The effect of personalized and standardized finance trainings on small business owners

How to cite

Seitz, Helke; Menkhoff, Prof. Dr. Lukas; Grohmann, Dr. Antonia. 2018. "The effect of personalized and standardized finance trainings on small business owners." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0002785. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.2785-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Helke Seitz* , Prof. Dr. Lukas Menkhoff , Dr. Antonia Grohmann

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0002785
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.2785-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2017-09-03 – 2018-12-03
Countries
Private
JEL codes
D14, O12, L25
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/2785

Abstract

In this study we examine two different financial trainings and compare them against each other. The first financial training is a “rule of thumb” based training that is designed especially for small business owners. The training tries to improve financial behaviors of business owners with a strong focus on improving investment strategies. It also informs about savings, borrowing and risk diversification as means to reach good investment practices. For the second training the content is the same as for the rules of thumbs training but it additionally provides personalized feedback on business owners past financial performance and practices. In addition there is a control group that receives a health and safety related training. We perform these trainings in Kampala, Uganda. Our participants are 500 small and micro entrepreneurs.

Intervention

We conduct the intervention with roughly 500 small and micro business owners in Kampala. Business owners were chosen at random out of a full listing of all small and micro business owners in the urban area. The listing was generated in the following way: In order to select sampling zones, we identified predominantly business zones based on interviews with the local administration. Based on 220 identified business zones, 21 zones were randomly selected for a door-to-door screening which resulted in 5,800 enterprises being listed. The screening survey identified enterprises with up to 10 employees and with a fix location. Finally, a first sample of 450 enterprises was drawn in 2012 with 200 enterprises in each retail and manufacturing sectors and 50 in services sectors. Replacements are drawn from the full list each year.
In order to conduct the trainings, we visit all business owners in their business, where trained enumerators present the respective information using a tablet. Information was presented in the business owners preferred language (English or Luganda). After the training session, which lasts for about 45 minutes, we left a booklet that contains all the information that was presented.
The treatment took place in October and November 2017.

Experimental design

The intervention builds on a survey of micro and small enterprises (MSEs) collected by the German Institute of Global and Area Studies (GIGA) and the German Institute for Economics Research (DIW) in Uganda.
We randomized business owners into the three groups based on the 2016 wave of the survey. To assign treatment groups, we separated the sample into strata based on business sectors. The treatment assignment was done using STATA. The baseline survey for this treatment was collected in October 2017. After conducting the baseline survey, a different team went back to the business owners to conduct the treatments. The team that collected the baseline survey was unaware of the business owner’s treatment status.
Standardized (Rule of thumb) treatment: This treatment group received information on financial concepts that are related to investing, savings, borrowing, risk diversification and separating household and business. These treatments were designed to be simple and interactive. They are also designed to address the needs of small business owners. There were 165 participants in this group
Personalized feedback treatment: This groups received all the information that the rule of thumb treatment received, but in addition are given feedback on their own past behavior. Personalized feedback is given just after they were confronted with a corresponding rule of thumb. There were 167 participants in this group.
Control group: the groups received information on health and safety related to business. This training was designed to last about as long as the other trainings. The colors and the layout had a similar design to the other treatments. There were 168 participants in this group.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization was stratified by business sector and was done using STATA.
Randomization unit
Randomization was done on the business level
Clusters
No cluster
Observations
500 micro and small businesses
Arms
Treatment "Rule of Thumb": Actual size: 165 Treatment "Personalized Feedback": Actual size: 167 Control: Actual size: 168
Primary outcomes
i) business profits, ii) business investment, iii) uptake of credit for the business, iv) savings (amounts and goals)
Secondary outcomes
i) financial numeracy, measured by a set of standard questions to asses respondents ability to perform calculations related to finance ii) financial awareness, which measures awareness of certain financial products, iii) financial attitude and perception, which measures how people deal with certain financial situations, iv) planning, this measures whether someone is planning to invest in the future, v) record keeping, this measures if a business owner keeps records in their business, vi) separation of business and household. Here we will measure if someone keeps business and their household separate and also check if the business owner pays himself/herself a salary, vii) we will also look at reflection and impulsiveness

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords