Unpacking a Multi-Faceted Program to Build Sustainable Income for the Very Poor

How to cite

Trachtman, Hannah; Karlan, Dean; Udry, Chris; Banerjee, Abhijit; Osei, Robert. 2018. "Unpacking a Multi-Faceted Program to Build Sustainable Income for the Very Poor." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0002689. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.2689-1.1

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Hannah Trachtman* , Dean Karlan , Chris Udry , Abhijit Banerjee , Robert Osei

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0002689
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.2689-1.1
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2010-11-01 – 2015-07-31
Countries
Ghana (Northern Region, Upper East)
JEL codes
O12
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/2689

Abstract

A multi-faceted program comprising a grant of productive assets, training, coaching, and savings has been found to build sustainable income for those in extreme poverty. We focus on two important questions: whether a mere grant of productive assets would generate similar impacts (it does not), and whether access to a savings account and a deposit collection service would generate similar impacts (it does not).

Intervention

For the multi-faceted program in Ghana, Graduating from Ultra Poverty ("GUP"), implementers first identified poor communities in poor regions of the country. In each identified community, staff members then facilitated a Participatory Wealth Ranking (PWR), in which members of the community worked together to rank households by economic status. Finally, staff members returned for a verification of the households judged to be the poorest. The program was implemented by Presbyterian Agricultural Services, a local nongovernmental organization, in coordination with Innovations for Poverty Action, a non-profit research organization.

The basic GUP program involved the transfer of a productive asset; skills training for the management of the asset as well as life skills training, a weekly cash stipend for consumption support, worth between $6 and $9 PPP depending on family size, lasting for 3-10 months; access to a savings account at a local bank (details below in the experimental design section, as this is one of the components unpacked); and some basic health services and health education. The productive asset was provided at the beginning of the program, and households were permitted to choose a package of assets from a set list. The rest of these services were delivered over two years via regular visits (typically weekly) by a field officer from the implementing organization.

Experimental design

The program included several experimental arms designed to unpack whether specific components were sufficient on their own. First, we introduced variation in the core program at the household level: 50% of sample households within GUP villages were randomly assigned to the graduation program without savings ("GUP without savings"), and 50% received the standard program with collection of
savings for deposit into a local bank by the field agent ("GUP with savings").

Second, we introduced two additional treatment groups at the village-level. For each of these two additional treatment groups, a two-level design was maintained, thus creating treatment households in treatment villages, control households in treatment villages, and control households in control villages.

In Asset-Only villages, 50% of sample households were assigned to treatment, and received only a productive asset, without skills training on how to use it, or any of the other GUP components. These households were simply given four goats, since this was the most popular asset in GUP (71% of households chose a package of assets that included four goats). Goats were chosen because most households have had or have some goats, and thus would typically be content with receiving more, and we did not want to interact with the households and give them choices for fear that such engagement itself could change behavior.

In Saving Out of Ultra Poverty ("SOUP") villages, 59% of sample households were assigned to the SOUP treatment, and received a visit from the field agent to collect savings, just as in the GUP with savings group, but did not receive any other components of the program. Of this 59%, half received savings accounts and deposit collection without a match (“SOUP without match”) and half received savings accounts and deposit collection with a 50% match ("SOUP with match"). Specifically, for every GHC 1 deposited, households in this group received a matching contribution of GHC 0.50. The remaining households in SOUP villages were assigned to the SOUP control group.

Design details

Randomization method
In office by computer
Randomization unit
First, treatment was assigned at the village level (control, GUP, SOUP, or asset-only). Within control villages, all households were assigned control. Within asset-only villages, households were then assigned to either control or treatment. Within GUP and SOUP villages, households were then assigned to control or to one of the two sub-treatments.
Clusters
276 villages.
Observations
4177 households.
Arms
76 villages and 1299 households were assigned pure control. 78 villages were assigned GUP, with 642 households assigned control, 333 households assigned GUP, and 333 households assigned GUP with savings. 77 villages were assigned SOUP, with 510 households assigned control, 371 households assigned SOUP, and 362 households assigned SOUP with match. 45 villages were assigned asset-only, with 163 households assigned control and 164 households assigned asset-only.
Primary outcomes
asset value index, consumption index, financial inclusion index, food security index, income index
Secondary outcomes
business income, crop income, animal revenue, wage income, savings deposits, livestock value (goat, fowl, pig, sheep, cow)

Materials

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords