Positive youth development through sports: Experimental evidence from Chicago
How to cite
Turner, Mary Clair; Galib, Linda; Hallberg, Kelly; Bertrand, Marianne. 2018. "Positive youth development through sports: Experimental evidence from Chicago." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0002643. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.2643-3.4000000000000004
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Extracurricular programming, particularly organized sports, are in high demand at the same time that sports participation rates for low-income children are diminishing (Afterschool Alliance, 2014; Aspen Institute, 2017). If participation in high-quality sports programming induces academic, social emotional learning, or health benefits, then the "opportunity gap" during middle childhood may contribute to inequalities later in life. However, there exists little causal evidence on the effects of participation on elementary school sports teams. In this paper, University of Chicago Urban Labs (Urban Labs) in collaboration with Urban Initiatives (UI) examines the causal effects of UI's Work to Play program. Work to Play promotes health and positive youth development through soccer programming. Participants, mostly 2nd-4th grade students, meet before or after school three times a week for 20 weeks during fall and spring seasons at 43 Chicago Public Schools (CPS).
Urban Labs randomized students to Work to Play rosters or a wait list at 19 oversubscribed schools during the 2017-2018 school year. Urban Labs will measure the impact of the intervention using CPS administrative data and primary data collected from students, their parents, and their teachers. Our primary analysis measures the treatment-on-treated effect of Work to Play participation on students' school grades, self-management behaviors, and body mass index percentile. Findings from this research will not only equip UI with a better understanding of the impact of Work to Play across multiple developmental domains, but also provide evidence on whether socioeconomic disparities in access to high-quality sports programming in childhood could induce inequalities later in life.
Intervention
Urban Initiatives (UI) operates Work to Play (WTP), a sports-based positive youth development program, in 44 Chicago Public Schools. WTP provides students primarily in 2nd-4th grades the opportunity to play on a soccer team at their school. Participation is free and open to all students regardless of skill level. Teams meet before or after school three times a week for 20 weeks split between fall and spring seasons. Teams range in size from 20 to 45 players depending on coach and facility constraints. Each week consists of two practice sessions and one game against a WTP team at another school or team scrimmage. Each session includes at least 60 minutes of physical activity and a healthy snack.
Trained coaches implement a curriculum that incorporates lessons on social emotional learning and health into structured soccer activities. For example, two teamwork activities are making a team cheer and setting expectations and responsibility for players and coaches. Two heart health lesson are learning how to take a pulse and learning about the chambers of the heart through a game where teams are split on the field into four quadrants. Participants earn game time based on teacher reports of their academic engagement and classroom behaviors. These reports also provide coaches with an opportunity to discuss school behaviors with players.
Experimental design
More interested participants signed up for WTP than available roster spots at 19 schools during the 2017-2018 school year. Roster sizes differed by school based on coaching staff and space constraints ranging from approximately 25 to 45 new and returning participants for the fall season. Since UI guaranteed roster spots to returning students and their siblings, random assignment determined who received the remaining open spots on the roster. Urban Labs (UL) used block random assignment to assign interested new participants to the WTP roster (treatment group) or waitlist (control group) at their school.
Before the fall season, we assigned students to the fall roster until all spots were filled. We assigned all remaining students to the waitlist condition at their school. We added students on the waitlist to the roster over the first two weeks of the season, if UI identified students on the roster who had transferred schools or decided not to participate on the soccer team. We did not adjust rosters to include waitlist students again until the spring season.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.