Dressing for Success: Evaluating a Governance Training and Uniform Distribution Program in Malawi
How to cite
Bleck, Jaimie. 2017. "Dressing for Success: Evaluating a Governance Training and Uniform Distribution Program in Malawi." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0002593. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.2593-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
This project explores the effect of a governance training and uniform distribution program on governance by Village Development Councils (VDC) in rural Malawi. The project leverages a randomized control design to evaluate to interventions, a governance training and a uniform distribution program to committee members, to understand how the two treatments affect a) general governance outcomes b) VDC members' efficacy and job performance, and c) villagers' perceptions of VDC members. Working in partnership with Catholic Relief Services, the PIs will conduct a baseline survey in all Group Village Heads (administrative unit for GVHs) and then an endline in communities, which have received treatment 1 (governance training), treatment 2 (governance training and uniform distribution), and control villages (no training or distribution in the period of study). The project conducts surveys with villagers, VDC members, other committee members, and GVH heads to evaluate the outcome variables of interest. In addition, we will conduct functionality assessments on the performance of VDCs.
Intervention
In partnership with Catholic Relief Services, we use a phased out, stratified, clustered randomized design to assign village development committees in Malawi to receive the following treatments:
Treatment 1: 1 day governance training run by CRS
Treatment 2: uniform (hat, badge, shirt) distribution to VDC members plus the 1 day governance training
Control: no treatments in the period of study; slated to receive trainings after the endline in November 2017.
We assess the impact of these interventions on governance outcomes in these communities.
Experimental design
This intervention is designed to study the effectiveness of Catholic relief service’s governance training program (Treatment 1) on functioning of village development committees (VDCs) in Malawi. A second intervention (Treatment 2) will comple- ment the trainings with a distribution of uniforms to VDC members. The research teams assess the effect of Treatment 1 and Treatment 2 on a) VDC governance out- comes; b) members’ assessment of themselves and their performance; c) villagers’ perceptions of the VDC members and their performance.
This idea for the second treatment came directly from focus groups with village committee members during the needs assessment phase, in which the research team asked about things that would help with their job performance. Village Committee Members had cited as uniforms as items that could help them to better do their job. This prompted the research team to consider literature from political science that suggests that ”professional dress” could influence members’ self-assessments and constituents preferences.
In partnership with CRS, the research team used a list of 207 administrative units (GVHs) to implement a phased out stratified cluster randomized design. It assigned all GVHs participating in the CRS program into a Treatment 1, Treat- ment 2 and Control Groups. VDC members in Treatment 1 received the 1 day CRS governance training, while VDC members in Treatment 2 receive the training as well as a uniform (hat, badge, and shirt). VDC members in control villages do not receive any treatments before the endline is conducted (end of year 2017). The research team will use a series of longitudinal surveys (collected before and after the interventions) that target the following populations: VDC members, Other Com- mittee Members, villagers, and traditional leaders in the communities. In addition, the team will conduct a functionality assessment of VDC organization and perfor- mance during the endline. Finally, the endline will include an embedded survey experiment, in which villagers are randomly assigned to images of VDC members (male/female/uniform/no uniform) to further test the mechanisms that could drive Treatment 2.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.