Microcredit Made to Measure. Experimental Evidence from Rural Morocco

How to cite

Pariente, William; Haas, Ralph De; Devoto, Florencia; Crepon, Bruno. 2018. "Microcredit Made to Measure. Experimental Evidence from Rural Morocco." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0002618. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.2618-1.2000000000000002

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

William Pariente* , Ralph De Haas , Florencia Devoto , Bruno Crepon

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0002618
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.2618-1.2000000000000002
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2018-04-09 – 2021-10-31
Countries
Morocco ()
JEL codes
D14, G21, O12
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/2618

Abstract

We use a randomized controlled trial (RCT) in rural Morocco to test whether matching loan repayments closely with expected entrepreneurial cash flows increases the take-up and poverty impact of microcredit. We introduce two new forms of individual-liability microcredit: a contract with a five-month grace period and, second, a ‘tailored’ contract where the repayment schedule is split into three equal periods (with varying installments). We first randomize an estimated 3,600 participants (all interested in and eligible for a standard loan) into either of the two new loan contracts or a control loan with the standard contract. We measure the effect on individuals’ repayment behavior, entrepreneurial activities and household consumption. We then use information campaigns to randomize the available information about the different treatments (the two new loan types and the standard loan) across 320 villages. We measure the impact on loan take-up and repayment quality at the village level.

Intervention

1. Grace period loan: A loan product is offered where borrowers only pay monthly interest during a five-month grace period and both interest and capital thereafter.
2. Tailored loan: A loan product is offered where the repayment schedule is split into three periods of equal length. The borrower and loan officer jointly decide on the monthly amount that the borrower has to repay in each of the three periods in order to more closely match the borrower’s expected cash flows (which may vary significantly over time). The repayment schedule can thus be decomposed into ‘low’ – ‘medium’ – ‘high’ repayment brackets (not necessarily in that order) with potentially substantial variation in the monthly repayment amount across these three brackets. The research team developed an Apache OpenOffice spreadsheet to help loan officers determine the cyclicality of participants’ expected cash flows.

Experimental design

We implement the following interventions:
1. Grace period loan: A loan product is offered where borrowers only pay monthly interest during a five-month grace period and both interest and capital thereafter.
2. Tailored loan: A loan product is offered where the repayment schedule is split into three periods of equal length. The borrower and loan officer jointly decide on the monthly amount that the borrower has to repay in each of the three periods in order to more closely match the borrower’s expected cash flows (which may vary significantly over time). The repayment schedule can thus be decomposed into ‘low’ – ‘medium’ – ‘high’ repayment brackets (not necessarily in that order) with potentially substantial variation in the monthly repayment amount across these three brackets. The research team developed an Apache OpenOffice spreadsheet to help loan officers determine the cyclicality of participants’ expected cash flows.

Design details

Randomization method
Part A of the study: randomization done at the branch by a computer. Part B of the study: randomization done in office by a computer.
Randomization unit
We will randomize at the individual level for the first part of the study and at the village level for the second part of the study.
Clusters
Part B will take place in eight villages in the catchment area of each of the 40 participating branches. This part thus involves 320 villages.
Observations
The first two waves of the baseline survey have provided us with preliminary estimates of the daily number of eligible clients that visit the branches and that consent to participate in the study. Since the variation across branches is substantial, we undertook power calculations for three scenarios where we assume total sample sizes of either 3,600; 3,000; or 2,400 clients.
Arms
Part A of the study: 1,200 individuals control, 1,200 individuals tailored loans (type 1), 1,200 individuals tailored loans (type 2). Part B will take place in eight villages in the catchment area of each of the 40 participating branches. This part thus involves 320 villages.
Primary outcomes
The primary outcomes vary across the two parts of the experiment. In Part A, we focus on the profits and revenues derived from the economic activities of the clients as well as on their consumption and income. In Part B, we focus on the number of loans disbursed, repayment rates, and the portfolio at risk. In the second part of the study, we will rely on administrative data to measure loan take-up, amounts borrowed, reimbursement length and frequency, client retention, and portfolio at risk.
Secondary outcomes
Our secondary outcomes are variables that may also be affected by the intervention but are not the core variables that determine whether the interventions have been successful. These include loan use, type and level of investments, time allocation (Part A), and reimbursement length and frequency, amount borrowed, characteristics of the pool of clients taking up loans, and client retention (Part B).

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords