Malleability of Sustained Attention

How to cite

Brown, Christina; Schofield, Heather; Kaur, Supreet. 2019. "Malleability of Sustained Attention." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0002673. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.2673-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Christina Brown* , Heather Schofield , Supreet Kaur

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0002673
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.2673-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2017-08-28 – 2020-12-31
Countries
Private
JEL codes
J24, I2, D9
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/2673

Abstract

The economics and education literatures traditionally view human capital as an individual's stock of knowledge and skills. In this project, we posit an additional potential component: the capacity for sustained attention. In cognitive psychology, the mind's ability to direct and sustain attention is thought to underlie all activity: cognitive processes (such as solving a math problem) as well as non-cognitive activities (such as exerting self-control) (Chun et al. 2011). In this project, we examine whether the capacity for exerting sustained attention is malleable. Using a field experiment, we introduce a novel tablet-based adaptive learning platform into low-income Indian primary schools. The platform engages students in sustained practice in either mathematics or cognitive activities for 30 minutes at a time, several days a week for the academic school year. For many students, who typically face disruptive classroom environments and exert little focused direction of attention at home or school, this intervention drastically boosts the amount of sustained attentional practice they receive. We will quantify treatment effects on sustained attention using standard laboratory tests from cognitive psychology, practical tests of attention and performance decline over the course of traditional subject tests. If we find impacts on such outcomes, this would suggest broadening our view of the cognitive dimensions of human capital, and how it is shaped through schooling.

Intervention

Students are randomly assigned to one of three experimental arms. Each arm will vary how students spend their three 30-minute program periods each week. The three arms are:
1. Treatment 1 - Tablet-based math practice: Students are given a tablet with math software and asked to work on problems in the given module which matches the topic being covered in their math class. The math software used is dynamically adaptive, provides students with the correct answer after each question and is more visually appealing than working in paper and pencil.
2. Treatment 2 - Tablet-based cognitive activity practice: Students are given a tablet with a cognitive activity which requires focused attention for an extended period of time. The activities are rotated through every few weeks and include memory activities (memory tile and n-back), maze-like activities (flow free), and spatial awareness activities (tangrams and Tetris). These activities are free of any math content.
3. Control - Status quo math practice (Control): This class is structured to similar to the style of practice in their regular math classes. The teacher provides students with a small number of problems to work on independently. The problems given are the same ones that students would see on the tablet, so the content itself is constant across this arm and treatment 1.

These program periods would have been study-hall, elective or assembly periods in the absence of the program, so students do not miss any of their core instruction periods as a result of the study.

In addition, students in all sections will receive 1 period of math instruction roughly once per two weeks.

Experimental design

Students in grades 1-5 will be randomly assigned to one of three experimental arms:
- Treatment 1: Tablet-based math practice
- Treatment 2: Tablet-based cognitive activity practice
- Control: Status quo math practice

Our design allows to estimate the effect of additional focused math practice through the use of the tablet on student's math ability, decline over the length of the math exam and broad measures of attention by comparing treatment 1 to the control. By comparing treatment 2 versus control on our attention outcomes, we can also see if we remove any academic content, are we able to train attention skills more broadly.

The randomization will be stratified by grade and baseline income and math performance. Baseline measures of the main outcomes will be collected to the extent it is operationally feasible given school operational constraints and used as a control throughout our analysis.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization of students into treatments is done using Stata.
Randomization unit
Students are individually randomized. Randomization is stratified by grade, baseline academic performance, and household income.
Clusters
We will have approximately 1400 students total in the sample. The final numbers may change based on enrollment changes in our partner schools. The randomization is at the student level.
Observations
We will have approximately 1400 students total in the sample.
Arms
Our sample is evenly split between the three experimental arms, with approximately 465 students in each arm.
Primary outcomes
The outcomes we will measure are students' performance on a grade-level math exam, a Ravens Progressive Matrices task and three sustained attention measures: the Sustained Attention to Response Task (SART), symbol search task and a listening attention task.
Secondary outcomes
We will attempt to collect observational data on students' behavior and attentional capacity during their class periods. We will also try to obtain administrative behavior data and student assessment data from the school.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords