Information, Participation and Deliberation: Experimental Evidence from Bangladesh
How to cite
Cocciolo, Serena; Habib, Ahasan; Tompsett, Anna; Ghisolfi, Selene. 2017. "Information, Participation and Deliberation: Experimental Evidence from Bangladesh." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0002333. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.2333-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
A key element of participatory development is the involvement of beneficiary communities in the decision-making process relative to the intervention. However, participation rates in community actions are typically low and participants are highly self-selected, with agents with higher vested interests or lower participation costs more likely to participate in the decision-making process. In this project, we study the determinants and consequences of participation and self-selection into community decision-making.
The project is conducted within a randomized controlled trial which offers rural Bangladeshi communities the opportunity to build a public source of safe water. The project process requires communities to take collective decisions over key features of the project at a public consultation meeting.
We conduct a randomized evaluation of the impact of sending SMS reminders about the time and location of the public meeting on the number and characteristics of participants in the decision-making process; on meeting dynamics; on the results of the deliberation process; on the resultant effect on drinking water quality. Among those communities where households are reminded via SMS about the community meeting, we vary the content of the reminder. Half the households receive a message designed to prime participants to consider access to safe water as a collective problem; half receive a message framing access to safe water as an individual problem.
In our empirical analysis, we will first provide a detailed description of the characteristics of households that participated in the community meetings. We will exploit the experimental variation in order to evaluate: (i) the impact of sending SMS-reminders; (ii) whether the effects vary with the content of the information included in the SMS.
Intervention
The project is conducted within an arsenic mitigation program implemented in rural Bangladesh. Key aspects of the program are decided by unanimous consensus during community meetings open to the whole community.
We evaluate the impact of an SMS reminder initiative on the number and characteristics of attendees at the community meeting, and how these effects vary with the content of the SMS.
We randomize communities across three SMS-treatments:
(i) No SMS;
(ii) SMS with individual-level information: reminder on the date, hour and location of the community meeting, plus a reminder on the arsenic and bacteria contamination level of the household’s water source;
(iii) SMS with community-level information: reminder on the date, hour and location of the community meeting, plus information on the share of arsenic- and bacteria-contaminated water sources in the community.
Experimental design
We conduct our main study in 171 communities eligible for receiving the arsenic mitigation program. The mean community size is 153 households. We selected communities for inclusion based on their baseline level of arsenic contamination: (i) communities where more than 25% of sources of drinking water are arsenic-contaminated; (ii) or communities where arsenic-contaminated water sources are geographically concentrated in few clusters. We randomly select 129 communities for receiving the program. Treated communities are further divided across three requirements for co-funding the installation costs: no contributions; cash contributions; labor contributions.
Before the implementation of the arsenic mitigation program we collected baseline data in all communities. We conducted a census of all sources of water used for drinking or cooking. We also randomly selected 40 households per community for an in-depth household survey.
As part of the baseline water source census, we offered a water quality testing program. 99.9% of water source owners or caretakers agreed to participate in the water source testing program. We also requested water source caretakers or owners to share their phone numbers with project staff. We used their phone numbers at baseline to send automatically generated SMS messages with the results of the water quality tests.
We used the phone number of caretakers of water sources tested at baseline in order to implement our SMS treatments. Water source owners are not a random selection of the population of households, but in our context, on average 71% of households own a water source. As a result, the sample of water source owners generally represents a large majority of the households in most communities. We also requested water source owners to share the message with other households who use their water sources, meaning that the reminders should have reached a large majority of households in the treatment unit.
In communities selected for the SMS-treatments, we send two reminders. We sent one message at 7 pm the evening before the community meetings, and one message at 7 am on the morning of the day when the meeting was held. The English translation of the text of the SMS reads:
1) Individual information treatment: “Hello {name}. You are welcome to attend the community meeting organized by NGO Forum for Public Health today/tomorrow in your community, {location}, at {time}. Your participation is important! Remember, your tubewell tested bacteria contaminated/not-contaminated and arsenic positive/negative! Please share this message with households who share your tubewell.”
2) Collective information treatment: “Hello {name}. You are welcome to attend the community meeting organized by NGO Forum for Public Health today/tomorrow in your community, {location}, at {time}. Your participation is important! Remember, of water sources in your community {share}% are bacteria contaminated and {share}% are arsenic contaminated! Please share this message with households who share your tubewell.”
Our design allows us to perform two sets of tests in order to evaluate: (i) the impact of sending SMS-reminders; (ii) whether the effects vary with the content of the information included in the SMS.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.