Do image concerns matter for the voluntary provision of public goods by firms? Field experimental evidence from carbon neutral courier services
How to cite
Fugger, Carina; Graevenitz, Kathrine von; Kesternich, Martin. 2017. "Do image concerns matter for the voluntary provision of public goods by firms? Field experimental evidence from carbon neutral courier services." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0002646. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.2646-11.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
The overall aim of the experiment is to test the impact of self-and social image concerns on the likelihood that firms participate in a voluntary carbon offsetting program as an example for a public good. Though public good provision of firms can be observed empirically (e.g. CSR measures), little is known about the different motivations and the mechanics behind it. We contribute to the literature by implementing an experimental setting that provides the sender of a delivery the opportunity to offset the carbon emissions of this service by paying a price premium, while we vary the opportunity to signal this pro-environmental behavior to the recipient of the delivery.
In a second phase, we extend the field experimental setting by introducing a 1:1 matching scheme to learn more about the firms’ evaluation of the signal. The matching doubles the amount of emissions offset while the price for the participant stays the same, if she decides to offset with a sticker attached to her delivery.
Intervention
From the beginning of the intervention onwards customers ordering deliveries via the webshop of a courier service provider are randomly assigned to one of the three different treatments in which they remain during the intervention. Observations of the treatments are therefore made in parallel. The intervention is planned to last at least 3 months. Based on previous orders we expect about 300 orders per month. So that a total of 900 observations (with equal shares of about 300 for each treatment) will be envisaged.
The three treatments vary the option to signal a carbon compensation decision (no signal, mandatory or voluntary signal). In a second ("matching") phase we offer to double the amount of emissions that are offset. This 1:1 matching is contingent upon signalling.
Experimental design
In our experimental setting, we aim at testing the impact of self- and social image concerns on firm behavior. Decision behavior will be examined by exposing individuals to different instruments in a randomized controlled trial. The focus of the experiment are business clients. We implement treatments in a carbon offsetting context that differ in the opportunity to signal the pro-environmental behavior. In the baseline scenario (T1) participants can decide whether they want to offset the carbon emissions resulting from their delivery but without any possibility to directly signal pro-environmental behavior to the recipient of the delivery. In a second treatment (T2) we introduce a sticker which is automatically attached to the address label of the parcel to signal pro-environmental behavior. In the third treatment (F3), the sticker option is optional and has to be actively chosen by the client.
In a second phase we add a 1:1 matching scheme. This adresses those participants that initially decided against the offsetting or against the signal. It offers them to double the amount of emissions offset in case they decide to purchase the carbon compensation and signal it.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.