Sustainability of Health Insurance Enrollment: Evidence from a Field Experiment in Ghana

How to cite

Sim, Armand; Asuming, Patrick; Kim, Hyuncheol. 2017. "Sustainability of Health Insurance Enrollment: Evidence from a Field Experiment in Ghana." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0002376. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.2376-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Armand Sim* , Patrick Asuming , Hyuncheol Kim

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0002376
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.2376-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2011-09-03 – 2014-12-30
Countries
Ghana (Wa West District )
JEL codes
I1, O12
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/2376

Abstract

This project aims to understand how to promote and sustain health insurance enrollment in Ghana. We also evaluate the impacts of insurance coverage on a host of health outcomes and healthcare utilization. To achieve our objectives, we hired local researchers in Ghana to help run experiments and collect various household and individual data. This study is going to make two contributions to the literature. First, our study will be among the first to document evidence of intervention on enrollment sustainability of nationwide insurance. Second, our study will be among the first to focus in pricing on health insurance in low-income countries.

Intervention

We conducted three main interventions in our study at community level: a subsidy to payment of NHIS premium and fees, an education campaign, and convenience. Additionally, we also provided multiple interventions: education and convenience, education and subsidy, subsidy and convenience, and education and subsidy and convenience. Households within communities that were randomly selected to receive the subsidy intervention were randomly assigned to receive three possible subsidy levels for insurance premiums and fees: 1/3 subsidy (GHC 4 or USD 2.67), 2/3 subsidy (GHC 8.10 or USD 5.40) or full subsidy (GHC 12.20 or USD 8.13). Subsidies were given in the form of vouchers with a two-month validity period and redeemable only at the Wa West District Mutual Health Insurance Schemes (DMHIS). The voucher specified names, ages and gender of all household members, expiration date and where it should be redeemed. The education campaign intervention provided basic intervention on the NHIS including registration information, premiums and exemptions, and benefits of the scheme as well as general education on the importance of being insured. Communities which received convenience intervention had visits from trained fieldworkers to provide information and answer questions about NHIS.

We limit our sample communities to those with 30 – 400 residents which are located at least 1km from the nearest other community. This size restriction was due to budgetary considerations considering our interventions were at the community level. The distance restriction was to minimize spillover of education and convenience interventions to neighboring communities. There were 61 communities and 680 households and 4,625 individuals that satisfied these restrictions.

Experimental design

Baseline survey was conducted in September 2011. Intervention was conducted in October 2011. First and second follow-up surveys were conducted in April 2012 and December 2014, respectively.

Baseline survey collected information on demographic characteristics, employment, health history, general health and utilization of healthcare services, expected future health, enrollment in the NHIS and health behaviors for all household members. Information on knowledge of health insurance was collected from household heads or an adult respondent present if the household head was not present. Information on pre-natal care, delivery and post-natal care was collected for all women aged 15 to 49 years. We also collected additional information on household characteristics, including ownership of assets, and GIS information on all communities and health facilities in the district.

The first follow-up survey collected additional information on general health and utilization of healthcare services, expected future health, enrollment in the NHIS and health behaviors for all household members. The second follow-up survey used an abbreviated questionnaire that collected information on knowledge of health insurance, current enrollment status, subjective and objective health outcomes in the past twelve months.

Design details

Randomization method
Assigning the treatment to communities in which individuals reside is done randomly by a computer random number generator. Households were not aware of this randomization. It remains unknown to them even after receiving interventions.
Randomization unit
Communities are randomly assigned to treatment and control groups. Households that live within communities in the treatment group are automatically included as treatment households. Similarly, households within control communities are included as control households. As for subsidy level intervention, randomization was conducted in household level. Households that reside within communities that received subsidy intervention were randomized to receive a particular subsidy level (1/3, 2/3, and full subsidy).
Clusters
60 communities.
Observations
4,625 individuals
Arms
1. Control group: 22 Communities, 167 Households, 1,174 Individuals. 2. Treatment group: 38 Communities, 476 Households, 3,541 Individuals. By treatment arms: 1. Subsidy only: 8 Communities, 102 Households, 706 Individuals. 2. Education only: 3 Communities, 32 Households, 268 Individuals. 3. Convenience only: 7 Communities, 126 Households, 906 Individuals. 4. Education and convenience: 5 Communities, 39 Households, 278 Individuals. 5. Subsidy and convenience: 7 Communities, 60 Households, 463 Individuals. 6. Subsidy and education: 4 Communities, 50 Households, 300 Individuals. 7. Subsidy and education and convenience: 4 Communities, 67 Households, 530 Individuals.
Primary outcomes
We are interested in several outcomes. First, determinants of enrollment and its sustainability to NHIS. We will explore whether individuals that received intervention enrolled more than those who did not receive intervention. We will differentiate three types of intervention: any intervention, multiple intervention, such as education, subsidy, and convenience, and each of seven interventions. An individual received any intervention if she received any of interventions, including standalone and multiple interventions. Multiple intervention means an individual received more than one intervention. An intervention received a multiple education intervention if she received either education and subsidy, education and convenience, or education and subsidy and convenience. Second, we measure causal effects of insurance coverage on utilization of health care, financial protection, and health outcomes. The measures for utilization of health care include whether an individual visited a health care facility in the last four weeks, in the last six months, visited a health care facility for malaria treatment in the last four weeks, and number of visits in the last six months. The measure for financial protection includes whether an individual made an out-of-pocket expenditure for health service in the last six months. Third, we also explore whether various heterogeneities among those who received intervention exist and affect insurance enrollment and its sustainability. We will measure heterogeneities based on illness and utilization of NHIS for illness or injury treatment. Heterogeneity measures for illness and utilization of NHIS for illness or injury treatment include the following measures that occurred in the last four weeks or six months: whether an individual got any illness, got any malaria episode, had limited ability to perform normal daily tasks, and visited a health facility.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords