An Experimental Evaluation and Land Lottery in Nepal
How to cite
Holland, Abraham. 2018. "An Experimental Evaluation and Land Lottery in Nepal." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0002664. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.2664-4.1
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
What is the role of community preferences in driving the viability of village relocation programs following natural disasters? Nepal’s post-2015 earthquake village resettlement program, an effort to shift high-risk communities to safer, previously unsettled, locations provides a setting in which to examine this question. A key challenge in this program is how to fairly and transparently allocate new private residential space to households, while maintaining individual and overall community satisfaction with the relocation effort. In response, the government plans to administer land lotteries in affected villages. This paper focuses on understanding potential drivers behind the popularity of different lottery types and seeks to understand its implications for community engagement efforts supporting the plot allocation process.
Experimental design
There are two randomized instruments that are central to the study's design. The first gains experimental traction in this situation by leveraging the insights of previous field experiments on social preferences. In particular, randomizing whether individuals make decisions in a private (anonymous) or public (non-anonymous) context can identify the effects of external social concerns on decision-making. To accomplish this goal, I use a `lab in the field' Lottery Preference Game (LPG).
The LPG is a private-value cash lottery game where groups of participants are randomized into anonymous or non-anonymous contexts. They are asked to choose which type of lottery they would like to play, either a `Box-Choice' Random Dictatorship (RD) or a `Box' lottery, and the entire group plays the lottery type preferred by a randomly-selected individual. This ensures incentive compatibility and causally estimates anonymity's effect on preferences. The LPG group composition is also randomly determined. With this in mind, group composition / individual characteristics are also a potential source of experimental variation. Pending additional funding and sufficient statistical power estimates, an additional treatment arm may be added to this experiment. In that event, this submission will be amended.
The second experiment is conducted by randomizing the order of information in a household-based Lottery Preference Survey (LPS). This survey solicits individual preferences over a set of three possible lottery allocation schemes for managing residential plot distribution. Within this survey there are two distinct sources of experimental variation. The first is whether potentially relevant information on possible preference heterogeneity within their community is presented before or after the enumerator has solicited their preferences for the three lottery types. The second source of experimental variation is in randomizing both the order of explanation and pair-wise rankings solicited prior to asking for a complete preference ranking over all three lottery types.
A third experiment based on the random variation in household location induced by actual land lotteries conducted in these communities is currently being submitted for financial support. Pending successful funding, there will be a separate registry entry created for that experimental study component.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.