Personal Financial Planning and Willpower Among Manufacturing Workers: Experimental Evidence from an Ethiopian Industrial Park
How to cite
Meyer, Christian Johannes. 2018. "Personal Financial Planning and Willpower Among Manufacturing Workers: Experimental Evidence from an Ethiopian Industrial Park." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0002806. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.2806-2.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Jobs in the garmenting industry are often seen as a potential pathway out of poverty for low-skill workers in developing countries, not least because they provide a stable income. The ability of workers to translate this stable income into welfare gains, however, depends on their ability to make financial decisions that are in their own short- and long-term interests. In this study, I work with women who start a job in a large industrial park outside Addis Ababa, Ethiopia. I design an intervention with the goal of helping them plan their finances, track their income and consumption, and follow through on self-set financial goals. Theoretically, the plan can be seen as a cognitive rule that relies on self-monitoring. I cross-randomize a light-touch information intervention designed to make workers "sophisticated" regarding their time preferences. Ultimately, I hope to improve workers' confidence in their own ability to manage their finances and their exercise of self-control. I primarily plan to analyze the intent-to-treat effects of these interventions (and their interaction) on individual consumption and savings decisions. I also plan to study measures of self-confidence that would speak to a theoretical framework in which workers' confidence in their own willpower may increase as a result of following the plan. As a secondary set of outcomes, I plan to use the longitudinal structure of the data to examine the relationship of economic circumstances, stress and affective states, and time preferences.
Intervention
The main intervention of this study involves a financial planning exercise. As part of this exercise, workers are given a "personal financial journal" in the form of a small notebook. Workers are encouraged to use this journal to track of their progress vis-a-vis self-set goals.
Additionally, I cross-randomize a light-touch information intervention in which a subset of surveyed workers is informed about their own time preferences as measured in baseline survey.
This experiment is conducted as part of a larger data collection exercise registered in the AEA RCT Registry with ID AEARCTR-0002555. There is a sister paper, also part the same data collection effort and also registered with the AEA RCT Registry, entitled: "The Devil Is in The Pre-Tales: A Closer Look at Women's First Months in Industrial Work", that uses the same experimental design, but is primarily concerned with documenting the experience of newly hired women working in Ethiopian manufacturing.
Experimental design
I collect data in four steps: First, I conduct a lab-in-the-field experiment and baseline survey. Second, I follow workers using biweekly phone calls. Third, I repeat the lab-in-the-field experiment together with an endline survey. Fourth, I obtain administrative data from firm personnel records and for transactions on workers' bank accounts.
All primary data is collected using CAPI with ODK on Android tablet computers. All survey materials are translated into Amharic. All subjects are expected to speak Amharic to be eligble for work in the industrial park. Enumerators speak both Amharic and Oromiffa and can translate if needed.
At baseline, all study participants will be randomly assigned to one of five groups:
(1) a SURVEY CONTROL group in which we conduct baseline, high-frequency follow-up and endline surveys;
(2) a PLAN group in which we conduct the surveys, administer the personal financial planning exercise, and provide the financial planning booklet to subjects;
(3) an INFORMATION group in which we conduct the surveys and administer a light-touch information treatment on respondent time preferences;
(4) a PLAN + INFORMATION in which we conduct the surveys and administer both interventions;
and (5) a PURE CONTROL group in which we do not conduct any surveys or administer any treatment, but only rely on administrative data on each subject.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.