Evaluation of the Di Lottery RCT (Burkina Faso)
How to cite
Ksoll, Christopher; Bambio, Yiriyibin. 2018. "Evaluation of the Di Lottery RCT (Burkina Faso)." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0002718. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.2718-3.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Access to irrigated land is a key factor in determining a household's income and its food security in rural parts of Africa. The construction of large-scale irrigation perimeters comprising networks of primary, secondary and tertiary canals and often times pumping stations is one avenue to providing access to irrigated land on a large scale. From 2009 to 2014, the Millennium Challenge Corporation (MCC) invested around 100M USD into the construction of an irrigated perimeter in the Boucle du Mouhoun region of Burkina Faso, the Di perimeter. After the original owners of the land were compensated through higher quality but smaller plots of land, MCC distributed 710 hectares of irrigated land via a public lottery, called the Di Lottery.
Five hundred and three Di Lottery winners were randomly selected among 1,528 participants. Lottery winners received leases for 710 hectares of irrigated land in the Di perimeter, training in agricultural technologies for irrigated land, and starter kits (land preparation, materials and inputs). Lottery winners are the treatment group. The 1,025 lottery participants who did not win the lottery constitute the lottery control group. In addition, there are applicants who were not admitted to the lottery because they did not meet an application score eligibility cutoff. These are a second control group for an RD design. Based on baseline data collected by a previous evaluator prior to the lottery, baseline observable characteristics of lottery winners and non-winners are balanced and have similar means.
The lottery offered plots of 2 hectares for rice or 1 hectare for polyculture, and participants disclosed their plot preferences prior to the lottery. About one-third of the households that participated in the lottery received land.
We will analyze the effect of winning the Di Lottery on agricultural practices, production, total agricultural income, overall household income and land tenure security by using the framework of a randomized control trial (RCT). Our analysis will incorporate lottery participants' plot preference, will interview members of both parts of split households, and will administer survey questions on communal land rights. We will undertake two rounds of quantitative data collection.
first round will be in October 2017. It will cover the 2017 planting season. The final round will be in 2020.
[UPDATE SEP 2018] The interim data collection took place in the first few months of 2018.
At a cost in U.S. dollars of about $39,700 (without Compact administration costs) or $45,000 (with Compact administration costs) per hectare, the benefit of winning the lottery ranks as one of the largest stakes in any RCT that we know of. For more detail, please see
Ksoll et al. "Evaluation of the Burkina Faso Agriculture Development Project: Design Report." Washington, DC: Mathematica Policy Research, June 2017.
Ksoll et al. "Evaluation of the Burkina Faso Agriculture Development Project: Baseline Report." Washington, DC: Mathematica Policy Research, April 2018.
Intervention
Access to irrigated land is a key factor in determining a household's income and its food security in rural parts of Africa. The construction of large-scale irrigation perimeters comprising networks of primary, secondary and tertiary canals and often times pumping stations is one avenue to providing access to irrigated land on a large scale. From 2009 to 2014, the Millennium Challenge Corporation (MCC) invested around 100M USD into the construction of an irrigated perimeter in the Boucle du Mouhoun region of Burkina Faso, the Di perimeter. After the original owners of the land were compensated through higher quality but smaller plots of land, MCC distributed 710 hectares of irrigated land via a public lottery, called the Di Lottery.
Five hundred and three Di Lottery winners were randomly selected among 1,528 lottery participants, with an additional 650-701 applicants not admitted to the lottery. Lottery winners received leases for 710 hectares of irrigated land in the Di perimeter, training in agricultural technologies for irrigated land, starter kits (land preparation, materials and inputs) and land tenure documents. Lottery winners are the treatment group. The 1,025 lottery participants who did not win the lottery constitute the first control group. The 650-701 applicants who were not admitted to the lottery are a second control group. The lottery offered plots of 2 hectares for rice or 1 hectare for polyculture, and participants disclosed their plot preferences prior to the lottery. About one-third of the households that participated in the lottery received land.
We will analyze the effect of winning the Di Lottery on agricultural practices, production, total agricultural income, overall household income and land tenure security by using the framework of a randomized control trial (RCT). Our analysis will incorporate lottery participants' plot preference, will interview members of both parts of split households, and will administer survey questions on communal land rights. We will undertake two rounds of quantitative data collection. The first round will be in October Februay/March 2018. It will cover the 2017 planting season, roughly between June 2016 and May 207. The final round will be in 2020.
Experimental design
Recruiting applicants and selecting Di Lottery beneficiaries was a multi-step process. The lottery was announced over the radio, with posters and through postings in local administrations (town halls). The ADP invited individuals to apply for the lottery who were (1) not PAPs; (2) 18 years of age or older; (3) residents of one of the six provinces of the Boucle du Mouhoun region (Kossi, Banwa, Mouhoun, Bale, Nayala, Sourou); and (4) able to list at least two other people age 15 or older who could cultivate the plot of land with the applicant. Initially, 2,178 of the applicants were determined to meet all four criteria. However, applicants were allowed to contest the decision and ask for a review. As a result, an additional 51 applicants were deemed eligible, bringing the total to 2,229 eligible applicants.
Among eligible applicants, admission to the lottery was determined through a points-based system designed to (1) select applicants with higher expected benefits (for example, applicants received more points when they owned certain machinery); and (2) meet distributional objectives (for example, female applicants and younger applicants received additional points).
Applicants provided the following information as part of their application package:
-Number of household members aged 15 and above who would be available to could help with work on the land
-Applicant's experience with irrigation
-Any ownership of irrigated land in other AMVS perimeters
-Participation in MCC-sponsored training activity
-Age and gender of the applicant
-Type of agricultural equipment owned by the applicant
-Level of debt
-Location of residence
Applicants were aware of the four eligibility criteria, the information they were scored on, and the associated scores, but they were not initially aware of the exact threshold that would determine participation in the lottery. In order to make the selection process transparent, all application information was made public in multiple locations (for example, at local town halls). The accuracy of the application documents was verified by the training implementer, for example, by cross-checking debt with farmers' cooperatives and land ownership with water-user associations.
The cut-off for participation in the lottery was set at 60 points. Given the number of male and female applicants scoring 60 points or more, this cutoff made it highly probable that at least 20 percent of beneficiaries would be female. Applicants with a score of 60 and above participated in the public lottery, which was held in February 2014. The lottery was conducted by the national lottery company LONAB (Loterie Nationale Burkinabe) and validated by a cabinet of lawyers.
Because there were two standard types of plots for which leases were distributed, applicants had to rank the two types of plots as their first and second choices. One plot was two hectares of land suitable for cultivating rice, and the other was one hectare that was suitable for polyculture. Just under 10 percent of the applicants stated that they would not accept a second choice.
We compare outcomes of lottery winners to outcomes of non-lottery winners. We account for different probabilities of selection because the probability of winning the lottery depended on preferences for rice and polyculture plots. In addition, in some households there were multiple applicants for the lottery. We also drop multiple applicant households in some analyses.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.