The impact of vocational training on labor market outcomes in Mongolia
How to cite
Batchuluun, Altantsetseg; Dlakhjav, Bayarmaa; Galdo, Jose; Batbekh, Soyolmaa; Alzua, Maria Laura. 2017. "The impact of vocational training on labor market outcomes in Mongolia." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0002461. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.2461-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Mongolia is a lower-middle income country characterized by high youth unemployment and a large informal sector. Training programs have been implemented to promote employment and tackle these issues. In this study, we evaluate the impact of a vocational training program (VTP) through a field experiment conducted between 2013 and 2015. This time frame allows us to explore short and medium term impacts. We focus on three outcomes of interest: employment, earnings and job quality. We also want to investigate how the high dropout rate registered in the VTP program is related to the fact that participants ignore the potential gains of the training in terms of wages and employments.
Intervention
The primary intervention is a short-term vocational training program (VTP), which was introduced in 2003. The program's primary goal consists of promoting employment by providing vocational skills through training. In 2013, there were 80 vocational skills programs provided by the VTP, which included heavy machinery operating, hairdressing, cooking, and various types of construction work, among others. The target population is unemployed youth between 15 and 30 who want to get vocational training. Participating in the VTP gives them an opportunity to improve their skills and competitiveness in the labor market in the short-term, by increasing their odds of getting a job and thus their income.
The Employment Promotion Service Center (EPSC) of the Ministry of Labor is responsible for the overall design of the program and selection of training institutions. It is financed by the State Employment Promotion Fund and is targeted at the unemployed or those vulnerable to unemployment, youth not enrolled in formal education, and low-income citizens.
The EPSC selects training institutions through a competitive bidding process. Institutions must show their ability to provide adequate training at the time of submitting their bids. In 2013, 75 institutions were selected for VTP. Approximately, 15% of them were non-profit and 85% were for-profit institutions.
The length of the training varies from 20 days to 45 days, depending on the type of class chosen, with a minimum duration of 144 hours. Each training program consists of classroom training and a subsequent internship to provide on-the-job work experience. Classroom teaching should not exceed 30% of the 144 total hours. The second part of the training is split into practical training and internships.
In Ulaanbaatar, the Metropolitan Employment Department (MED) implements the VTP once a year, from April to November. The MED signs a contract with the selected institutions and monitors the courses.
VTP covers the tuition cost of the training with no other benefit included using vouchers, the trainees hand in to the selected training institutions. Tuition fees are approximately US$140 per trainee. Eligibility criteria include household income and employment status.
Applicants apply for the program in their respective Khoroo offices and are assigned the training. Historically, the VTP has shown a very high dropout/no-show rate. To that end, and additionally to the effect of the training itself, our intervention test the potential information pitfalls of the beneficiaries regarding the returns to vocational training. This is called the "information treatment". To that end, we delivered a series of letters to trainees. The letters contained detailed information about labor market outcomes of skilled vs.unskilled workers in Mongolia. The letters were delivered every Friday during the training.
Experimental design
We designed our experimental protocol together with MED. We followed the regular registration process of the MED, which consisted of the following stages: First, khoroo officials screened applicant eligibility and sent eligible applicants to the district labor divisions. In particular, the VTP targets people who are unemployed, vulnerable to unemployment, those having difficulty finding a job and school dropouts. After the screening process, eligible applicants are randomized into treatment and control group. Applicants assigned to the treatment group continued the application process and received training funded by the MED.
At the second stage, district officials checked place availability for the chosen vocation and provided the contract form. Depending on both vocations and training institutions, some applicants had to sign an agreement with an employer, while other applicants did not need to. Once the contract was signed by all the parties, applicants went to the MED office to receive the training.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.