Gender matters - Performance spillover effects of symbolic recognition at school

How to cite

Essl, Andrea; Bieberstein, Frauke von. 2018. "Gender matters - Performance spillover effects of symbolic recognition at school." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0002676. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.2676-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Andrea Essl* , Frauke von Bieberstein

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0002676
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.2676-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2014-05-01 – 2018-12-31
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/2676

Abstract

Symbolic recognition can be an efficient and powerful tool for motivating people. Despite much research on ex ante announced symbolic incentives, little is known about the spillover effect of different recognition types in a multitask setting. In this laboratory experiment we examine not only positive but also negative symbolic recognition and its spillover effects. Secondary school students work on two different tasks. In the experimental treatment, students receive unannounced symbolic performance feedback for the first task. We are interested in gender differences for the spillover effect of recognition on performance in the second task.
This experiment is a follow-up study designed to collect more data as suggested by two referees. Experimental design and procedures are the same as in the first study.

Intervention

Between-subject design. The experiment consists of two main tasks, both without any performance-dependent financial incentives. The first task is a simple estimation task (to estimate the number of peas in a bowl borrowed from Falk and Zimmermann 2016). In the control treatment, students directly continue with the second task. In the experimental treatment, the experimenters distribute smiley-stickers to the top third, frowny-stickers to the bottom third and nothing other than the message that they are ranked in the middle to the intermediate third. Participants put the stickers on their sweatshirt and then continue with the second task. In the second task, students cut out flyers from sheets.

Experimental design

Between-subject design. The experiment consists of two main tasks, both without any performance-dependent financial incentives. The first task is a simple estimation task (to estimate the number of peas in a bowl borrowed from Falk and Zimmermann 2016). In the control treatment, students directly continue with the second task. In the experimental treatment, the experimenters distribute smiley-stickers to the top third, frowny-stickers to the bottom third and nothing other than the message that they are ranked in the middle to the intermediate third. Participants put the stickers on their sweatshirt and then continue with the second task. In the second task, students cut out flyers from sheets. This time, in both treatments there is a symbolic recognition program in place (smiley-sticker/frowny-sticker/no recognition) and students are aware of this program.
Prior to the two main tasks, there is a baseline stage of flyer cutting. This stage provides us with a baseline measure of students' ability. After the experiment, students also fill in a questionnaire on demographics.

Design details

Randomization method
Random draw
Randomization unit
individual student
Clusters
165 students
Observations
In total about 165 participants (depending on school attendance on the experimental day; about 87 males and 78 females). Pooling with the existing data, this gives about 300 participants.
Arms
About 60 participants in the control treatment, about 105 participants in the experimental treatment. This gives about 35 participants in the no recognition condition of the experimental treatment. About 50% of participants in each group will be female. Pooling with the existing data, this gives about 35 females in the no recognition group and >40 females in the control group (same numbers for males).
Primary outcomes
Our primary outcome variable is the number of corretly cut out flyer in taks 2 (performance in task 2). We will take into account individual baseline performance. We are interested in two main questions: 1) Do female students perform differently in task 2 following unannounced symbolic performance feedback for task 1 compared to males? 2) Do female (male) students perform differently in task 2 following unannounced symbolic performance feedback for task 1 compared to females (male) in the control?

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords