Community Policing and Public Trust: A Field Experiment in Uganda
How to cite
Blair, Robert; Kachero, Benjamin; Grossman, Guy. 2017. "Community Policing and Public Trust: A Field Experiment in Uganda." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0002577. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.2577-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
The ability of the police and other state security institutions to enforce the law depends on the trust and cooperation of the policed. Our study is designed to address the challenge of building trust and cooperation between police and citizens in Uganda, using the “Muyenga model” of community policing. The Muyenga model is explicitly designed to create opportunities for more positive, mutually respectful interactions between civilians and police officers by allowing UPF officers to respond more proactively to the needs of citizens and communities; by providing mechanisms to report acts of corruption and abuse; and by encouraging citizens to rely on state security and justice sector institutions when crimes are committed or violence occurs. The model has been piloted successfully in a small number of communities, and is now scaled up sufficiently to allow a rigorous study of its effectiveness. Our study is one of six field experiments in the Evidence in Governance and Politics (EGAP) network’s Metaketa IV initiative.
Intervention
Relations between civilians and the Ugandan Police Force (UPF) remain strained, with correspondingly relatively low levels of citizen trust, cooperation and crime reporting. This study aims to test whether the above problems could be addressed via a homegrown model of community policing, which has already been successfully piloted (on a small scale) in Uganda. Known as the “Muyenga model”, this approach to community policing is designed to create opportunities for more positive, mutually respectful interactions between civilians and police officers by allowing officers to respond more proactively to the needs of citizens and communities; by providing mechanisms to report acts of corruption and abuse; and by encouraging citizens to rely on state security and justice sector institutions when crimes are committed or violence occurs. The Muyenga model comprises three components:
1. Frequent motor cycle and especially foot patrols by police officers. The goal of the “meet and greet” patrols is to increase “police presence” but also to form ties and increase trust between the local officers and residents.
2. Frequent “town hall” meetings with citizens and local leaders. The primary purpose of the meetings is to allow residents, local leaders, other community stakeholders, and police officers to discuss chronic crime and disorder problems, and to formulate local solutions. Town hall meetings are also designed to provide information to citizens about police procedures and rules of conduct (for example, whom to contact in case of officers’ misconduct).
3. Training and support to community watch teams (CWTs). Community watch teams allow greater security presence (in the face of shortfalls in police manpower), but also create a cadre of residents that better understand police procedures and resources. Specifically, CWTs act as liaisons between the community and UPF officers at the beat and station levels. The idea behind NWTs is to create a group of civilians with a better understanding of the law and of UPF’s roles and responsibilities, who can then serve as points of contact between community members and the police. Among other responsibilities, watch teams are specifically trained to monitor the incidence of gender-based violence (GBV) in their communities.
Through these three mechanisms, police officers learn about local security needs and are then expected to address them with resources and decision-making authority decentralized to the local level.
In this study, we also test whether community policing could be strengthened using a second intervention, which offers training in prevention of GBV for community leaders and volunteers from villages in the study area. These community volunteers will then serve as focal points within their villages, disseminating knowledge of GBV and delivering strategies for preventing and mitigating it. Training will also be delivered to police officers to raise awareness on the seriousness of GBV and to teach them how to handle cases reported to them. The training will be organized at the station level. This intervention was selected since focus groups discussions the research team conducted at the “seed” stage, suggested GBV as both pervasive and major unreported crime.
Experimental design
We will evaluate these two interventions using a randomized controlled trial. The unit of randomization is the police station. We will implement a 2x2 factorial design in which stations are randomly assigned to one of four groups:
1. Community policing
2. GBV training
3. Community policing and GBV training
4. Neither (pure control)
Randomization will proceed in three stages. First, we will identify 72 police stations serving rural communities from among the stations in the study districts. We began collecting information on these stations (for example, number of officers, distance to district capital, number of villages the station covers) to allow us to place stations with similar characteristics in blocks (using the blockTools R package). Second, we will randomly assign each of these stations to one of the four treatment groups, within blocks. For purposes of data collection, we will randomly select 1 police unit within the jurisdiction of each police station, if a station doesn't have any post we pick the station itself, and chose the parish where the police unit is located for our sample, within each parish, four villages. Third, within each village we will select (using a random walk) 12 survey respondents, 7 women and 5 men.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.