial (C-RCT). The eligible population for the study are all families served by Genesis Foundation’s ECDC in Tumaco, Colombia and whose children’s ages range between 2 to 4 years of age. For example, for the first cohort, the children should have been born between August 1st, 2014 to April 1st, 2016.
Random assignment to the treatment will be conducted at the ECDC level (n=19). We eliminated one of these EDCD because it did not provide the infrastructure required to run the group sessions – a private space. However, this center is not different than the other 18 ECDC over a range of observable characteristics. Out of the remaining 18 EDCD, we conducted a random assignment based on the ECD’s size, age-range, gender and anthropometrics of eligible children, the size of the center, and a composite socio-economic status score. In doing so, 9 ECDC to were selected to run the implementation, while the other 9 remaining centers were assigned to the control arm.
Within each center assigned to the treatment arm in each cohort, the total number of families invited to participate in the program, and the number of intervention groups, will be based on the number of children served by the center relative to the total number of children served by the 18 EDCD in Tumaco. Then, we will distribute the treated ECDC and intervention groups across the 4 cohorts, ensuring that each ECDC has at least one intervention group per year. Hence, larger ECDC in the treatment arm will have one or more intervention groups in each of the 4 cohorts, whereas the smaller ECDC will have at least one intervention group in 2018 and another one in 2019.
For each treated ECDC in each cohort, we will randomly order eligible subjects within each center to be invited to participate in the intervention and invite then to participate according to this ordered list. Invitations will be carried out by the team of six social workers starting three weeks prior to the start of the intervention. Eligible subjects will be contacted at the EDCD or by phone and will be informed of the objectives and structure of the program, the schedule of the group sessions, and the potential benefits, including small incentives (super market cash cards or other incentives for up to US$8) for completing each phase of the data collection.
Eligible subjects will also be informed that their decision to participate or not in Semillas de Apego and the data collection does not have any consequence on access to Genesis Foundation’s programs in the municipality, including their children’s access to the ECDC, or their participation in standard community groups and activities. Once eligible subjects accept to participate, they will be contacted by the data collection firm, which will coordinate the date and time of the baseline data collection.
We will follow a similar strategy in the EDCD assigned to the control arm. We will first calculate the number of families that were invited to participate in the program based on the number of children served by the center relative to the total number of children served by the 18 EDCD in Tumaco. Then, we will distribute the ECDC across the 4 cohorts, ensuring that in each ECDC we assemble control groups at least once per year. Hence, larger ECDC in the control arm will have one or more control groups in each of the 4 cohorts, whereas the smaller ECDC will have at least one control group in 2018 and another one in 2019.
Then, we will randomly order eligible subjects within each center to be invited to participate in the different phases of data collection. Invitations will be carried out by the data collection team three weeks prior to the start of the intervention. Eligible subjects will be contacted at the EDCD or by phone and will be informed of the objectives and structure of the data collection and the potential benefits, including small incentives (super market cash cards for up to US$8) for completing the data collection.
Eligible subjects will also be informed that their decision to participate in the data collection does not have any consequence on access to Genesis Foundation’s programs in the municipality, including their children’s access to the ECDC, or their participation in standard community groups and activities.
All randomization procedures will be conducted using the RANDOMIZE module (Kennedy & Mann, 2015), available in Stata 15. In doing so, we achieve balance on key characteristics at each phase of the randomization procedure.

Design details

Randomization method
All randomization procedures will be conducted using the RANDOMIZE module (Kennedy & Mann, 2015), available in Stata 15.
Randomization unit
1st stage/level: Early Childhood Development Center. 2nd stage/level: individual - primary caregiver
Clusters
18 (9 per treatment arm).
Observations
40 groups of 16 participants in treatment and 640 participants in the control arm: n = 1280
Arms
9 Early Childhood Development Centers
Primary outcomes
We identify five different constructs as primary outcomes for the program. According to the program’s theory of change, we should observe effects in these different constructs in a sequential way. In particular, we expect that the program will bring about positive effects in some dimensions during the implementation of the 15-week program; for instance, in the maternal mental health and child rearing practices domains. Additionally, we expect that effects on other dimensions, such as early childhood development, will build up and become salient at the second follow-up assessment. For this reason, we will conduct two rounds of follow-up data collection that will take place one (1) month and twelve (12) months after the 15-week program has concluded, . This will enable us to observe the short and medium run impacts of the intervention. The five primary outcomes and the hypothesis that guide this evaluation are: 1) Primary caregiver’s mental health: Participation in the intervention arm of the evaluation will generate a reduction in the number of emotional symptoms reported by caregivers one month after the intervention has been completed (first follow-up) and one year after the end of the intervention (second follow-up) 2) Child rearing practices: Participation in the intervention arm of the evaluation will generate an increment in the number and type of reported child-rearing practices implemented by caregivers right after the end of the intervention (first follow-up). These effects will persist one year after the end of the intervention (second follow-up). 3) Healthy child-parent emotional bonds: Participation in the intervention arm of the evaluation will lower the stress in the child parent relationship (first follow-up) and will generate a positive effect in the quality of the attachment relationship between caregiver and children one year after the end of the intervention (second follow-up). 4) Children’s mental health: Participation in the intervention arm of the evaluation will generate a positive effect in the caregivers’ report of child mental health in the medium run; 12 months after the end of the intervention (second follow-up). 5) Child’s cognitive, social, and emotional development. Participation in the intervention arm of the evaluation will generate a positive effect in children’s’ cognitive and socioemotional development in the medium run; 12 months after the end of the intervention (second follow-up).
Secondary outcomes
Owing to the sequential follow-up design we have designed for these trial, we characterize unexpected differences in our child and relational outcomes at the first-follow up as secondary outcomes. As such, we postulate that positive differences in: (i) Quality emotional relationships measured by observation of the interaction, (ii) child´s mental health, measured with the TSCYC and BITSEA, and (iii) child´s cognitive and socioemotional development, measured with the PSRA. While unpredicted according to our theory of change, positive differences could be observed at this phase of data collection. If present, we will report these findings as secondary outcomes.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords