The Behavioral Foundations of Labor Supply and Job Search: Experimental Evidence from an Urban Labor Market in Ethiopia

How to cite

Meyer, Christian Johannes. 2018. "The Behavioral Foundations of Labor Supply and Job Search: Experimental Evidence from an Urban Labor Market in Ethiopia." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0002555. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.2555-3.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Christian Johannes Meyer*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0002555
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.2555-3.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2018-03-22 – 2019-01-31
Countries
Private
JEL codes
C93, D91, J63, J64
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/2555

Abstract

This project seeks to provide new evidence on the behavioral foundations of labor supply, job search behavior, and occupational choice. I focus on impatience. I use two lab-in-the-field experiments and high-frequency phone surveys over thre months to elicit individual time preference parameters and a range of other individual characteristics, including cognitive control, non-cognitive ability, and aspirations, from a sample of young women who start their job in a light manufacturing firm in highly dynamic urban labor market in Ethiopia. I augment this data with rich administrative data from firm personnel records and bank account transactions. I use the resulting panel dataset to structurally estimate an on-the-job search model for workers with hyperbolic preferences. I hope to use the structural estimates to study counter-factual scenarios of labor supply and firm tenure, job search behavior, and occupational trajectories in the labor market under various degrees of present bias.

I have completed piloting the survey and intervention. No baseline data has been collected.

Intervention

The focus of this study is to experimentally elicit individual time preference parameters and a range of other individual characteristics, including cognitive control, non-cognitive ability, and aspirations, from a sample of young women who start their job in a light manufacturing firm in highly dynamic urban labor market in Ethiopia.

Additionally, I randomly administer a light-touch information intervention in which a subset of surveyed workers is informed about their own time preferences as measured in baseline survey.

In the same context, I cross-randomize an unrelated intervention which is separately registered in the AER RCT Registry.

Experimental design

The main focus of this study is to construct a longitudinal dataset of individuals starting employment at a large manufacturing firm. I collect data in four steps: First, I conduct a lab-in-the-field experiment and baseline survey. Second, I follow workers using biweekly phone calls. Third, I repeat the lab-in-the-field experiment together with an endline survey. Fourth, I obtain administrative data from firm personnel records and on workers' bank accounts.

At baseline, all study participants will be randomly assigned to one of three groups: (1) a SURVEY CONTROL in which I conduct baseline, high-frequency follow-up and endline surveys, (2) a TREATMENT group in which I additionally administer a light-touch information treatment, and (3) a PURE CONTROL group in which I do not conduct any surveys or administer any treatment, but only rely on administrative data on each subject.

Details are set out in the submitted Pre-Analysis Plan.

Design details

Randomization method
I randomize among all individuals starting employment in an industrial park outside Addis Ababa. Workers apply for work at the factory gate Monday through Saturday (t=-1), and I randomize them into treatment arms on the next day when they return for their first day of work (t=0). The randomization is done by the tablet computer used for interviewing. All interviewed subjects are eligible to win the payouts from a convex time budget experiment with a 50 percent chance. Randomization for this payout is done using a coin flip at the end of the interview. If subjects win the coin flip, they draw one of the 15 decisions that they made to determine the payout dates and amounts. This is done using numbered cards in a bowl.
Randomization unit
I randomize at the individual level among workers who start employment in an industrial park outside Addis Ababa.
Clusters
Target sample size of 450 garmenting workers as part of the main study, with an additional 400 workers for which I only collect administrative data.
Observations
Target sample size of 450 garmenting workers as part of the main study, with an additional 400 workers for which I only collect administrative data.
Arms
Target sample size by treatment arm as follows: - 225 workers in SURVEY CONTROL (with baseline, midline, and endline surveys) - 225 workers in TREATMENT (with baseline, midline, and endline) - 400 workers in PURE CONTROL (no surveys, no treatment, only administrative data)
Primary outcomes
My intermediate outcomes from the lab-in-the-field experiment are individual-level time preference parameter estimates for all my subjects. I then use these parameters as inputs to a structural model of on- and off-the-job search to study the following final outcomes: (1) the labor supply decision on the new job, (2) on-the-job search behavior, (3) tenure at the firm, (4) job search behavior while unemployed after leaving the firm, (5) reservation wages while employed and while unemployed, and (6) occupational choice after leaving the firm.
Secondary outcomes
While my main interest lies in the structural estimation of a behavioral job search model, my setup can speak to four secondary groups of outcomes that I am planning to study using observational data: - Hypothesis Group A “Confidence and Job Search”: The role of baseline locus of control, aspirations, and self-confidence ("self-efficacy") in search effort and the potential psychological costs (beyond effort) from unsuccessful search. - Hypothesis Group B “Cognitive control, cognitive depletion, and information processing”: The role of cognitive control and its depletion in job search. - Hypothesis Group C “Industrial Work and Aspirations”: The effect of indus- trial work on aspirations and self-confidence. - Hypothesis Group D “Industrial Work and Health”: The effect of industrial work on mental and physical health outcomes.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords