Complementarities in microcredit and financial services interventions for financial inclusion and empowerment: evidence from randomized evaluation in South West Nigeria

How to cite

Olajide, Damilola; Alzua, Maria Laura. 2018. "Complementarities in microcredit and financial services interventions for financial inclusion and empowerment: evidence from randomized evaluation in South West Nigeria." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0002705. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.2705-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Damilola Olajide* , Maria Laura Alzua

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0002705
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.2705-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2017-08-21 – 2019-05-31
Countries
Private
JEL codes
C93, G21, I32
Secondary IDs
DPW1/1023
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/2705

Abstract

The intervention being evaluated is the Amoye Digital Microcredit Initiative for Women Empowerment, in collaboration with a microfinance provider; Amoye Microfinance Bank, Ikere Ekiti Nigeria. The intervention offers microcredit alone and microcredit combined with digital banking services to clients. The key objective of study is to assess the effectiveness of the interventions, paying particularly attention to whether microcredit combined with digital banking services offers incremental impacts over what the demand side alone (microcredit) would have offered. The main identification strategy is a randomized control trial, involving random allocation of eligible beneficiaries into two treatments: microcredit only, microcredit + digital financial services, and a control group. The experimental design to examine spillover effects follows a clustered Randomized Saturation design. At least 75 clusters per block are required to generate sufficient power (min 0.80) and effect size (0.20) to examine the main research questions, leading to a total of 375 clusters. Findings will provide evidence informing Nigeria’s national financial inclusion and gender empowerment policy.

Intervention

The intervention being evaluated is the Amoye Digital Microcredit Initiative for Women Empowerment, in collaboration with a microfinance provider; Amoye Microfinance Bank, Ikere Ekiti Nigeria (AMfB). The intervention offers small microloan alone, and microloan combined with access to digital banking services to clients. The key objective of the complementary interventions is to enhance economic empowerment amongst women microentrepreneurs through increased financial inclusion, in line with Nigeria’s national policy of significantly reducing the population of women excluded from the financial system. The beneficiaries are women microentrepreneurs in Ikere community, Ekiti State Nigeria. The implementing bank is using the evaluation as part of a learning process and strategy to reaching the largely unbanked / underbanked women microentrepreneurs in Ikere community.

Experimental design

The experimental designed is the randomized saturation (RS) design developed at the World Bank by Baird, Bohren, Mcintosh, and Ozler (2016). It is a two-level clustered-type randomization design where within-cluster assignment to treatment follows some degree of intensity (saturation). The RS design approach is adopted primary to enable us measure the nature and size of community level spillover effects potentially arising from the microcredit.

References:
(i) Baird, S., J.O. Bohren, C. McIntosh, and B. Ozler (2016). Optimal Design of Experiments in the Presence of Interference. Poverty and Applied Microeconomics Seminar Series, World Bank.

Design details

Randomization method
The randomization method will be done in office using STATA codes. The randomization procedure follows three-stages. The first stage involves random assignment of the entire Z clusters (women groups) into N overall treatment and Y control clusters, respectively. In the second stage, within each block, the N overall treatment clusters undergo further random assignment into equal-sized Treatment arm 1 (T1) (microcredit only, T1=N/2 clusters), Treatment arm 2 (T2) (microcredit + digital banking services, T2=N/2 clusters), Treatment arm 0 (T0) (pure control group, T0=Y clusters). The final stage involves within-cluster random allocation of beneficiaries into 50% saturation (treatment intensity) for both T1 and T2. Each of the randomization procedure will take place in each of the five fixed blocks that the community is divided.
Randomization unit
Women groups (clusters) are the unit of randomization. As described above, the first two-stages of the randomization procedure are group level randomization. The third level will be within-cluster randomization for treatment saturation is an individual level randomization. Each of the randomization procedure will be undertaken in each of the five fixed blocks that the community is divided.
Clusters
375 women groups, comprising 35 women groups within each block.
Observations
There will be at least 3,750 women microentrepreneurs. Each women cluster comprises at least 10 women members.
Arms
Treatment arm 1 (T1) = 1,000 beneficiaries allocated into 100 women groups to receive microloan alone. Treatment arm 2 (T2) = 1,000 beneficiaries allocated into 100 women groups to receive microloan + access to digital banking services. Treatment arm 0 (T0) = 1,750 beneficiaries allocated into 175 women groups as pure control. Total sample size=3,750
Primary outcomes
The primary outcomes are at the beneficiary level for economic empowerment, and household level outcomes for reduction in household vulnerability. The main indicators for economic empowerment include Financial inclusion; Decision making in hhold; Expenditure on hhold members; Contribution to hhold expenses (e.g. education, health), Peer networking / community participation; and Consumption expenditure (durable assets). Indicators for household vulnerability includes Household income; Savings; Child work; Food shortage in household; Health services demand; and Migration from household; and Copying with shocks. Indicators for institutional level outcomes include; Usage of digital banking services; Intensity of usage; Nature of usage; and Type of income generating activities.
Secondary outcomes
The secondary outcomes are mainly institutional design outcomes, such as interest rate, repayment, loan tenure.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords