Incentives: Evidence from Uganda
How to cite
Katreniak, Dagmara Celik. 2019. "Incentives: Evidence from Uganda." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0002781. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.2781-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Throughout our lives, we are routinely offered different incentives as a way to motivate us. Many researchers have studied the effects of incentives on people’s performance. There can also be important psychological outcomes in terms of stress and happiness. The current project contributes to the literature by explicitly accounting for this performance-versus-well-being trade-off introduced by incentives. In total four different incentives and their interactions were provided to students. Such cross-cutting design allows me to study the complementarities of the incentives. Additional outcome of tee project is to study the role of feedback in shaping subjects' expectations. Finally, having friendship network structure of each student within his/her class allows me to study how various competitive environments influence group formations in classes at different school levels.
Intervention
I implement two types of social comparative feedback regimes, within and across-class group comparisons, and two types of incentive regimes, financial and reputation rewards. I also allow for their interaction. In total, eight different treatment groups are formed. More than 5000 primary and secondary school students in Uganda, who were repeatedly tested and interviewed over one academic year. In total, five testing rounds were administered between January and December 2012.
Experimental design
Students were randomly assigned to two feedback treatment groups and a control group. Students in the within-class feedback group (within) were randomly divided into units of three to four classmates and evaluated as units (using the unit averages) within their respective classes. Students in the within group received feedback about their own performance, the performance of their unit members, and the relative position of their unit within their class. Moreover, they received detailed information about whether they and the position of their unit have improved or worsened from one testing round to the next.
Students in the across-class feedback group (across) were evaluated as a class (using the class average) and were compared to other classes of the same grade in the district. Students in the across group received feedback about their own performance, the average performance of their class, the relative position of their class with respect to other classes, and whether they and/or their class have improved or worsened between two subsequent testing rounds
Students in the control group received no information but only took exams. In order to motivate all students to participate in the experiment, we began our visits reminding students that the exams serve as an additional practice for national leaving examinations (which are compulsory for seventh graders in primary schools and fourth and sixth graders in secondary schools).
In order to study the effects of monetary and non-monetary rewards, students were orthogonally re-randomized at the school level into a tournament for financial or reputational rewards. Re-randomization took place after round 4 and students had no information about tournaments beforehand. The qualification criteria differed based on initial randomization into treatments but the general rule was to reward the 15% best performing students/units/classes, and the 15% most improved students/units/classes. In order to avoid confusion, students were given exact information regarding the number of winning students/units/classes. Therefore, all students, despite the class size or treatment allocation, had the same probability of winning. Students in the monetary reward treatment groups could win 2,000 UGX (about .80 USD). Students in the reputational reward group could receive a certificate and their names were announced in the most popular local newspaper in the region, Bukedde.
Overall, the orthogonal randomization divided the sample into 9 groups – one control group, four sole treatment groups (i.e., one type of treatment only) and four combined treatment groups (two types of feedback interacted with two types of rewards). Such cross-cutting design allows me to compare the impact of feedback and reward incentives on students’ performance expectations and their well-being, and to study the complementarities of feedback and rewards.
Design details
Papers from this trial
- Katreniak Celik, Dagmara. 2019. “Persistent overconfidence: evidence from a field experiment in Uganda.” Working paper. https://docs.google.com/viewer?a=v&pid=sites&srcid=ZGVmYXVsdGRvbWFpbnxkYXNhY2VsaWt8Z3g6MzI3MmUxMDhlMGEzZWM2Yg
- Katreniak Celik, Dagmara. 2019. “Dark side of incentives: evidence from a field experiment in Uganda.” CERGE-EI https://sites.google.com/site/dasacelik/DarkSideOfIncentives_Celik_JMP.pdf?attredirects=0
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.