Women’s Agency and Women’s Labor Supply: Experimental Evidence from India

How to cite

McKelway, Madeline. 2017. "Women’s Agency and Women’s Labor Supply: Experimental Evidence from India." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0002399. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.2399-4.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Madeline McKelway*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0002399
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.2399-4.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2017-08-08 – 2018-10-07
Countries
India (Uttar Pradesh)
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/2399

Abstract

A striking feature of the lives of women living in rural India is their lack of agency. Decisions regarding female labor force participation (FLFP) are a case in point. I study FLFP in rural Uttar Pradesh through a partnership with a large Indian carpet manufacturer. The firm offers a weaving job for women that women themselves are very interested in taking. Yet, consistent with a lack of agency over the decision, women enroll at very low rates.

Intra-household barriers are often cited as a leading cause for women’s lack of agency; cultural norms in the setting lead women’s lives to be largely controlled by husbands and in-laws. However, a lack of agency may also reflect important, and often overlooked, psychological roots. In particular, women’s agency may be constrained by a lack of generalized efficacy (i.e. the conviction that one has the ability to attain desired outcomes) in women’s own psychology.

This project will offer randomly chosen women a psychosocial intervention designed to enhance generalized efficacy. The aim of this intervention is to give women the psychological assets required to act on their desires. I will investigate the effect of this intervention on enrollment in the weaving job and on other economic outcomes that represent commonly held goals of women in the setting.

Psychological efficacy will interact crucially with intra-household constraints on women’s agency whenever women’s desires conflict with those of their family members. On the one hand, the actions efficacy inspires may only be fruitful if not met with opposition from husbands and in-laws. On the other hand, the internal assets that efficacy engenders may allow women to overcome intra-household barriers on their own. Intra-household constraints will be particularly important in FLFP decisions as husbands and in-laws typically oppose women working outside of the home. I will therefore offer a second, cross-randomized intervention that markets the women’s weaving opportunity directly to husbands and in-laws so as to reduce intra-household opposition women face in enrollment. I will investigate the effect of this intervention, both given alone and together with the efficacy intervention, on enrollment decisions.

Intervention

The first intervention will be a psychosocial intervention designed to enhance women's generalized efficacy. It will be delivered in nine group sessions held once or twice per week. Each group will consist of a single surveyor and several (around 6-10) women from the same basti. Women assigned to the control group will have the same schedule and format of meetings. But rather than discuss topics to enhance efficacy, the control group will respond to questions about their daily lives.

The second intervention is designed to reduce intra-household opposition women face in enrolling in the weaving job. To do so, the intervention will market the job opportunity to husbands and in-laws using video testimonials from participating wives and their husbands.

Experimental design

I will conduct the experiment in conjunction with the firm's opening of six new women's weaving centers. The survey team will begin by canvassing the catchment area for each center to identify all eligible women, invite eligible women to participate in the study, and take a baseline survey. Study participants will then be assigned treatment status. This will take approximately 1 week. In weeks 2-6, the efficacy intervention will be delivered. At the end of the final session, surveyors will administer an Endline 1 survey. In week 7, surveyors will return to women to administer an Endline 2 survey and provide information about the weaving job opportunity. In the same week, surveyors will visit women's husbands and in-laws to deliver the intra-household opposition intervention. An enrollment day for the weaving job will occur at the start of the 8th week. An Endline 3 survey will be taken in the week following enrollment. The team will return 1-2 months later to take a follow-up survey.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization done in Stata
Randomization unit
Generalized Efficacy Intervention: each household is randomly assigned to a meeting group consisting of around 6-10 households from its basti. Treatment is then assigned at the meeting group level. Whenever a household has multiple women and there are multiple groups in the household's basti with the same treatment status, individual women are re-assigned meeting group so as to minimize the number of women from the same household in the same meeting group while maintaining the same treatment status for all women in the household. Intra-Household Opposition Intervention: treatment is assigned at the household level.
Clusters
150 meeting groups, roughly 900 households (exact values will depend on the number of households that enroll in the study).
Observations
Roughly 1000 women (exact values will depend on the number of women that enroll in the study).
Arms
Efficacy intervention: 75 meeting groups assigned to treatment and 75 to control. Intra-household opposition intervention (cross-randomized): about 450 households assigned to treatment and 450 to control (exact values will depend on the number of households that enroll in the study).
Primary outcomes
(1) Psychological outcomes: (a) generalized self-efficacy, (b) self-esteem, (c) goal setting, (d) planning, (e) overall happiness. (2) Weaving job outcomes: (a) enrollment, (b) retention, (c) stated interest, (d) household decision-making process. (3) Child health visit sign-up. (4) Other economic outcomes: (a) women’s work and earnings across all sectors, (b) child school attendance and studies, (c) household savings.

Papers from this trial

  1. McKelway, Madeline. 2018. "Women's Self-Efficacy and Women's Employment: Experimental Evidence from India." Working Paper. https://economics.mit.edu/files/16014

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords