Benchmarking USAID-Funded Health Programs against Household Grants: An Application to Health in Rwanda
How to cite
McIntosh, Craig; Zeitlin, Andrew. 2017. "Benchmarking USAID-Funded Health Programs against Household Grants: An Application to Health in Rwanda." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0002559. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.2559-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
This project will provide rigorous, experimental evidence of the cost-effectiveness of alternative programs to improve the nutritional status of vulnerable households with children under the age of five and women of reproductive age, with an emphasis on the 1,000 day windows of opportunity from pregnancy until a child's second birthday. To do so, the study will conduct a cluster-randomized controlled trial in Rwanda that evaluates the impacts of two programs: a multi-dimensional nutritional program typical of those implemented by USAID in many parts of the world, and a household grant program built to transfer an amount of money exactly equivalent from the perspective of the donor. These two treatments are compared to a control group, namely a set of villages that receive neither program. This study design achieves a fundamental kind of cost-effectiveness benchmarking increasingly called for in recent years: the comparison of a standard and widespread development intervention with the outcome that would occur if the cost of the intervention were simply given away to the beneficiaries for them to spend as they see fit. The primary outcomes for the study are the anemia and anthropometrics of target children, as well as consumption, dietary diversity, and wealth of the households to which they belong.
Intervention
This project will provide rigorous, experimental evidence of the cost-effectiveness of alternative programs to improve the nutritional status of vulnerable households with children under the age of five and women of reproductive age, with an emphasis on the 1,000 day windows of opportunity from pregnancy until a child's second birthday. To do so, the study will conduct a cluster-randomized controlled trial that evaluates the impacts of two programs: a multi-dimensional nutritional program implemented by Catholic Relief Services (the program is called Gikuriro, which means Good Growth), and a household grant program implemented by GiveDirectly. These two treatments are compared to a control group, namely a set of villages that receive neither program. This study design achieves a fundamental kind of cost-effectiveness benchmarking increasingly called for in recent years: the comparison of a standard and widespread development intervention with the outcome that would occur if the cost of the intervention were simply given away to the beneficiaries for them to spend as they see fit.
Gikuriro consists of four components: a Village Nutritional School, Farmer Field Learning Schools, Savings and Internal Lending Communities, and Sustainable Sanitation and Hygiene for All. This combination has been developed by CRS over the course of many years implementing anti-malnutrition programs across the world. GiveDirectly has pioneered the use of household grants, an intervention which has been found in Ethiopia, Kenya, Zambia, and Zimbabwe to increase consumption, bringing with this improvements in dietary diversity. While very different in design, both of these approaches appear to hold out tremendous promise for improvements in child nutrition. These alternative approaches have rarely been evaluated side-by-side, in a setting that not only rigorously evaluates impacts for a statistically comparable population, but also carefully tracks costs in a comparable way across distinct projects. Doing so allows governments and donors to identify the most cost-effective means to achieve the critical goal of decreasing malnutrition.
Experimental design
Villages enrolled in the study were drawn from two districts: Kayonza and Nyabihu. A computer was used to conduct the randomization by the researchers based on a frame of villages agreed to by CRS and government officials. Randomization occurred at the village level across 248 villages. Of these, 74 were assigned to the Gikuriro intervention, 74 were assigned to the control group (no intervention), and 61 were assigned to GiveDirectly household grants in a range around the anticipated equivalent cost of Gikuriro (19-21 villages in each of 3 transfer amount cells). A final 34 villages were assigned to the large GiveDirectly transfer intended to maximize cost effectiveness of cash.
The total GD costs (inclusive of overhead) chosen to bracket expected Gikuriro based on ex-ante estimation of costs were $77, $119, $152. Once GD overheads are deducted, this translates into $41.32, $83.63, and $116.91 actually transferred to beneficiaries in GD villages. Then, the large transfer amount selected to optimize GiveDirectly’s benefit/cost ratio was $532 actually transferred to households. All transfer amounts were translated into Rwandan Francs at an exchange rate of 790 RwF per US dollar, and were rounded to the nearest hundred.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.