More Than Money: Effects of Cash Transfer Narratives on Agency and Self-Investment
How to cite
Thomas, Catherine; Otis, Nicholas; Abraham, Justin; Markus, Hazel; Walton, Gregory. 2017. "More Than Money: Effects of Cash Transfer Narratives on Agency and Self-Investment." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0002388. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.2388-5.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
This document describes the pre-analysis plan for a randomized experiment examining the effects of narratives accompanying unconditional cash transfers on self-concept and economic behavior. We provided one-time, unconditional cash transfers to residents of two informal settlements in Nairobi and randomly assign participants to receive one of three messages. Respondents will receive a non-binding message stating that the cash is intended for 1) poverty alleviation, 2) individual empowerment, or 3) community empowerment. We then collected self-reported measures of self-efficacy, stigma, and affect and behavioral measures of future-orientation, self-investment, and program support. This pre-analysis plan outlines our hypotheses, the schedule of experimental tasks, and our empirical strategy. In order to guarantee transparency and bind ourselves from fishing for results, we will pre-register the scripts to be used for data analysis.
Intervention
Participants were randomly assigned by the survey software within enumerator to receive one of three messages introducing the purpose of the cash transfer. The three messages had a similar structure, but we experimentally varied the described purpose of the cash transfer. Specifically, we changed the stated goals of the organization, rationale for providing money, assumptions about recipients, and expectations and goals for the use of the transfer. In the poverty alleviation message, the payment was described as a means to meet basic needs. The individual empowerment message described the payment as a means toward individual goals and advancement. The community empowerment message described the payment as a means toward goals advancing one’s family and the community for community advancement. Participants listened to the message twice in their preferred language (English or Swahili) with pre-recorded audio clips or as read by the enumerator.
After hearing the message once, senior enumerators were alerted to use a project MPESA account to send USD PPP 10.5 to the participant via the mobile money system M-Pesa. Enumerators were instructed to confirm receipt of the payment on the respondent’s phone, after which enumerators played the message a second time.5 Then, enumerators led the respondent’s through a series of questions on how they view the transfer. In particular they are asked questions on their current needs (in the “poverty alleviation” arm) or goals (in the “individual empowerment” and “community empowerment” arms), the name they would assign to these funds (for example “education fund”), how receipt of these funds would affect their relationship with others, and their perceived goal of the organization.
Experimental design
Sampling
This study was conducted in conjunction with the Busara Center for Behavioral Economics (Busara) in Nairobi with 565 participants residing in Kibera and Kawangware, two of Kenya’s largest informal settlements. Treatment and data collection were con- ducted by Busara Center enumerators with participants from Kibera and Kawangware in lab and field settings, using tablets to display audio and video media and record participant responses. This section outlines the sampling procedure used in the experiment.
At the outset of the survey, eligible and consenting participants were told they would be receiving an unconditional cash transfer of KES 400 (USD PPP 10.5) from an organization unaffiliated with the Busara Center.
Treatment
Participants were randomly assigned by the survey software within enumerator to receive one of three messages introducing the purpose of the cash transfer. The three messages had a similar structure, but we experimentally varied the described purpose of the cash transfer. Specifically, we changed the stated goals of the organization, rationale for providing money, assumptions about recipients, and expectations and goals for the use of the transfer. In the poverty alleviation message, the payment was described as a means to meet basic needs. The individual empowerment message described the payment as a means toward individual goals and advancement. The community empowerment message described the payment as a means toward goals advancing one’s family and the community for community advancement. Participants listened to the message twice in their preferred language (English or Swahili) with pre-recorded audio clips or as read by the enumerator.
Participants were recruited from the Busara participant pool and were asked to participate in the survey in one of the lab settings. There were seven survey locations used throughout the study period. Table 1 summarizes these areas. Participants were recruited to participate in the study if they met the following eligibility criteria:
1. Member of the Busara Center’s participant pool
2. Resident of Kibera or Kawangware
3. Owns a working phone and an M-Pesa account registered under the participant’s name
Experimental procedure
The survey questionnaire was delivered by enumerators to participants in Swahili or English, as preferred by the participant. The following summarizes the schedule of tasks in the questionnaire.
1. Consent agreement
2. Cash transfer and message (randomized)
3. Self-efficacy module
4. Stigma module
5. Affect module
6. Video selection task
7. Savings task
8. Message evaluation
9. Support for organization and message
10. MacArthur Subjective Social Status Ladders
11. Sociodemographic module
Design details
Papers from this trial
- Thomas, C. C., Otis, N. G., Abraham, J. R., Markus, H. R., & Walton, G. M. (2020). Toward a science of delivering aid with dignity: Experimental evidence and local forecasts from Kenya. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 117(27), 15546-15553. https://www.pnas.org/content/117/27/15546.short
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.