Making People Pay their Debts: The role of salience, information, and computational costs in a tax amnesty
How to cite
Scartascini, Carlos; Castro, Edgar. 2017. "Making People Pay their Debts: The role of salience, information, and computational costs in a tax amnesty." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0002329. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.2329-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
This document describes the pre-analysis plan of a set of interventions that will take place in the city of Santa Fe, Argentina. In these interventions we will evaluate the role that messages play on the probability that taxpayers will cancel their debt with the Tax Administration by subscribing to a payment plan in the context of a tax amnesty. The interventions are the following. First, a group of recent debtors -debt less than five years old- will be divided into 3 groups. The control group will receive the old notification. Treatment one will receive a new notification that is more colorful and presents easy to follow descriptions of the payment plans. Treatment 2 will receive the new notification but including the computation of interests saved under each one of the payment plans also. The second intervention has been designed for those who have older debt that is close to prescribing. These taxpayers will be divided into two groups, one receiving the old notification and one receiving the new notification, including the analysis of savings. With these interventions we plan to evaluate the role of messages, salience, and information on debt payment, on the selection of a payment plan, and on compliance with current tax obligations (spillover). While there are several recent field experiments looking at the role of messages on tax payment, there is no evidence for this in the context of a tax amnesty. Moreover, even though it has long been considered that reducing transaction and informational costs should be a relevant policy instrument, there is little to no evidence about the role that reducing the costs of understanding the specifics of a payment plan could have on tax payment and compliance behavior.
Intervention
The field experiment consists on two interventions. The first intervention includes those taxpayers who have accumulated debt in some or all periods between January 2013 and March 2017. This group of taxpayers was randomly split into three groups. The first group was assigned to a control or placebo. The placebo group will receive the old CDA, which includes a verbal description of each plan and the total due amount after discounting the corresponding amount of the one payment plan. As mentioned, this CDA has been in used for several years now and most taxpayers have grown accustomed to it. The Treatment 1 group will receive a new CDA that includes many of the improvements noted before: (i) it is more salient; it is printed in color; (ii) it includes a moral message; (iii) it explains better the different benefits and costs of each payment plan. The Treatment 2 group will receive a new CDA which also includes the amount of interests the individual is saving under each one of the plans. This information is personalized for each taxpayer.
The second intervention includes those taxpayers who also owe bills from January 2011 to December 2012. This period is relevant because absent any action from the government those debts would prescribe. Henceforth, before the debts are ready to prescribe the government sends those debts and taxpayers to judicial enforcement. This group of taxpayers was split into two groups. The first group, control or placebo group, receive the old CDA. The treatment group received a similar new CDA than treatment 2 above but including also a deterrence message highlighted in red. The message says (in Spanish) ``If you decide not to pay your outstanding debt, your account will be assigned to judicial enforcement''.
Every CDA includes a payment coupon that allows the taxpayer to make effective payment if she decides to make only one payment. Otherwise, the CDA informs the taxpayer the procedure to follow to subscribe to the plan and make the first payment.
Experimental design
From the universe of taxpayers, we removed those who had no debt and were not part of the interventions, and those who only owed some or all of 2017 bills (6,340 taxpayers). The reason to eliminate this group was that the status of these taxpayers is likely to change within the period of randomization and the intervention -they could have paid their debt. The total number of taxpayers in the experiment is 54,700.
Because we are working with a sample with a high degree of heterogeneity, we divided the sample into strata to facilitate the balance between treatment and control groups. The strata are made upon the taxpayer's average compliance for the period of interest (2011-2017), and whether they have or not outstanding debt originated in 2012 or before. The latter is a stratum by itself (Category 1). For the rest of taxpayers, we distributed them in strata according to tax compliance: Category 2 are those who paid less than 10\% of the bills; Category 3 are those who paid between 10\% and 90\% of the bills, and Category 4 are those who paid 90\% of the bills or more. In total we have four strata.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.